Soup of the day. Please contact restaurant for today's selection.
$4.49
0
Bowl of No. 16
Wisconsin beer cheese soup.
$5.49
0
Cup of No. 18
Green Bay style chili. Our Secret recipe of seasoned beef and red beans served over spaghetti. Add shredded Cheddar, onion and sour cream at no extra charge.
$6.79
0
Bowl of No. 17
Soup of the day. Please contact restaurant for today's selection.
$6.79
0
Bowl of No. 18
Green Bay style chili. Our Secret recipe of seasoned beef and red beans served over spaghetti. Add shredded Cheddar, onion and sour cream at no extra charge.
$9.59
0
Advertisment
desserts
3 items
Slice of Apple Pie
Made by the FFA of Randolf, WI. All proceeds benefit FFA program.
$4.09
0
No. 61
Chocolate brownie.
$5.49
0
No. 60
Seasonal fruit crisp.
$6.79
0
sides
4 items
No. 11
Haystack onion strings, thinly sliced and hand dipped in buttermilk butter. Includes one dip of choice.
$6.79
0
No. 12
Warm potato chips, thin and crispy.
$6.79
0
No. 14
Matchstick fries.
$6.79
0
No. 13
Hand made beer-battered Wisconsin cheese curds.
$9.59
0
Advertisment
the old fashioned brunch
11 items
No. 6 Brunch
Granola with dried Door County cherries and vanilla yogurt.
$6.89
0
Hot Mini Donuts
One dozen, made to order, hot mini donuts with powdered sugar or icing.
$6.89
0
No. 5 Brunch
Belgian style waffle served with pure Wisconsin maple syrup, Grand Marnier whipped cream and powdered sugar.
$9.59
0
No. 1 Brunch
A toasted Wolfermann's English muffin with your choice of a Miesfeld Market bratwurst patty or grilled market vegetables. Topped with a sunny side up egg, whole grain mustard cream and rosemary potat
$10.89
0
No. 2 Brunch
Wood-grilled Jordandal Farm ham served with rosemary potatoes, country toasty and two sunny side up eggs.
$13.69
0
No. 3 Brunch
House cured salmon lox and toasted Gotham bagel served with cream cheese and mixed greens tossed with shaved red onion, capers and white wine vinaigrette.
$13.69
0
No. 11 Brunch
Cored beef hash served with two sunny side up eggs, rosemary potatoes and toasted country bread.
$13.69
0
No. 4 Brunch
Walleye and eggs. Crisp beer-battered walleye served with two sunny-side up eggs, rosemary potatoes, rye toast and tartar sauce.
$16.39
0
No. 10 Brunch
Wood-grilled 4 oz. beef tenderloin fillet with sauteed spinach and garlic on a toasted Wolfermann's English muffin topped with a sunny side up egg, whole grain mustard cream and rosemary potatoes.
$16.39
0
No. 8 Brunch
Lightly breaded top sirloin steak served with sausage gravy, rosemary potatoes, country toast and two sunny side up eggs.
$17.79
0
No. 9 Brunch
Wood-grilled 8 oz. New York Strip served with rosemary potatoes, country toast and two sunny side up eggs.
$25.99
0
salads
6 items
No. 24
Tossed mixed greens with brandy vinaigrette.
$8.19
0
No. 19
Spinach and Stravecchio cheese with shaved red onion, sunflower seeds, croutons, deviled egg and hot bacon dressing.
$10.89
0
No. 20
Plump Door County cherries, buttermilk blue cheese and toasted almonds tossed with mixed greens and brandy vinaigrette.
$10.89
0
No. 21
Pickled baby beets and Salemville Gorgonzola with toasted walnuts, shaved red onion, mixed greens and creamy white wine vinaigrette.
$10.89
0
No. 22
Classic iceberg wedge salad with carrots, red onions, Bavaria's hickory smoked bacon, buttermilk blue cheese and croutons with French and blue cheese dressing.
$10.89
0
No. 23
Grill-seared Norwegian salmon with Bavaria's hickory-smoked bacon, cucumber, shaved red onion, deviled egg, mixed greens and tarragon vinaigrette.
$15.09
0
Advertisment
sandwiches
15 items
Single No. 32
Sheboygan's grand champion Miesfeld Market double bratwurst with raw onions, pickles and brown mustard on a buttered Highway Bakery hard roll.
$8.19
0
No. 39
Build your own hot dog. A 100% beef hot dog from Baranek's Farm Fresh Beef in Crivitz, on a toasted bun from Clasen's Bakery. Add sauerkraut, raw onions, pickle relish or Dusseldorf mustard.
$8.19
0
No. 38
Jim's Blue Ribbon summer sausage, grilled and topped with brown mustard, shaved red onions and Muenster cheese on toasted rye bread.
$9.59
0
No. 32
Sheboygan's grand champion Miesfeld Market double bratwurst with raw onions, pickles and brown mustard on a buttered Highway Bakery hard roll.
$10.89
0
No. 40
Grilled cheese sandwich with Swiss, aged Cheddar, wood-roasted red bell peppers and Bavaria's hickory-smoked bacon on Texas toast.
$10.89
0
No. 41
Wood-grilled and slow roasted pork shoulder, hand pulled and topped with pickle relish, Muenster cheese and smoked paprika sauce on Texas toast.
$10.89
0
No. 28
Wisconsin Burger made with local grass-fed beef, grilled over a live fire and topped with cheddar cheese, olive oil, mayonnaise and raw onion on a buttered and toasted bun.
$10.89
0
No. 33
Shaved hickory-smoked turkey breast with tiger sauce, provolone cheese and leaf lettuce on a toasted country bread.
$12.29
0
No. 35
Grilled eggplant, portabella mushroom, wood-roasted red pepper and zucchini, with goat cheese and black olive tapenade on toasted country bread.
$12.29
0
No. 37
Wood-grilled breast of chicken with Bavaria's hickory-smoked bacon, melted Swiss, Dijon mustard and mayonnaise on toasted country bread.
$12.29
0
No. 29
Spicy Burger. Made with local grass-fed beef, grilled over a live fire and topped with pepper-jack cheese, jalapeno, fried onions, Bavaria's hickory-smoked bacon and smoked paprika sauce on a buttere
$12.29
0
No. 34
Tuna salad with roasted red peppers, hard boiled eggs and leaf lettuce on toasted country bread.
$12.29
0
No. 30
Made with local grass-fed beef, grilled over a live fire and topped with fried onions, Bavaria's hickory-smoked bacon, aged cheddar, garlic sauce and a soft-cooked egg on a buttered and toasted roll.
$13.69
0
No. 36
Beer battered walleye with shredded cabbage, shaved radish and house-made lemon-caper tartar sauce on toasted country bread.
$13.69
0
No. 27
Prime Rib Sandwich. Hot, shaved prime rib, sauteed with mushrooms, onions, red peppers and topped with provolone cheese, tiger sauce and pickles on Clasen's Bakery sesame seed roll.
$13.69
0
nightly specials
3 items
No. 51
Mac and cheese. Crisp breadcrumb topped macaroni and cheese made with Wisconsin sharp cheddar.
$12.29
0
No. 52
Grilled Rushing Waters rainbow trout with fresh thyme, baby spinach and Door County beets tossed with white wine vinaigrette.
$25.99
0
No. 50
16 oz. of wood grilled rib-eye beef topped with a pat of Wisconsin sweet-cream butter. Served with matchstick fries, tiger sauce and grilled Texas toast.
$38.29
0
appetizers for big shots or sharing
3 items
Appetizer No. 8
Wisconsin's best wurst platter - a selection of our local favorites; Bavaria Sausage Kitchen's Nurnberger bratwurst, knackwurst and weisswurst with grilled bread, sauerkraut, local dilly beans and mu
Local dilly beans, deviled eggs, dill potato salad, pickled beets, poppy seed coleslaw, dill pickles, Widmer's brick spread and Vern's sharp cheddar spread with a side of crackers and rye bread.
$21.89
0
lazy susans
2 items
No. 6
Jim's Blue Ribbon summer sausage, Miesfeld Market holiday garlic salami, Bavaria Sausage Kitchen's Braunschweiger, mustard, bread and butter, pickles, deviled eggs, coleslaw and rye bread.
$21.89
0
No. 7
Wood-grilled red pepper and white bean dip, sharp Cheddar spread, grilled vegetables, deviled eggs, dill potato salad, pickled beets and grilled bread.
View
Old Fashioned's menu prices, nutrition, locations and coupons
Browse latest menu of Old Fashioned's
drinks Menu,
bar snacks Menu,
the old fashioned brunch sides Menu,
soups Menu,
desserts Menu,
sides Menu,
the old fashioned brunch Menu,
salads Menu,
sandwiches Menu,
nightly specials Menu,
appetizers for big shots or sharing Menu,
lazy susans Menu,
Breakfast menu, Lunch menu and Dinner menu everything is included.
Old Fashioned offers Drinks, Bar Snacks & The Old Fashioned Brunch Sides across 84 menu items, with prices from $1.09 to $38.29. Browse the full Old Fashioned menu with current prices — budget picks like the $1.09 Coca-Cola — updated July 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.
Suggestions are reviewed before they show publicly. Thanks for keeping deals fresh!
Reviewed before any change is made. Thanks for keeping menus accurate!
Spotted wrong info, or want this page updated or removed?
Contact us →
Opens your email app to [email protected] — we attach this page's link so we can reply faster.
Old Fashioned Menu — Frequently Asked Questions
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the Old Fashioned menu?
Old Fashioned offers 84 menu items across sandwiches and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does Old Fashioned food cost?
Menu prices at Old Fashioned range from $1.09 for the most affordable options up to $38.29 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Old Fashioned cheapest items guide.
What are the cheapest items at Old Fashioned?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Old Fashioned, visit the dedicated Old Fashioned cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $1.09.
Is Old Fashioned good value for money?
Old Fashioned holds a customer rating of 4/5 based on 86 reviews. To judge value more accurately, compare Old Fashioned side-by-side with similar restaurants: Old Fashioned vs FOOD or Old Fashioned vs Jimmy John's.
How does Old Fashioned compare to similar restaurants nearby?
Old Fashioned serves sandwiches cuisine alongside similar restaurants like FOOD, Jimmy John's, KFC. Use our comparison pages to see a direct price-by-price breakdown: Old Fashioned vs FOOD, Old Fashioned vs Jimmy John's.
