Shelsky's Of Brooklyn Menu

Bottle of Poland Spring

Can of Seltzer

Can of Diet Coke

Dr. Brown's Soda

Fizzy Lizzy

Ashlawn Farm Coffee

Palais de Thes Tea

Bottle of Mexican Coke

Regata Ginger Beer

Abita Root Beer

Sprecher's Cream Soda

Fentiman's Soda

Mama Ilene's Coconut Macaroons

2 Pieces Raspberry Rugelach

2 Pieces Apricot Rugelach

2 Pieces Chocolate Lingonberry Rugelach

2 Pieces Clementine and Ginger Rugelach

Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt

Bag of five.

1 lb. Homemade Assorted Rugelach

Homemade Chocolate Babka

Homemade Honey Cake

Butter

Plain Cream Cheese

Scallion Cream Cheese

Horseradish Cream Cheese

Ben's All Natural Cream Cheese

Ben's All Natural Vegetable Cream Cheese

Olive Cream Cheese

Super Loxy Lox Cream Cheese

Egg Salad

Pickled Herring Salad

Smoked Bluefish Salad

Contains nuts.

Chopped Liver

Smoked Whitefish Salad

Baked Salmon Salad

Plain Cream Cheese

Scallion Cream Cheese

Lox Cream Cheese

Homemade Chopped Liver (Chicken Livers)

Smoked Bluefish Salad with Oranges, Fennel and Roasted Hazelnuts

Smoked Whitefish Salad

Baked Salmon Salad

Small House Pickled Herring with Cream Sauce and Onions

Small House Pickled Herring with Wine Sauce and Onions

Small French Oak Smoked Herring Fillets

Small Schmaltz Herring

Small Matjes Herring

The Fishless Sandwich

Tomato, pickled tomato, cilantro, jalapeno, red onion, apple horseradish sauce and mayonnaise served on a bagel or bialy.

The Holy Mackerel Sandwich

Smoked peppered mackerel, Ben's vegetable cream cheese and cucumber salad served on a toasted bialy.

Dr. Goldstein Special Sandwich

Duck fat-laced chopped liver and apple horseradish sauce served between two schmaltz fried potato latkes.

Member of the Tribe Sandwich

Gaspe nova, scallion or plain cream cheese. Served on a bagel or bialy.

The Spicy Red Sandwich

Baked salmon salad with roasted hazelnuts fennel and oranges, cucumber salad and Sriracha chili sauce, served on rye or pumpernickel.

The Spicy White Sandwich

Smoked whitefish salad with roasted hazelnuts fennel and oranges, cucumber salad and Sriracha chili sauce, served on rye or pumpernickel.

Spicy Blue Sandwich

Smoked bluefish salad with roasted hazelnuts fennel and oranges, cucumber salad and Sriracha chili sauce, served on rye or pumpernickel.

The Whitefish Club

Door county whitefish fillet, tomato, onion, jalapeno, cilantro and cream cheese on a bagel or bialy.

The Great Gatsby Sandwich

Pastrami cured salmon, honey mustard, horseradish cream cheese and red onion, served on caraway seeded rye.

Brooklyn Transplant Sandwich

Fatty kippered salmon, apple horseradish, cream cheese, pickled herring salad, served on pumpernickel or rye.

The Tribute Sandwich

Door county smoked whitefish salad, horseradish cream cheese, wasabi tobiko, served on a bagel or bialy.

Shelsky's Pastrami Sandwich

Pastrami salmon, mustard herring, Riesling braised sauerkraut, served on pumpernickel or rye.

Peter Shelsky Sandwich

Gaspe nova, sable, pickled herring with cream sauce and onion, scallion cream cheese. Served on bagel or bialy.

Brooklyn Native Sandwich

Gaspe nova, smoked whitefish salad, pickled herring, sour pickle, served on bagel or bialy.

The Fancy Pants Sandwich

Fatty lake sturgeon, house cured gravlax, Ben's cream cheese, tomato and red onion served on a bagel or bialy.

El Vincente Sandwich

Lake sturgeon, plain cream cheese, fresh jalapenos and heirloom tomato (sour pickle when tomato is out of season) served on bagel or bialy.

The $20 Smoked Salmon Sandwich

Ruby red wild Alaskan sockeye salmon, butter, red onion, served on a toasted bialy.

Hand Sliced New Brunswick Smoked Salmon for 2 People

Hand Sliced Gaspe Nova Smoked Salmon for 2 People

Hand Sliced Salty Belly Lox for 2 People

Hand Sliced Mild Scottish Salmon for 2 People

Hand Sliced Double-Cure Irish Organic Salmon for 2 People

Hand Sliced House Cured Gravlax for 2 People

Hand Sliced Wild King Salmon for 2 People

Hand Sliced Ruby Red Wild Alaskan Sockeye for 2 People

Whole Smoked Red Trout

Bering Cisco

Similar to chubs.

Whole Smoked Whitefish

Hand Sliced Smoked Sable for 2 People

Hand Sliced Fatty Lake Sturgeon for 2 People