Skip to content
M

Mystic Fish Menu

Prices, calorie guide, and order-online options in one place

3 103 ratings
224 items
$2.00 from
seafood category Add photos
Coupons Order Online

Advertisment

Menus change often, so please confirm prices at the restaurant. Know a current price? Use the report option on any item to help keep this menu accurate.

224 dishes From $2.00 – $190.00

eventide drink specials

4 items

$5 Bar & High Top Specials

0

Domestic, Import and Hand Crafted Beers $1 off

0

House Wine, Copper Ridge

$2.75
0

Well Cocktails

$2.75
0

single malt scotch

15 items

Aberlour

0

Laphroaig

0

Balvenie Single Barrel 12 yr.

0

Macallan 12 yr

0

Macallan 18 yr

0

Glenfiddich

0

Glenlivet

0

Cognac

0

Courvoisier VSOP

0

Hennessey Paradis

0

Hennessey VS

0

Remy Martin XO

0

Remy Martin 1738

0

Remy Martin VSOP

0

Martell Cordon Blue

0

Advertisment

the list

3 items

Hendricks Cucumber Gimlet

hendricks gin, muddled cucumber, fresh lime juice & agave nectar.

0

Limoncello Martini

positano imported limoncello, boyd & blair vodka, lemon juice, & agave nectar.

0

White Tsunami

pinnacle pineapple vodka, triple sec, & white cranberry juice.

0

beers of the world

1 items

Three Taps of American Hand Crafted Draft Beer

0

Advertisment

bottled

16 items

Laqunitas, Little Sumpin' Sumpin' Pale Ale

0

Blue Moon Belgium White, Wheat Ale

0

Bucklers, NA

0

Heavy Seas, Small Craft Warning, Uber Pilsner

0

Coors Light

0

Corona Extra

0

Heineken, Lager

0

Michelob Ultra

0

Victory, Hop Devil, IPA

0

Sam Adams Boston Lager

0

Harpoon, IPA

0

Stella Artois, Pale Lager

0

Avery Brewing, "Ellie" American Brown Ale

0

New Belgium, Fat Tire, Amber Ale

0

Brooklyn Brewery, Lager

0

Yuengling, Amber Ale

0

specialty drinks

10 items

White Tsunami

van gogh pineapple infused vodka, triple sec & white cranberry juice

0

10 Cane And Tonic

10 cane rum, tonic, fresh lime & agave nectar on the rocks

0

Pomegranate Margarita

patron tequila, triple sec & pure pomegranate juice

0

Twisted Arnold

fire fly sweet tea vodka & fresh squeezed lemonade on the rocks

0

Agave Rita

margaritaville tequila, fresh lime & agave nectar on the rocks. the classic or with seasonal fresh fruit

0

Pearadise

absolut pear vodka, raspberry liquor, pineapple & orange juice

0

Mojito

mt. gay silver, mint, fresh lime & agave nectar on the rocks. the classic or with seasonal fresh fruit

0

Double Espresso Martini

van gogh double espresso, fresh espresso, godiva dark, dark crème de coca

0

Mystic Metropolitan

sky ginger vodka, citron, cranberry & fresh lime

0

Lemon Chill

van gogh citron, triple sec & fresh squeezed lemonade

0

Advertisment

salads

4 items

Caesar

romaine, anchovy, parmesan, fried tortilla crisps

$2
0

Mystic Field Green Salad

$3
0

The Iceberg

iceberg lettuce, blue cheese dressing, crispy pancetta

$4
0

Spinach & Field Green

miso vinaigrette, candied walnuts, dried apricots, gorgonzola

$4
0

sides

6 items

Mashed Potatoes

$2
0

Rice

$2
0

Fries

$3
0

Sauteed Spinach

$4
0

Vegetable

$4
0

Steamed Broccoli

$4
0

Advertisment

drinks

2 items

Espresso

$2.5
0

Cappuccino / Latte

$3.75
0

the sweet finish

8 items

Flourless Chocolate Cake

$2.75
0

Key Lime Panna Cotta

$2.75
0

Espresso Pots de Creme

$2.75
0

White Chocolate Bread Pudding

$2.75
0

Crème Brulee

$2.75
0

French Vanilla Ice Cream

$2.75
0

Gourmet Ice Cream

$2.75
0

Gelato

$2.75
0

soups

3 items

Mystic Soup

$5
0

Bermuda Fish Chowder

dark rum and sherry pepper sauce

$6
0

Lobster Bisque

$7
0

portts and dessertt wiines

3 items

Croft, 10 yr Tawny

$5
0

Fonseca “Bin 27”

$7
0

Taylor Fladgate, 20yr

$11
0

salad add ons

3 items

Chicken (6oz.)

$6
0

Grilled Shrimp (5)

$9
0

Salmon ( 6 oz.)

$10
0

sparkling

4 items

Zonin, Prosecco, Italy, 187ml, NV

$6
0

Korbel, Brut, California, 187ml, NV

$8
0

La Perlina, Moscato, Italy, 750ml, NV

$28
0

Veuve du Vernay, Brut, France 750 ml.

$28
0

wines by the glass

13 items

LaRoche, La Chevaliere, Sauvignon Blanc, France

$7
0

Banfi, Le Rime, Pinot Grigio, Veneto,

$7
0

Wente, Morning Fog, Chardonnay,Livermore Valley, CA

$8
0

SA Prum, Essence, Riesling, Mosel

$8
0

Santa Julia Reserv, Malbec, Mendoza

$8
0

Mystery, Pinot Noir, Monterey

$9
0

Maso Canali, Pinot Grigio, Trentino-Alto Ridge

$10
0

Wente, Sandstone Merlot, Livermore Valley, CA

$10
0

Kunde, Zinfandel, Sonoma Valley,

$10
0

Coppola Diamond Claret, Cabernet Sauvignon

$10
0

Clos Pegase, Mitsuko's Vineyard, Chardonnay, Carneros

$12
0

Byron, Pinot Noir, Santa Barbara

$12
0

Hess, Shirtail ranches, Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa

$13
0

dessert wiine

4 items

Espresso Martini

$8
0

Half Baked Martini

vanilla vodka, white crème de cacao, frangelico, kahlua, chocolate cookie rim

$8
0

Justin “Obtuse”

$33
0

Quady “Essensia”

Orange Muscat

$36
0

small plates

20 items

Pork & Vegetable Pot Stickers

truffled teriyaki sauce, dried figs and green onion

$9
0

Herbed Goat Cheese Spring Roll

fig balsamic glace with artichoke tapenade

$9
0

Calamari Fries

roasted red & banana curry pepper aioli

$9
0

Asian BBQ Boneless Short Ribs

ginger soy bbq with wakami salad and pickled ginger

$9
0

Maine Lobster Roll

Add Lobster Bisque $3 Half $9 Whole $17

$9
0

Prime Burger

caramelized onions, Wisconsin cheddar and steak fries

$10
0

Prince Edward Island Mussels

olive oil, wine, garlic broth, red peppers, leeks & chorizo

$10
0

Escargot "Mystic Style"

garlic, red wine - curry infused butter

$10
0

Grilled Shrimp

spice rubbed, grilled with a roasted onion aioli

$10
0

Shrimp Cake

with grapefruit remoulade

$11
0

Lobster "Escargot Style"

maine lobster meat in a garlic - parsley butter

$11
0

Crab Stuffed Artichoke Bottoms

crab meat, parmesan, cream cheese and scallions

$11
0

Grilled Octopus

extra virgin olive oil, lemon, feta, tomato & kalamata olives

$11
0

Togorashi Seared Yellowfin Tuna

seared rare, ponzu, wasabi, wakame and pickled ginger

$12
0

Seared Sea Scallops

arugula, strawberry, truffled feta, scallions, lemon & honey

$12
0

Cheese Plate

four unique cheeses with toast, dried fruit, and fig sauce

$12
0

Steak Tartare

miso yolk, fried capers, scallions, anchovy, truffle oil, and red chile threads

$13
0

Vegetable Plate

vegetables prepared in several different styles

$13
0

Jumbo Lump Crab Martini

field greens with dijon - madeira sauce

$14
0

Petite Filet

melted gorgonzola, lobster meat and herb garlic butter

$16
0

early dinners

7 items

Shrimp Cake

served on a grapefruit remoulade

$14.75
0

Kona Crusted Salmon

finished with a pistachio dill pesto

$14.75
0

Shrimp and Pasta

Chefs preparation

$14.75
0

Sauteed Chicken Francaise

Lite egg batter, white wine, capers and lemon

$14.75
0

Braised Boneless Short Ribs

finished with a Madeira demi glace

$14.75
0

Breast of Chicken "Valencia"

pan seared, baked in a Spanish vegetable-saffron broth with sweet peas and fresh orange

$14.75
0

Pan Seared Cod

finished with a lemon butter sauce

$14.75
0

champagne

3 items

Moet, Imperial, France, N/V, 187ml

$15
0

Moet, Imperial, France, N/V

$68
0

Taittinger, La Francaise, Brut, France, N/V

$72
0

additional entrees (sample entrees)

5 items

Seared Sea Scallops

Chef's preparation

$15.75
0

Filet Mignon

cooked to your liking

$17.5
0

Half Rack of Lamb

served on a Guiness- Dijon demi

$17.75
0

Maine Lobster Tail

served with drawn butter

$17.95
0

Bouillabaisse

shrimp, scallops, mussels, clams and assorted fish in a saffron vegetable broth

$17.95
0

signature dishes

14 items

Sauteed Chicken "Francaise"

lite egg batter, white wine, capers and lemon

$16
0

Braised Boneless Beef Short Ribs

Madeira- miso demi glace or Asian BBQ style

$17
0

Kona Seared Atlantic Salmon

pistachio dill pesto

$17
0

Prairie Fresh Prime Pork Loin Chop

Montreal seasoned served with horseradish cream sauce

$17
0

Maple Leaf Duck Breast

apricot curry sauce with sliced strawberry

$21
0

Shrimp & Scallop Ravioli

truffle ricotta ravioli with porcini mushroom sauce

$22
0

Maine Lobster Tail (6 oz)

broiled with drawn butter

$22
0

Mystic Paella

chicken, shrimp, clams, mussels, chorizo, saffron, orzo (can be prepared without poultry and chorizo if desired)

$23
0

Iowa Beef Tenderloin

$23
0

Bouillabaisse

lobster, shrimp, scallops, mussels, clams, assorted fish in saffron broth

$25
0

Bronzed Chilean Sea Bass

lightly blackened served with a ginger - soy hijiki sauce

$27
0

Choice Rib Eye

kona & spice crusted served with horseradish sauce

$27
0

Choice New York Strip (Center Cut)

All of our steaks are seasoned with salt and pepper, seared on cast iron to seal in the juices, then brushed with butter. We are not responsible for any menu items cooked medium well or well done

$28
0

New Zealand Rack of Lamb

Dijon-guiness demi - glace

$34
0

great whites

5 items

Tariquet, Classic, White Blend, France

$24
0

SA Prum, Essence, Riesling, Mosel

$28
0

Sauvion, Vouvray, Loire Valley

$30
0

St. Supery, Virtu, White Blend, Napa

$45
0

Sauvion, Sancerre, Loire Valley

$48
0

sauvignon blanc

4 items

LaRoche. La Chevaliere, France

$25
0

Ferrari Carano, Fume Blanc, Sonoma

$35
0

Jackson Estate, Stich, Marlborough, NZ

$40
0

Illumination, Napa

$52
0

pinot grigio

3 items

Banfi, Le Rime, Veneto

$25
0

Maso Canali, Trentino-Alto Adige, Italy

$35
0

J Vineyards, Pinot Gris, California

$36
0

chardonnay

11 items

Wente, Morning Fog, Livermore,

$28
0

Clos Pegase, Mitsuko's Vineyard, Carneros

$32
0

Chamisal, Un Oaked, Central Coast

$35
0

K J, Grande Reserve, Santa Barbara

$42
0

Louis Jadot, Pouilly Fuisse, France

$47
0

Rombauer, Carneros

$52
0

Jordan, Russian River

$54
0

Moillard - Grivot, Mercurey, Cjalonnaise, France

$56
0

Cakebread, Napa

$60
0

Paul Hobbs, Russian River

$63
0

Kistler, Les Noisetiers, Sonoma Coast

$64
0

snappen reds

11 items

Santa Julia Reserve, Malbec, Mendoza

$28
0

Kunde, Zinfandel, Sonoma Valley

$35
0

Ben Marco, Malbec, Mendoza

$39
0

Chat. Graves de Rabion, Bourdeaux, St Emilion

$42
0

Tower 15, The Swell, Rhone Blend, Paso Robles, 10

$46
0

Four Vines, "Biker", Zinfandel, Paso Robles

$48
0

Les Cadran, De Lassegue, Grand Cru, St. Emilion

$50
0

Atalon, Pauline's Cuvee, Blend, Napa

$50
0

Seghesio, Zinfandel, Sonoma

$50
0

Saldo, Zinfandel, Napa

$50
0

The Prisoner, red blend, Napa

$58
0

pinot noir

17 items

Mystery, Monterey

$32
0

Byron, Santa Barbara,

$42
0

Laetitia, Arroyo Grande Valley

$50
0

Louis Latour, Bourgogne, France

$52
0

Louis Latour, Bourgone, France

$52
0

David Bruce, Select, Sonoma

$55
0

Soter, North Valley, Oregon

$56
0

La Crema, Russian River

$58
0

Etude, Grace Benoist Ranch, Carneros

$58
0

Penner-Ash, Willamette Valley

$65
0

Elk Cove, Clay Court, Willamette Valley

$68
0

Cherry Pie, Staly Ranch

$72
0

En Route, Les Pommiers, Russian River

$73
0

AP Vin, Rosella's, Santa Lucia

$74
0

Three Sticks, Silver Eagle, Russian River

$75
0

Paul Hobbs, Russian River

$80
0

Kistler, Sonoma Coast

$90
0

merlot

2 items

Wente, Sandstone, Livermore Valley

$35
0

Markham, Napa

$50
0

cabernet sauvignon

9 items

Coppola Diamond, Claret

$35
0

Nadia, Santa Barbara, 12

$42
0

Hess, Shirtail Ranches

$45
0

St. Suprey, Napa, 11

$48
0

Hess, "Allomi Vineyards", Napa

$49
0

Charles Krug, Yountville -Napa

$50
0

Cedar Knoll, by Palmaz, Napa

$58
0

Sequoia Grove, Napa

$58
0

Turnbull, Napa

$60
0

italian

2 items

Castello Di Bolgheri, Varvara, Bordeaux

$50
0

Castello Di Bolgheri, Superiore, Blend

$80
0

cabernet sauvignon & blends

12 items

Michael David, Inkblot, Cab Franc, Lodi

$62
0

Michael David, Inkblot, Petit Verdot, Lodi

$62
0

Jordan, Alexander Valley

$65
0

Stags Leap Winery, Artemis, Napa

$67
0

Chappellet, Napa

$70
0

Cade, Napa

$75
0

Krupp Bros., Veraison, Stagecoach, Napa

$95
0

Caymus, Napa

$105
0

Stag

$135
0

Decades Five, Petit Verdot, Stagecoach, Napa

$140
0

Chappellet, Pritchard Hill, Napa

$160
0

Caymus, Special Selection, Napa

$190
0
View Mystic Fish's menu prices, nutrition, locations and coupons

Browse latest menu of Mystic Fish's eventide drink specials Menu, single malt scotch Menu, the list Menu, beers of the world Menu, bottled Menu, specialty drinks Menu, salads Menu, sides Menu, drinks Menu, the sweet finish Menu, soups Menu, portts and dessertt wiines Menu, salad add ons Menu, sparkling Menu, wines by the glass Menu, dessert wiine Menu, small plates Menu, early dinners Menu, champagne Menu, additional entrees (sample entrees) Menu, signature dishes Menu, great whites Menu, sauvignon blanc Menu, pinot grigio Menu, chardonnay Menu, snappen reds Menu, pinot noir Menu, merlot Menu, cabernet sauvignon Menu, italian Menu, cabernet sauvignon & blends Menu, Breakfast menu, Lunch menu and Dinner menu everything is included.

Restaurant Information

Categories:
seafood
Rating
3 (103 reviews)
Click on a star to rate this restaurant

About Mystic Fish

Mystic Fish offers Eventide Drink Specials, Single Malt Scotch & The List across 224 menu items, with prices from $2.00 to $190.00. Browse the full Mystic Fish menu with current prices — budget picks like the $2.00 Caesar — updated August 2026.

3 ★ · 103 reviews

Rate & review

Reviews are checked before they appear. Be honest & kind.

No reviews yet — be the first to review Mystic Fish.

Photos

No photos yet — add the first one.

Similar Binge-Worthy Restaurants

More budget-friendly fast food and value menu alternatives to Mystic Fish

See all →
B

Buck's

american · Binge-worthy picks
K

Key Colony Inn

italian · Binge-worthy picks
V

Vinnie's Lobster Bar

italian · Binge-worthy picks

Own Mystic Fish?

Claim it to update prices & details, post offers, and get a verified ✓ badge guests trust.

Free while we're in beta. Later a one-time $99 lifetime, then monthly plans — early claims stay free.

Claim this restaurant →
Spotted wrong info, or want this page updated or removed? Contact us →

Opens your email app to [email protected] — we attach this page's link so we can reply faster.

Mystic Fish Menu — Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.

What is on the Mystic Fish menu?
Mystic Fish offers 224 menu items across seafood and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.

How much does Mystic Fish food cost?
Menu prices at Mystic Fish range from $2.00 for the most affordable options up to $190.00 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Mystic Fish cheapest items guide.

What are the cheapest items at Mystic Fish?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Mystic Fish, visit the dedicated Mystic Fish cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $2.00.

Is Mystic Fish good value for money?
Mystic Fish holds a customer rating of 3/5 based on 103 reviews. To judge value more accurately, compare Mystic Fish side-by-side with similar restaurants: Mystic Fish vs Buck's or Mystic Fish vs Mariner's.

How does Mystic Fish compare to similar restaurants nearby?
Mystic Fish serves seafood cuisine alongside similar restaurants like Buck's, Mariner's, Shell's. Use our comparison pages to see a direct price-by-price breakdown: Mystic Fish vs Buck's, Mystic Fish vs Mariner's.