Nutrition Breakdown

Pier 51 Calories — Lowest to Highest

Browse calorie values for Pier 51 menu items, with official nutrition where available and estimated calories for uncovered items. Updated August 2026.

Coverage

100%

Average Calories

177 kcal

Lowest Item

14 kcal

Highest Item

575 kcal

67 / 67 items resolved USDA database: 66 Estimated: 1

Lowest Calorie Items at Pier 51

Use this ranking to find lighter menu options quickly

Full menu →
# Item Category Source Calories
1 Calabash Shrimp senior citizens USDA 14 kcal
2 Calabash Shrimp fried shellfish selections USDA 14 kcal
3 Calabash Shrimp demetri's seafood platter USDA 14 kcal
4 Oyster Stew (Bowl) appetizers USDA 48 kcal
5 Cup of Soup & Salad Bar salad & soup USDA 58 kcal
6 Fresh Fillet of Ocean Perch all you can eat USDA 62 kcal
7 Crab Legs (Two Clusters) appetizers USDA 69 kcal
8 Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail appetizers USDA 75 kcal
9 Tilapia fried fish selections USDA 80 kcal
10 Flounder Fillet, Skin On fried fish selections USDA 88 kcal
11 Fresh Fillet of Flounder all you can eat USDA 88 kcal
12 Scallops fried shellfish selections USDA 89 kcal
13 Fantail Shrimp fried shellfish selections USDA 99 kcal
14 New England Clam Chowder appetizers USDA 106 kcal
15 Catfish Fillet fried fish selections USDA 110 kcal
16 Fresh Whole Catfish all you can eat USDA 116 kcal
17 Flounder demetri's seafood platter USDA 118 kcal
18 Perch Fillet fried fish selections USDA 118 kcal
19 Jumbo Shrimp fried shellfish selections USDA 119 kcal
20 Any Three Items combination platters USDA 121 kcal
21 Any Two Items combination platters USDA 121 kcal
22 Green Shrimp fried shellfish selections USDA 124 kcal
23 Green Shrimp billy's platter USDA 124 kcal
24 Broiled Canadian Skinless Flounder senior citizens USDA 128 kcal
25 Broiled Flounder Fillet daily specials - monday USDA 128 kcal
26 Senior Broiled Flounder Fillet senior citizens USDA 128 kcal
27 Grilled Chicken Breast senior citizens USDA 135 kcal
28 Fillet of Flounder and Deviled Crab billy's platter USDA 136 kcal
29 Fried Calabash Shrimp Deviled Crab & Flounder our everyday special USDA 136 kcal
30 Broiled Alaskan White Fish senior citizens USDA 143 kcal
Nutrition sync is temporarily paused Missing official items: 1

Highest Calorie Items

Top calorie-dense picks based on current nutrition data

Whole Catfish

fried fish selections 575 kcal

Alaskan White Fish

fried fish selections 470 kcal

Broiled Alaskan White Fish

daily specials - tuesday 390 kcal

Homemade Onion Rings

appetizers 385 kcal

Salad Bar Only

salad & soup 328 kcal

Similar Binge-Worthy Restaurants

Discover related spots for price and calorie comparisons

See all →
B

Buck's

american
K

Key Colony Inn

italian
V

Vinnie's Lobster Bar

italian

How Estimated Calories Are Calculated

When official nutrition is unavailable, calorie values are estimated using menu-item keywords and then adjusted by portion size. These values are directional for comparison, not medical nutrition advice.

  • Base estimate: item-name tokens (for example burger, fries, salad, pizza, shake) map to baseline calorie ranges.
  • Portion weighting: ounce and gram values adjust the estimate (about 8 oz = 1.0x, about 230 g = 1.0x), then the value is capped within a safe range.
  • Size modifiers: small/kids items apply a lower multiplier, while large/xl/family/double items apply a higher multiplier.
  • Final output: estimates are rounded to whole calories and shown as Estimated in the source column.

Pier 51 Calories — Frequently Asked Questions

Questions about calorie values, estimates, and nutrition coverage.

How many Pier 51 items have calorie data?
Pier 51 currently has calorie values for 67 of 67 menu items (100% coverage). We first use official nutrition sources when available, then apply estimation fallback for unresolved items.

What is the lowest-calorie item at Pier 51?
The lightest item currently tracked is Calabash Shrimp at approximately 14 kcal. Use the ranked table to find other low-calorie meal choices.

Are Pier 51 calorie values official or estimated?
This page uses a hybrid model: 66 items use USDA database estimates, while 1 items are algorithmic estimates. Both are directional for comparison, not medical guidance.

Where can I compare calories and prices together?
Use the Pier 51 full menu prices page for price-focused browsing and the cheapest menu items page for budget picks. This calories page is built for nutrition-first filtering.

How to Use This Calories Page

Use this page to compare low-calorie and high-calorie items quickly before ordering. Official values are used where available, and estimated values fill the coverage gap for broad menu discovery.

Estimated values are directional and may vary by location, preparation style, and serving size. For strict dietary planning, cross-check with the official restaurant nutrition statement when available.