fresh seasonal stone crabs served with a garden salad and honey mustard
0
Red Conch Chowder
tomato base homemade conch chowder
$5.75
0
Smoked Fish Dip
fresh caught fish, smoked and blended into a creamy dip
$6.5
0
Calamari Rings
hand cut squid breaded and deep fried plain or italian served with homemade cocktail sauce
$7.95
0
Conch Fritters
the best fritters in town with lots of conch
$8.75
0
Buffalo Style Chicken Wings
chicken wings spiced with cayenne & sweetened with honey
$8.95
0
Peel And Eat Shrimp
local shrimp steamed daily with herbs and spices served hot or cold with drawn butter
$9.95
0
Seared Tuna
lightly seared tuna with sesame seeds served with wasabi and soy sauce
$12.95
0
salad
4 items
Rusty's Garden Salad
fish
0
Rusty's Garden Salad
$3.95
0
Rusty's Garden Salad
chicken
$8.95
0
Rusty's Garden Salad
shrimp
$9.95
0
Advertisment
sandwiches
13 items
Rusty's Fish
on cuban bread, fried, grilled, blackened or lemon peppered
0
Rusty's Fish
on cuban bread fried, grilled, blackened or lemon peppered
0
Ham And Cheese
on cuban bread, white, wheat or rye served hot or cold
$6.95
0
Original Cuban Mix
pork, ham, cheese, pickles, lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo & mustard
$8.75
0
Deep Blue Burger
10oz of angus beef with cheese and bacon
$9.5
0
The Gorilla Burger
10oz of angus beef with cheese and bacon
$9.5
0
Chicken
on cuban bread, fried, buffalo, grilled or blackened
$9.95
0
Sliced Roast Beef
sliced juicy rib eye on cuban bread, au jus & creamy horseradish sauce
$9.95
0
Chicken
on cuban bread fried, buffalo, grilled or blackened
$9.95
0
Fish Reuben
blackened fish with swiss cheese, sauerkraut and 1000 island dressing on rye bread
$10.95
0
The Gorilla Burger
10oz of angus beef, includes your choice of cheese, blue cheese, bacon & grilled onion
$10.95
0
Delmonico Steak
on cuban bread, with grilled onions
$11.95
0
Fried Conch
on cuban bread, sweet tender white conch seasoned and fried
$12.95
0
sandwiches - rusty anchor baskets
4 items
Fresh Fish
fried, grilled, blackened or lemon peppered
0
Clam Strip Fried
$7.5
0
Chicken Tenders Fried Or Buffalo
$7.95
0
Shrimp Fried Or Buffalo
$9.95
0
Advertisment
additional sides $1.50
4 items
Black Beans
0
Rice Or Cole Slaw
0
French Fries
0
Vegetable
0
dinner
8 items
Local Fish Of The Day
have your fish prepared pan fried, grilled, blackened, lemon peppered, broiled or deep fried
0
Florida Keys Spiny Lobster
fresh tender lobster, broiled or fried served with drawn butter
0
1lb Steamed Pink Shrimp
peel and eat served hot or cold with drawn butter
$17.5
0
BBQ Baby Back Ribs
full rack of barbecued ribs
$17.95
0
Key West Pink Shrimp
florida keys pink shrimp, fried, buffalo or sauteed
$18.95
0
Rusty's Famous Conch Steak
sweet tender white conch seasoned and fried
$19.95
0
Steak Delmonico
hand cut 16oz rib eye grilled to order
$21.95
0
Fried Captains Platter
conch fritters, fried shrimp, fried fish, calamari rings and fried clams served with french fries only
$24.95
0
Advertisment
specials
7 items
Soup Of The Day
0
Locally Caught Fish
the rusty anchor restaurant and seafood market est.1983. home of the florida keys freshest seafood. rusty anchor receives fresh local seafood daily. our in house seafood market is available for retai
0
Seared Tuna
lightly seared tuna with sesame seed served with wasabi and soy sauce
0
Sea Scallops
large excellent sea scallops sauteed, broiled or fried
0
Chef's Pasta Special
0
Seared Tuna
tuna appetizer
$12.95
0
Seared Tuna
tuna dinner
$18.95
0
wednesday night
3 items
Prime Rib Roast
center cut prime rib roast, prepared with rosemary and slow-roasted to perfection
0
Prime Rib Roast
queen cut
$22.95
0
Prime Rib Roast
king cut
$24.95
0
Advertisment
drink included with meal
5 items
Soda
0
Milk
0
Orange
0
Cranberry
0
Apple Juice
0
imports $5
10 items
Amstel
0
Becks
0
Becks Dark
0
Corona
0
Corona Light
0
Dos Xx
0
Heineken
0
Kalik
0
Kalik Gold
0
Red Stripe
0
premium $4.50
4 items
Blue Moon
0
Presidente
0
Sam Adams
0
Yuengling
0
beer $4
6 items
Bud
0
Bud Light
0
Coors Light
0
Miller Lite
0
Michelob Ultra
0
O'doul's
0
flipflop wine by glass $6
8 items
Sauvignon Blanc
0
Pinot Grigio
0
Chardonnay
0
Pink Moscato
0
Pinot Noir
0
Cabernet
0
Merlot
0
House Whit Zinfandel
0
...
7 items
Black Beans & Rice
$1.5
0
Grilled Cheese & Fires
$4.95
0
Chicken Fingers & Fries
$5
0
Ham And Cheese Sandwich & Fries
$5.5
0
Mini Fish Bites & Fries Basket
$5.95
0
Cheese Burger & Fries
$5.95
0
Mini Shrimp & Fries Basked
$6.95
0
coffee drinks
9 items
Espresso
$2
0
Cappuccino
$4
0
Italian Coffee
amaretto & coffee
$6.5
0
Swiss Coffee
peppermint schnapps & creme de cacao
$6.5
0
Plain Shot Of Frangelico
$7
0
Coffee Royale
baileys & brandy
$7.5
0
Keoki Coffee
kaluha & brandy
$7.5
0
Jamaican Coffee
tia maria & rum
$7.5
0
Hot Fisherman
frangelico, baileys & coffee
$8.5
0
dessert
7 items
Chocolate Or Vanilla Ice Cream
$2.5
0
Vanilla Or Chocolate Ice Cream
topped with your choice of chocolate syrup or strawberries & whipped cream
$3.5
0
Key Lime Pie
homemade key lime pie fresh from the keys to your table
$4
0
Apple Pie A La Mode
warm apple pie with vanilla ice cream drizzled with caramel
$4.5
0
Pecan Pie
traditional pecan pie with vanilla ice cream & whipped cream
$4.5
0
Supreme Cheese Cake
vanilla cheese cake served with strawberries or caramel topping & whipped cream
$5
0
Fudge Dark Chocolate Pie
dark thick mousse with a toffee center served with vanilla ice cream & whipped cream
$5.5
0
special drinks
20 items
Cuba Libre
don quba rum & coke
$6
0
Wild Cherry Lemonade
stoli wild cherry vodka, cranberry, pink lemonade & splash of sierra mist
$6.5
0
Dark & Stormy
coruba dark rum & ginger beer
$6.5
0
Rusty's Rum Punch
bacardi rum light & dark & fruit juice
$6.5
0
Strawberry Daiquiri
$6.5
0
Pina Colada
$6.5
0
Espresso Martini
van gogh espresso vodka, dash of real espresso & kahlua
$7
0
Flying Cosmo Martini
citrus vodka, triple sec, & splash cranberry &lime juice
$7
0
Peach Martini
absolute peach vodka, peach puree, peach schnapps with a sugar rim
$7
0
Salted Carmel Martini
stoli salted caramel vodka & apple juice, rimed with cinnamon sugar
$7
0
Vanilla Martini
absolute vanila vodka dash of tuaca
$7
0
Ocean Dream
absolute vodka, coconut rum & a splash of pineapple
Rusty Anchor serves Appetizers, Salad & Sandwiches across 127 menu items, with prices from $1.50 to $24.95. See the full Rusty Anchor menu with current prices — budget picks like the $1.50 Black Beans & Rice — updated August 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.
Suggestions are reviewed before they show publicly. Thanks for keeping deals fresh!
Reviewed before any change is made. Thanks for keeping menus accurate!
Spotted wrong info, or want this page updated or removed?
Contact us →
Opens your email app to [email protected] — we attach this page's link so we can reply faster.
Rusty Anchor Menu — Frequently Asked Questions
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the Rusty Anchor menu?
Rusty Anchor offers 127 menu items across seafood and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does Rusty Anchor food cost?
Menu prices at Rusty Anchor range from $1.50 for the most affordable options up to $24.95 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Rusty Anchor cheapest items guide.
What are the cheapest items at Rusty Anchor?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Rusty Anchor, visit the dedicated Rusty Anchor cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $1.50.
Is Rusty Anchor good value for money?
Rusty Anchor holds a customer rating of 4/5 based on 122 reviews. To judge value more accurately, compare Rusty Anchor side-by-side with similar restaurants: Rusty Anchor vs Buck's or Rusty Anchor vs Mariner's.
How does Rusty Anchor compare to similar restaurants nearby?
Rusty Anchor serves seafood cuisine alongside similar restaurants like Buck's, Mariner's, Shell's. Use our comparison pages to see a direct price-by-price breakdown: Rusty Anchor vs Buck's, Rusty Anchor vs Mariner's.