Mixed greens, carrots, baby tomatoes, hard boiled egg, cucumber, smokehouse bacon, and fresh corn
$8
0
Wedge Salad
Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, red onion, bacon bits, bleu cheese dressing and bleu cheese crumbles
$9
0
Kale Caesar
Crisp kale tossed with our housemade caesar dressing and reggiano croutons
$10
0
Grilled Chicken Chopped Greek Salad
Substitute giant grilled shrimp for $5.00. Tomatoes, red onion, cucumber, red pepper, green pepper, kalamata olives, parsley, feta and oregano. Tossed with olive oil and red wine vinegar and chopped.
$14
0
Grilled Mahi Kale Caesar Salad
With chicken. Fresh kale tossed with baby tomatoes, roasted red peppers, caesar dressing, and reggiano croutons
$15
0
Seared Togarashi Tuna
Seared sushi grade ahi tuna, spicy. Served with asian slaw
$17
0
appetizers
12 items
Fried Green Olives
Stuffed with creamy bleu cheese & served with fig jam
$6
0
Crab Stuffed Oysters
Baked with lemon aioli 3
$12
0
½ Dozen Chilled Oysters
$12
0
Conch Fritters
With cocktail & curry sauces
$12
0
Cracked Conch
Marinated in coconut milk. Served with wasabi aioli
$12
0
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
$12
0
Crispy Calamari
Served with zucchini spears, marinara & lemon aioli
$13
0
Hickory Grilled Artichokes
With remoulade
$14
0
Mussels Diablo
With alligator sausage
$15
0
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake
With pommery mustard
$17
0
Shrimp Kabang
Tossed in thai chili sauce
$17
0
Chilled Shrimp Cocktail
Giant shrimp
$17
0
Advertisment
vegetarian menu - appetizers
3 items
Fried Green Olives
Stuff ed with creamy bleu cheese & served with fig jam
$6
0
Grilled Avocado
Whole california avocado grilled and served with remoulade on the side
$7
0
Hickory Grilled Artichokes
With remoulade
$14
0
vegetarian menu - salads
3 items
Vegetarian House Salad
Mixed greens with cheese, tomato wedges, cucumber & croutons. No bacon
$8
0
Vegetarian Wedge Salad
1/4 head of iceberg lettuce, tomato wedges, red onion, and bleu cheese dressing no bacon. F inished with bleu cheese crumbles
$9
0
Caesar Salad
Crisp kale tossed with our housemade caesar dressing and reggiano croutons
$10
0
Advertisment
vegetarian menu - entrees
5 items
Grilled Caulifower & Fried Baked Potato
Start with a house salad, without bacon, and then continue on to a platter of hickory-grilled caulifl ower, and fried sweet potato or Idaho potato chunks on the side
$8
0
Grilled Mushroom Kabobs (2)
Mushrooms, carrots, green peppers, and onions grilled to perfection and served with rosemary-garlic roasted potatoes on the side
$11
0
Pasta Primavera
Fresh zucchini slices, sliced mushrooms, tomatoes, roasted red peppers, spinach, and basil sauteed in olive oil with a hint of garlic and white wine. Served over penne pasta. Vegan, but with re
$12
0
Vegetarian Columbo
Mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes, and fresh spinach sauteed in a creamy alfredo sauce and served over penne pasta
$13
0
Vegan Tomato Basil Pasta
Penne pasta tossed with fresh tomatoes, basil, white wine, and garlic. Finished with a hint of balsamic. Vegan, but with refi ned our
$13
0
desserts
5 items
Famous Key Lime Pie
Our most famous dessert, tart. Topped with meringue
$8
0
Molten Chocolate Cake
A warm molten center. Served with vanilla ice cream
$8
0
White Chocolate Creme Brulee
Served with fresh red berry compote
$8
0
Peanut Butter Pie
Served with housemade strawberry jam
$8
0
Famous Key Lime Pie - Whole Key Lime Pie To Go
$28
0
Advertisment
vegetarian menu - desserts
4 items
Key Lime Pie
Voted best in the upper keys. Topped with meringue
$8
0
White Chocolate Creme Brulee
Served with raspberry coulis
$8
0
Peanut Butter Pie
Served with housemade strawberry jam
$8
0
Chocolate Cake
Baked with a warm, so chocolate center. Served with whipped cream
$8
0
bread bowl soups
2 items
Lobster Bisque
$9
0
Clam Chowder
$9
0
featured beverages
4 items
Southern Belle
Bulleit small batch bourbon, triple sec, Pineapple juice and grenadine, shaken
$10
0
Nolets Citrus Fizz
Nolets finest, muddled lemons, simple syrup, club soda, and a splash of water
$10
0
Mango Coconut Mojito
Parrot bay coconut rum, mango, mint, lime, simple syrup, and a splash of lemon lime soda
$11
0
Bacon Old Fashioned
Bacon infused buffalo trace bourbon, vanilla maple syrup, orange wedge, bitters, and a splash of soda
$11
0
sandwiches & burgers
6 items
Cuban Sandwich
House roasted pork, ham, swiss cheese, pickle planks, mustard, and mayo served on pressed cuban bread
$11
0
Grilled Chicken & Avocado BLT
Grilled chicken breast, avocado, house smoked bacon & garlic aioli. Served on a ciabatta roll
$13
0
Hickory Grilled Ruthie Burger
Ground fresh daily. House ground sirloin, bacon jam, swiss & american cheese, and garlic aioli. Add house smoked onion garlic bacon for $2.00. Add a fried egg for $1.00
$13
0
Key Largo Fish Sandwich
Jerked fresh mahi topped with grilled onions and american cheese yes american cheese. Served on a kaiser
$15
0
Jerked Shrimp Club Croissant
Jerked shrimp, house smoked onion-garlic bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo
$15
0
Hot Tin Roof Fish Sandwich
Blackened mahi served on cuban bread with diced tomatoes, scallions, and shredded mozzarella. Wrapped in aluminum foil
$16
0
entrees
13 items
Bayou Pasta
Grilled chicken tossed in a cajun alfredo sauce and served over penne
$18
0
Ale Battered Fish & Chips
Substitute giant shrimp or fish and shrimp for $5.00. Key west sunset ale battered fresh mahi. Fried and served with fresh cut fries, cocktail & tartar sauces, and malt vinegar
$21
0
Steak & Seafood Kabobs
Grilled filet mignon tips, shrimp and scallops drizzled with garlic butter and served over orzo and wild rice
$22
0
Barbecued Baby Backs
House smoked baby back ribs. Glazed on the hickory grill with our housemade barbecue sauce
$23
0
Hickory Grilled Mahi Mahi
Simple grilled fresh mahi mahi. Served with sauteed spinach & kale, and your choice of a side
$26
0
Portugese Pan Roast
Clams, pulled pork, chorizo, calamari, and spinach sauteed in light stock with fresh rosemary
$28
0
Whole Yellowtail Snapper
Dusted in cornmeal and fried. Topped with housemade sweet thai chili sauce
$29
0
Yellowtail Fernando
Fresh snapper sauteed in garlic butter and topped with diced tomatoes, scallions, and jumbo lump crab
$29
0
Florida Lobster Tail
Broiled and served with herbed butter
$29
0
Seafood Paella
With alligator sausage. Shrimp, scallops & mussels sauteed in a spicy chicken stock. Served over a saffron risotto cake
$30
0
Key Lime Seafood
Lobster, shrimp, and blue crab sauteed in a key lime-tabasco butter with tomatoes and scallions. Served over orzo and wild rice
$32
0
Filet Mignon
Center cut beef tenderloin, seasoned and hickory grilled. Add a broiled florida lobster tail $18.00
$32
0
Smoked Sea Salt Cowboy Steak
Add a fried egg for $1.00. 22 oz. bone-in ribeye, dusted with housemade smoked sea salt and served with sherried tomatoes
View
Sundowners on the Bay's menu prices, nutrition, locations and coupons
Browse latest menu of Sundowners on the Bay's
sides Menu,
vegetarian menu - sides Menu,
salads Menu,
appetizers Menu,
vegetarian menu - appetizers Menu,
vegetarian menu - salads Menu,
vegetarian menu - entrees Menu,
desserts Menu,
vegetarian menu - desserts Menu,
bread bowl soups Menu,
featured beverages Menu,
sandwiches & burgers Menu,
entrees Menu,
Breakfast menu, Lunch menu and Dinner menu everything is included.
Sundowners on the Bay offers Sides, Vegetarian Menu - Sides & Salads across 84 menu items, with prices from $4.00 to $38.00. Browse the full Sundowners on the Bay menu with current prices — budget picks like the $4.00 Sweet Potato Wedges — updated August 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.
Suggestions are reviewed before they show publicly. Thanks for keeping deals fresh!
Reviewed before any change is made. Thanks for keeping menus accurate!
Spotted wrong info, or want this page updated or removed?
Contact us →
Opens your email app to [email protected] — we attach this page's link so we can reply faster.
Sundowners on the Bay Menu — Frequently Asked Questions
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the Sundowners on the Bay menu?
Sundowners on the Bay offers 84 menu items across seafood and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does Sundowners on the Bay food cost?
Menu prices at Sundowners on the Bay range from $4.00 for the most affordable options up to $38.00 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Sundowners on the Bay cheapest items guide.
What are the cheapest items at Sundowners on the Bay?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Sundowners on the Bay, visit the dedicated Sundowners on the Bay cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $4.00.