*FRIED CHICKEN FINGERS; FISH FINGERS, GRILLED CHEESE OR HOT DOG
0
Fried Chicken Fingers
$8.95
0
Fried Clam Strips
$9.95
0
Fried or Grilled "Catch Of The Day"
$10.95
0
Fried Fish Burrito
Our Fish of the Day fried and wrapped in a flour tortilla with sour cream & topped with our homemade salsa & melted cheese
$10.95
0
Fried Calamari
$10.95
0
10 Oz. New York Strip Steak
(Certified Angus Beef)
$11.95
0
Fried Scallops
$12.95
0
Fried Shrimp
$12.95
0
Fried Coconut Shrimp
$13.95
0
Grilled Ahi Yellowfin Tuna
$14.95
0
homemade desserts
4 items
Now Featuring Homemade "Desserts by Nadia"
0
ALSO FRESH BAKED COOKIES
CHOCOLATE CHIP OR OATMEAL RAISIN
$1.5
0
Key Lime Pie
$3.75
0
Our Homemade Ice Cream Mud Pies
chocolate cookie crust, topped with chocolate sauce & whipped cream. choose from coffee, chocolate almond or chocolate chip
$3.75
0
Advertisment
check out our market
1 items
Check Out Our Market
certified angus beef, choice & prime steaks (rib eye, new york, tenderloin) pork, lamb, homemade sausage, freshest seafood around. we will cook your catch; smoke your catch; or ship your catch
0
drinks
3 items
Bottled Water
$1.25
0
Fresh Brewed Tender Leaf Iced Tea
$1.25
0
Fresh Roasted Whole Bean Millstone Coffee
$1.25
0
Advertisment
fountain soda
6 items
Coke
*Free refill with all fountain sodas
$1.75
0
Diet Coke
$1.75
0
Sprite
$1.75
0
Fruit Punch
$1.75
0
Raspberry Tea
$1.75
0
Pink Lemonade
$1.75
0
draft beer
6 items
Coors Light
$2.95
0
Fat Tire
$4.5
0
Key West Sunset Ale
$4.5
0
Paulaner Octoberfest Lager
$4.5
0
Tucker "Fest Bier"
$4.5
0
*our Beer of the Month
$4.5
0
Advertisment
bottled beer
8 items
Budweiser
$2.95
0
Bud Light
$2.95
0
Michelob Ultra
$2.95
0
Miller Light
$2.95
0
O'doul's
$2.95
0
Heineken
$3.95
0
Corona
$3.95
0
Corona Light
$3.95
0
soups & starters
12 items
Red Conch Chowder
$3.5
0
White Lobster Bisque
$3.5
0
Ceasar Salad
Add Grilled Chicken or Fish to either a Ceasar or Johnny's Salad
$4.95
0
Johnny's Salad
romaine with tomatoes, onions, croutons & our homemade Johnny's dressing (ranch, blue cheese & a little Italian mixed in)
$4.95
0
Fried Fish Fingers
$6.95
0
Our Smoked Fish Spread
$7.95
0
Conch Fritters
$8.95
0
Fried Calamari
$8.95
0
Buffalo Shrimp
$9.95
0
Dz. Steamed Clams
$9.95
0
1/2 # Steamed Shrimp
$10.95
0
Ahi Yellowfin Tuna
seared, sliced with seaweed salsa & wasabi sauce
$12.95
0
Advertisment
wines by the glass
4 items
Chardonnay
$4.5
0
Pinot Grigio
$4.5
0
White Zinfandel
$4.5
0
Cabernet
$4.5
0
our specialty sandwiches
7 items
Char-Grilled Burger
$4.95
0
1/4# All Beef Hot Dog
$5.95
0
Fried or Grilled Chicken Breast
$7.95
0
Fried, or Grilled "Catch Of The Day"
$8.95
0
Clam Po Boy
fried clam strips on a sub topped with our slaw
$9.95
0
Steak Sandwich
8oz. choice certified angus new york strip
$10.95
0
Grilled Ahi Yellowfin Tuna
$12.95
0
specialty sandwiches
4 items
Our "Bavarian Burger" & Fries
$8.95
0
Johnny's Rambler & Fries
fried dolphin on grilled swirled rye with melted american cheese, tomato, tartar
$9.95
0
German Fish Sandwich & Fries
fried dolphin on grilled swirled rye with cole slaw & melted muenster cheese
$9.95
0
George
grilled dolphin topped with sauteed mushrooms, onions & melted muenster cheese on our new pretzel roll
Fish Tales Market & Eatery serves Platters, Homemade Desserts & Check Out Our Market across 67 menu items, with prices from $1.25 to $14.95. See the full Fish Tales Market & Eatery menu with current prices — budget picks like the $1.25 Bottled Water — updated August 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.
Suggestions are reviewed before they show publicly. Thanks for keeping deals fresh!
Reviewed before any change is made. Thanks for keeping menus accurate!
Spotted wrong info, or want this page updated or removed?
Contact us →
Opens your email app to [email protected] — we attach this page's link so we can reply faster.
Fish Tales Market & Eatery Menu — Frequently Asked Questions
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the Fish Tales Market & Eatery menu?
Fish Tales Market & Eatery offers 67 menu items across sandwiches and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does Fish Tales Market & Eatery food cost?
Menu prices at Fish Tales Market & Eatery range from $1.25 for the most affordable options up to $14.95 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Fish Tales Market & Eatery cheapest items guide.
What are the cheapest items at Fish Tales Market & Eatery?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Fish Tales Market & Eatery, visit the dedicated Fish Tales Market & Eatery cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $1.25.
Is Fish Tales Market & Eatery good value for money?
