Yo Pauly's New York Pizza Co Menu

Old School Garlic Knots

Pizza dough tied in a knot and basted with olive oil, fresh garlic & spices. One dozen served with marinara sauce. Smother it with mozzarella for a little extra

Manhattan Meatballs

Three delicious meatballs in marinara sauce

Standard Antipasto

Genoa salami, ham, provolone cheese, tomatoes, olives, green peppers on a bed of mixed lettuce with balsamic vinaigrette

Jimmy the Greek

Mixed lettuce, feta cheese, tomoatoes, cucumbers, red onion, green peppers, kalamata olives & pepperoncinis

Chop Salad

Mixed lettuce, feta cheese, bacon, cucumbers, olives, tomatoes, served with our balsamic ranch dressing

Traditional House

Mixed lettuce, tomato, cucumber with black & green olives

Hail Caesar

Romain lettuce, croutons, & grated parmesan cheese with caesar dressing

Chinatown (Sweet & Spicy)

Buffalo (Medium Temp)

My Honey's BBQ (Sweet & Tangy)

Astoria (Lemon & Oregano)

Theo's Traditional Gyro

Beef and lamb thinly sliced then grilled to perfection. Topped with tomato, red onion and tzitziki sauce

The Mayor's Meatball Parmesan

Meatballs, marinara sauce, parmesan & mozzarella

Chelsea Chicken Parmesan

Breaded chicken cutlet, marinara sauce, parmesan & mozzarella

Goodfella's Eggplant Parmesan

Breaded eggplant, marinara sauce, parmesan & mozzarella

The Italian Job

Genoa salami, ham, provolone, cheese, spicy mustard & da works. Da works includes lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil, vinegar, salt & pepper

City Hall Chicken

Crispy chicken cutlet, mayo & da works. Da works includes lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil, vinegar, salt & pepper

Sonny's Spaghetti

A generous portion of meatballs with spaghetti & marinara sauce

Luigi's Lasagna

Delicious layers of lasagna noodles, sausage, ground beef, marinara sauce & ricotta cheese

Bensonhurst Baked Ziti

Penne pasta, ricotta cheese, our signature marinara sauce, parmesan & mozzarella cheese

Grandma's Chicken Parmesan

Breaded chicken cutlet, our signature marinara sauce, parmesan & mozzarella cheese. Served with penne pasta

Mama Leone's Eggplant

Breaded eggplant, our signature marinara sauce, parmesan & mozzarella cheese. Served with penne pasta

Cheese Louise

Keeping it original with mozzarella & our signature pizza sauce

Da Midtown Meltdown

Extra pepperoni & extra cheese

Margerita Village

Olive oil, garlic, a light touch of pizza sauce, sliced tomatoes, fresh basil & mozzarella

It's All Greek to Me

Garlic, feta & mozzarella cheese, sauce, fresh tomatoes, spinach, olive oil & topped with kalamata olives

Hawaiian Vacation

Smoked ham, pineapple & fresh basil

The Godfather

Garlic, ham, salami, provolone, mozzarella, sauce, pepperoncinis, olive oil & fresh basil

5 Burroughs Barbecue Chicken

Garlic & oil, BBQ sauce, mozzarella, red onions & of course, chicken

Whitestone Bridge

Our white pie with fresh garlic, ricotta cheese, mozzarella, fresh spinach, olive oil & sliced tomatoes

Madson Square Garden

Tomatoes, green peppers, onion, sauce, mozzarella, black olives & mushrooms

Ziggy's Favorite Za

Pepperoni, sausage, sauce, mozzarella & fresh basil

Wiseguy's Choice

Pick any 3 toppings

Melting Pot

Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, sauce, mozzarella, ham & bacon

The Big Apple

Sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, green peppers, sauce, mozzarella, onions & mushrooms

The New Yorker

Olive oil, garlic, sauce, mozzarella, eggplant & fresh basil

Times Square Sicilian Style

Turn any one of our 18" pizzas into a sicilian style - deep dish crust for an additional charge. 1/2 sicilian also available. Feeds 3-4

Pizza Toppings Selection

Anchovies, black olives, breaded eggplant, fresh basil, fresh garlic, extra cheese, fresh mushrooms, fresh spinach, fresh tomato, green peppers, ham, italian sausage, jalapenos, onions, pepperoni, pi

Ham It Up Calzone

Ricotta & mozzarella cheeses with lots a thin sliced ham

Little Italy Calzone

Ricotta & mozzarella cheeses with pepperoni & sausage

Tri State Calzone

Ricotta & mozzarella cheeses with choice of any 3 toppings

City Slickers Calzone

Ricotta & mozzarella with eggplant, tomato, mushrooms & fresh basil

Daily News Stromboli

Sausage, pepperoni & ham with mozzarella, rolled up like the daily newspaper

2 Cheese Slices

Any 2 Slices

Any 1 Slice, Garlic Knots (6)

Greek Salad, Any 1 Slice

Chop Salad, Any 1 Slice

Caesar Salad, Any 1 Slice

House Salad, Any 1 Slice

Stromboli

Pepperoni & Sausage Calzone

Aaron's Pasta

Penne pasta served with melted butter & a side of marinara sauce for dipping

Little Joey's Pizza

One slice of cheese pizza cut into bite sized pieces

Eddie's Spaghetti & Meatball

Kids' sized pasta with with marinara and one meatball

NY Cheesecake

World famous new york style cheesecake with cherry topping

Coney Island Cannolis

Mini cannoli shells filled with traditional italian cream & chocolate chips