M
May St. Cafe Menu
Prices, calorie guide, and order-online options in one place
Prices may vary — please confirm at the restaurant before ordering.
From $2.50 – $50.00
Sort: Default
Price ↑
Price ↓
A → Z
Jump to category
soup $7.50 (2)
seafood (6)
specialties (3)
vegetarian options (3)
coffee (4)
sides (5)
desserts (6)
starters (5)
salad (2)
signature cocktails (5)
margaritas (3)
blanco (9)
rojo (4)
meat, steaks & chops (5)
allen brothers steaks (4)
Butternut Squash
cranberries and cream.
Sopa De Tortilla
grilled chicken, spicy tomato broth, avocado, sour cream.
Grilled Lobster Tail
chipotle garlic butter sauce, choice of mashed potato, organic vegetables.
Catch Of The Day
always something good. we'll let you know about today's special.
La Pina De La Playa De Puerto Rico
shrimp & scallop spanish fried rice made with chipotle coconut sauce, served in a half pineapple (can also be made vegetarian).
$20
Shrimp Diabla Pasta
tomato cream sauce and as devilish as you like - mild, medium or hot.
$22
Tilapia
pan seared, choice of mashed potato, mango tomatillo sauce.
$23
Wild Salmon Blackstone
tequila chipotle cream sauce, spanish rice & black beans.
$25
Cinnamon Chipotle Chicken Fajitas
Abuela Ines' Chicken Con Mole
chef lupe's mother's recipe. michoacan style with apricots, nuts, chocolate, three different types of peppers, pumpkin seeds & love.
$18
Yellow Squash
zucchini, portabello mushrooms, chipotle cream sauce. can also be made vegetarian.
$20
May St. Cafe Garden Specials
chefs mario and lupe enjoy gardening and occasionally the fruits of their labors make its way to our kitchen.
Portabello Mushroom
grilled portabello mushroom, wilted greens, sauteed organic seasonal vegetables with goat cheese.
$16
Chiles Rellenos A La Lupita
poblano pepper coated in an egg batter, stuffed with chihuahua cheese, covered in a rich michoacan tomato sauce.
$18
Jasmine Coconut Rice Or May St. Cafe Sofrito Rice
$4
Tostones
fried plantains.
$4.5
Potatoes
choice of potato: wasabi mash, chipotle mash, garlic mash, roasted new potatoes with may st. garden fresh herbs, yuca & sweet mash
$5.5
La Familia Navarro's Homemade Seasonal Ice Creams And Sorbets
$4
Mango Flan
with wild seasonal berries.
$6
White Chocolate Flan
with wild seasonal berries. chef art smith's favorite, "the best thing i ever ate" on food networks.
$6.5
Double Chocolate Lava Cake
served warm with natural vanilla ice cream.
$6.5
Pastel Tres Leches
three-milk chocolate cake with creme anglasie.
$7
Poached Pear Compote
$7.5
Quesadilla
french double cream brie & winter pears, may st. cafe chipotle sauce, a chicago magazine favorite choice.
$7
Queso Fundido
melted chihuahua cheese, spicy chorizo sausage, flour tortillas.
$7
Empanadas
oven baked argentine style allen brothers prime beef stuffed turnovers.
$7
Guacamole
chef lupe's secret recipe made to order.
$7.5
Escargot
crispy phyllo, garlic butter, seasonal berries.
$8.5
Evy's Spinach Salad
spinach leaves, goat cheese, avocado, pecans, red onions, balsamic.
$8
Chef's Salad
arugula, blue cheese, walnuts, warm sauteed apples, mango balsamic.
$8.5
Pina Colada
10 cane rum, fresh pineapple, coconut milk on the rocks.
$9
Strawberry Mojito
10 cane rum, muddled strawberries & limes, mint leaves, sugar, splash of soda.
$10
Citron Cosmo
belvedere citrus vodka, cranberry juice, fresh simple syrup.
$10
Mojito
10 cane rum, muddled limes and mint leaves, sugar, splash of soda.
$11
Margarita
los 3 garcias silver tequila, fresh simple syrup, fresh sour mix.
$9
Mango Margarita
los 3 garcias silver tequila, fresh simple syrup, mango puree, fresh sour mix.
$12
May Street Cafe Margarita
los 3 garcias reposado tequila, grand marnier liqueur, fresh sour mix.
$13
Bin Cava
100 segura viudas brut reserva, spain
$9
Bin Sauvignon Blanc
130 casa lopostolle '09, chile
$9
Bin Riesling
140 urban '08, germany
$9
Bin Chardonnay
150 napa station '07, napa valley
$10
Bin White Varietals
170 godello alma de blanco '08, spain
$10
Bin Sauvignon Blanc
131 jackson estate green lip '08, marlborough
$12
Bin Non-Vintage
111 veuve clicquot brut, reims
$14
Bin Pinot Grigio
160 livio felluga '08, friuli
$14
Bin Non-Vintage
110 moet et chandon imperial, epernay
$16
Bin Pinot Noir
200 samantha starr '06, monterey country
$9
Bin Malbec
220 keltehue '09, argentina
$9
Bin Cabernet Sauvignon
230 alto 3 reserve organic '07, argentina
$9
Bin Zinfandel
210 moss roxx ancient vine '05, lodi
$13
May St. Cafe Mexican Burger
10oz. allen brothers prime beef patty, chipotle ketchup, fresh crema, avocado, red onions & cilantro. served with yuca fries.
$15
Lechon Asado
slow cooked (go ahead, ask us how long) oven roasted pork marinated with mojo criollo puerto rican spices.
$21
Pork Chop
grilled boneless center cut pork loin chop, cilantro mango salsa, jasmine coconut rice, cuban black beans.
$22
Beef Tenderloin Skewers
beef skewers made with allen brothers prime beef tenderloin tips and seasonal vegetables, sofrito rice and black beans.
$24
Lamb Chops & Pesto Penne Pasta
french cut new zealand lamb chops, penne pasta tossed in a pesto cream sauce.
$25
View
May St. Cafe's menu prices, nutrition, locations and coupons
Browse latest menu of May St. Cafe's
soup $7.50 Menu ,
seafood Menu ,
specialties Menu ,
vegetarian options Menu ,
coffee Menu ,
sides Menu ,
desserts Menu ,
starters Menu ,
salad Menu ,
signature cocktails Menu ,
margaritas Menu ,
blanco Menu ,
rojo Menu ,
meat, steaks & chops Menu ,
allen brothers steaks Menu ,
Breakfast menu, Lunch menu and Dinner menu everything is included.
Restaurant Information
Rating
Click on a star to rate this restaurant
About May St. Cafe
May St. Cafe features Soup $7.50, Seafood & Specialties across 66 menu items, with prices from $2.50 to $50.00. Explore the full May St. Cafe menu with current prices — budget picks like the $2.50 Cafe — updated August 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.
No reviews yet — be the first to review May St. Cafe.
Similar Binge-Worthy Restaurants
More budget-friendly fast food and value menu alternatives to
May St. Cafe
See all
→
Own May St. Cafe?
Claim it to update prices & details, post offers, and get a verified ✓ badge guests trust.
Free while we're in beta. Later a one-time $99 lifetime, then monthly plans — early claims stay free.
Claim this restaurant →
Know a deal here? Suggest an offer →
Spotted a menu error? Suggest a correction →
Spotted wrong info, or want this page updated or removed?
Contact us →
May St. Cafe Menu — Frequently Asked Questions
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the May St. Cafe menu?
May St. Cafe offers 66 menu items across coffee and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does May St. Cafe food cost?
Menu prices at May St. Cafe range from
$2.50 for the most affordable options up to
$50.00 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the
May St. Cafe cheapest items guide .
What are the cheapest items at May St. Cafe?
For the lowest-cost meal options at May St. Cafe, visit the dedicated
May St. Cafe cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just
$2.50 .
Is May St. Cafe good value for money?
May St. Cafe holds a customer rating of
4/5 based on 173 reviews. To judge value more accurately, compare May St. Cafe side-by-side with similar restaurants:
May St. Cafe vs Taco Bell or
May St. Cafe vs Chipolte .
How does May St. Cafe compare to similar restaurants nearby?
May St. Cafe serves coffee cuisine alongside similar restaurants like
Taco Bell, Chipolte, Coffee Shop . Use our comparison pages to see a direct price-by-price breakdown:
May St. Cafe vs Taco Bell ,
May St. Cafe vs Chipolte .
Menu Insights
Cheapest Menu Prices
Find the cheapest item on May St. Cafe menu and low-cost meal options
View Cheapest Items
Calories & Nutrition Values
Compare low-calorie menu choices with source-tagged nutrition data at
May St. Cafe
Calories Breakdown
Plan Your Order
Open a calculator prefilled with May St. Cafe menu items — total your bill or track calories before you order
Compare Menu Prices
4 pairs
Advertisment
No menu items match your search criteria
0
Disclaimer: Menus and prices may vary from season and location.
Prices provided on this website are estimated and are for reference
only. Trademarks and logos of all the brands listed on
MenuXP
are the property of their respective owners. This website is not
associated with any of them.
MenuXP
© 2023-2026
MenuXP. All Rights Reserved.
