Costello Sandwiches & Sides on Sheffield Menu

Free Giant Cookie

Free giant cookie with any purchase of $20 or more.

Soda

Sprecher Soda

Nantucket Juice

Arizona Tea

Izze Soda

Vitamin Water Zero

Bottled Water

Apple Juice Box

Soup of the Day

Northwoods Chili

Chili Mac

Hummus, Cukes and Pita

Garlic Cheese Bread

Pizza Bread

Chicken Caesar Salad

Grilled chicken strips, crisp romaine lettuce diced tomatoes, black olives and tangy Caesar dressing tossed with finely grated Parmesan cheese. Simply delicious!

Antipasto Salad

Romaine lettuce, black olives and pepper rings tossed with classic Italian dressing and topped with capicola, Genoa salami and provolone cheese.

Southwest Chicken Salad

Grilled chicken strips with black bean-corn relish, tomato chunks, red peppers, romaine lettuce, cheddar cheese and jalapeno ranch dressing.

Garden Salad

How does your garden grown? Ours grows with lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, red peppers, onions, black olives and our classic vinaigrette!

Spicy Roscoe Sandwich

Pepper crusted turkey, capicola and pepper jack cheese on an Italian sub with pepper rings, lettuce, tomatoes, chipotle mayo and classic vinaigrette.

Spicy Roscoe Deluxe Meal

Pepper crusted turkey, capicola and pepper jack cheese on an Italian sub with pepper rings, lettuce, tomatoes, chipotle mayo and classic vinaigrette. Served with your choice of side and drink.

The Mess Sandwich

Genoa salami, capicola, ham, provolone cheese, French fries and coleslaw (yes, BOTH on the sandwich!) and tomatoes all on a sub roll. Try it!

The Mess Deluxe Meal

Genoa salami, capicola, ham, provolone cheese, French fries and coleslaw (yes, BOTH on the sandwich!) and tomatoes all on a sub roll. Try it! Served with your choice of side and drink.

Village Veggie Sandwich

Provolone cheese, Muenster cheese and hummus baked on multi-grain bread and topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, and black olives.

Village Veggie Deluxe Meal

Provolone cheese, Muenster cheese and hummus baked on multi-grain bread and topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers and black olives. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Costello Club Sandwich

Our triple decker/piled high with smoked turkey, tavern ham, jalapeno bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and garlic mayo on multi-grain bread.

Costello Club Deluxe Meal

Our triple decker/piled high with smoked turkey, tavern ham, jalapeno bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and garlic mayo on multi-grain bread. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Subpocalypse Sandwich

Our 2011 Sandwich Challenge Winner! Ciabatta sub roll topped with smoked turkey, ham, capicola, jalapeno bacon, cheddar and pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pepper rings and chipotle ra

Subpocalypse Deluxe Meal

Our 2011 Sandwich Challenge Winner! Ciabatta sub roll topped with smoked turkey, ham, capicola, jalapeno bacon, cheddar and pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pepper rings and chipotle ra

Southern Reuben Sandwich

Turkey pastrami and Swiss cheese baked (not grilled) on rye bread and topped with homemade coleslaw and 1000 Island dressing.

Southern Reuben Deluxe Meal

Turkey pastrami and Swiss cheese baked (not grilled) on rye bread and topped with homemade coleslaw and 1000 Island dressing. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Italian Grinder

Genoa salami, capicola, ham and provolone cheese baked on an Italian sub dressed with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pepper rings, classic vinaigrette and garlic mayo. Perfect!

Italian Grinder Deluxe Meal

Genoa salami, capicola, ham and provolone cheese baked on an Italian sub dressed with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pepper rings, classic vinaigrette and garlic mayo. Perfect! Served with your choice of

Roast Turkey Grinder

Roast turkey and provolone cheese oven-baked and topped with lettuce, tomatoes, pepper rings, garlic mayo and classic vinaigrette.

Roast Turkey Grinder Deluxe Meal

Roast turkey and provolone cheese oven-baked and topped with lettuce, tomatoes, pepper rings, garlic mayo and classic vinaigrette. Served with your choice of side and drink.

All Veggie Grinder

A whole wheat sub roll with hummus and provolone cheese oven-baked then dressed with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pepper rings and classic vinaigrette.

All Veggie Grinder Deluxe Meal

A whole wheat sub roll with hummus and provolone cheese oven-baked then dressed with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pepper rings and classic vinaigrette. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Parmesan Tuna Grinder

Homemade Parmesan tuna salad baked on a sub roll then topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pepper rings and classic vinaigrette.

Parmesan Tuna Grinder Deluxe Meal

Homemade Parmesan tuna salad baked on a sub roll then topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pepper rings and classic vinaigrette. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Smokin' Turk Sandwich

Smoked turkey breast and cheddar cheese baked on an Italian sub roll topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pepper rings and mayo.

Smokin' Turk Deluxe Meal

Smoked turkey breast and cheddar cheese baked on an Italian sub roll topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pepper rings and mayo. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Pepper Turkey Sandwich

Pepper crusted turkey and pepper jack cheese baked on an Italian sub with lettuce, tomatoes, pepper rings and chipotle mayo.

Pepper Turkey Deluxe Meal

Pepper crusted turkey and pepper jack cheese baked on an Italian sub with lettuce, tomatoes, pepper rings and chipotle mayo. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Chipotle Chicken Sandwich

Grilled chicken strips and pepper jack cheese baked on a sub roll with lettuce, tomatoes, pepper rings and mayo.

Chipotle Chicken Deluxe Meal

Grilled chicken strips and pepper jack cheese baked on a sub roll with lettuce, tomatoes, pepper rings and mayo. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Turkey Lite Sandwich

Roasted turkey baked on a whole wheat sub roll dressed with lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, low-fat chipotle mayo and low-fat Italian dressing.

Turkey Lite Deluxe Meal

Roasted turkey baked on a whole wheat sub roll dressed with lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, low-fat chipotle mayo and low-fat Italian dressing. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Horseradish Roast Beef Sandwich

Roast beef and provolone cheese baked on our muffuletta bread and dressed with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and our own horseradish sauce.

Horseradish Roast Beef Deluxe Meal

Roast beef and provolone cheese baked on our muffuletta bread and dressed with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and our own horseradish sauce. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Italian Meatball Sandwich

Delicious meatballs covered with rich marinara sauce and provolone cheeses baked on an Italian sub roll. That's it!

Italian Meatball Deluxe Meal

Delicious meatballs covered with rich marinara sauce and provolone cheeses baked on an Italian sub roll. That's it! Served with your choice of side and drink.

Beefsteak Grinder

Tender roast beef au jus and provolone cheese with sauteed onions and peppers baked on an Italian sub and topped with our roasted garlic mayo.

Beefsteak Grinder Deluxe Meal

Tender roast beef au jus and provolone cheese with sauteed onions and peppers baked on an Italian sub and topped with our roasted garlic mayo. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Tavern Ham and Swiss Sandwich

Premium smoked ham baked on our muffuletta bread with melted Swiss cheese dressed with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mayo and deli mustard.

Tavern Ham and Swiss Deluxe Meal

Premium smoked ham baked on our muffuletta bread with melted Swiss cheese dressed with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mayo and deli mustard. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Roast Turkey Foccacia

Tomato focaccia topped with roasted turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, roasted garlic mayo and classic vinaigrette.

Roast Turkey Foccacia Deluxe Meal

Tomato focaccia topped with roasted turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, roasted garlic mayo and classic vinaigrette. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Pesto Chicken Focaccia

Tender chicken breast, lettuce, tomatoes, classic vinaigrette, Parmesan cheese and provolone cheese topped with creamy pesto.

Pesto Chicken Focaccia Deluxe Meal

Tender chicken breast, lettuce, tomatoes, classic vinaigrette, Parmesan cheese and provolone cheese topped with creamy pesto. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Veggie Pizza Pie Focaccia

Our focaccia topped with marinara sauce, black olives, red peppers and red onions under provolone cheese.

Veggie Pizza Pie Focaccia Deluxe Meal

Our focaccia topped with marinara sauce, black olives, red peppers and red onions under provolone cheese. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Monterey Chicken Wrap Sandwich

Grilled chicken strips and pepper jack cheese baked in a chipotle tortilla wrap with pico de gallo, lettuce and chipotle mayo.

Monterey Chicken Wrap Deluxe Meal

Grilled chicken strips and pepper jack cheese baked in a chipotle tortilla wrap with pico de gallo, lettuce and chipotle mayo. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Southwest Veggie Wrap

Pepper jack cheese, fresh pico de gallo, red bell peppers, black olives, lettuce and chipotle mayo baked in our southwest chipotle tortilla.

Southwest Veggie Deluxe Meal

Pepper jack cheese, fresh pico de gallo, red bell peppers, black olives, lettuce and chipotle mayo baked in our southwest chipotle tortilla. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Parmesan Tuna Wrap

Homemade Parmesan tuna salad baked on a tortilla and topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pepper rings and classic vinaigrette.

Parmesan Tuna Wrap Deluxe Meal

Homemade Parmesan tuna salad baked on a tortilla and topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pepper rings and classic vinaigrette. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Turkey and Muenster Wrap

Roasted turkey, muenster cheese, tomatoes, lettuce, pepper rings and olives with chipotle mayo in a tomato basil tortilla.

Turkey and Muenster Wrap Deluxe Meal

Roasted turkey, muenster cheese, tomatoes, lettuce, pepper rings and olives with chipotle mayo in a tomato basil tortilla. Served with your choice of side and drink.

Costello's Value Meal

A sandwich and your choice of a small side, a regular soda and chips, pretzels or an apple.

Chipotle Mac and Cheese

A spicy hot mac and cheese made with chipotle peppers and rotini pasta.

Mashed Potatoes

Red skinned potatoes mashed with garlic, sour cream and butter (skins and all, chunky style).

Maryanne's Pineapple Tuna Salad

Shell pasta, tuna and juicy pineapple chunks mixed in a tasty mayo dressing, served chilled. A family holiday favorite!

Red Pepper Rotini Salad

Rotini pasta tossed with fresh red and green bell peppers, celery, cucumbers and a sweet and tangy dressing.

Mustard Potato Salad

Made fresh daily with eggs and just the right mix of mustard and mayo.

Creamy Cole Slaw

Old Fashioned Style! In a creamy celery dressing.

Peanut Butter and Jelly (Kid's Menu)

Cheese Pizza Boat (Kid's Menu)

Baked American Cheese (Kid's Menu)

Ham and Cheese (Kid's Menu)

Turkey and Cheese (Kid's Menu)

Home Rice Crispy Treat

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Double Chocolate Chip Cookie

White Chocolate Macadamia Cookie

Peanut Butter Cup Cookie