we make our sandwiches on our own freshly made bread
0
new york deli sandwiches
19 items
Breads
served on pumpernickel, rye, oatmeal wheat or sourdough breads, wraps, baguette, bialy, ciabatta, kaiser roll, multi-grain roll, croissant or focaccia
0
Hand - Sliced Pumpernickel Or Multi - Grain Bread
add $0.50
0
Toppings
with mayo, dijon, deli or honey cup mustard, russian, aioli, chipotle, aioli, parsley garlic, sesame ginger or vinaigrette dressing, lettuce, tomato, sprouts, banana peppers or red onion
0
Half Of A Ny Deli Sandwich Is Half
price Plus $0.75
0
Cheeses
add two slices of cheese (cheddar, swiss, muenster, provolone, mozzarella, pepper jack or american )
$0.75
0
Egg Salad
$3.5
0
Hummus
$3.5
0
Cheese
(1/4 lb, choice)
$4.95
0
Genoa Salami
$4.95
0
Ham
$4.95
0
Turkey
$4.95
0
Chicken Salad
$5.25
0
Seltan
$5.25
0
Tuna Salad
(solid white)
$5.25
0
Corned beef
$5.75
0
Prosciutto
$5.75
0
Roast Beef
$5.75
0
Roast Chicken
$5.75
0
Smoked Turkey
$5.75
0
Advertisment
bagel sandwiches - side stuff
6 items
Potato Chips
$0.95
0
Terra Chips
$0.99
0
Almond Crescent
$1.5
0
Jumbo Cookie
$1.75
0
Fudge Brownie
$1.75
0
Cheesecake Brownie
$2.25
0
bagel sandwiches
16 items
Butter
$1.11
0
Peanut Butter, Jams, Preserves. Cinnamon - Sugar And Butter, Or Honey And Butter
american, cheddar, mozzarella, muenster, provolone, pepper jack or swiss
$2.45
0
Veggie, Veggie - Lite, Bacon - Scallion
$2.75
0
Pizza Bagel
$2.95
0
San Diego Bagel
(bagel with cream cheese and raspberry jalapeno spread)
$2.95
0
Nova
$3.25
0
Mexican Bagel
(jalapeno cream cheese, fresh salsa and melted cheddar)
$3.95
0
Vegetarian Bagel
(veggie cream cheese, tomato and melted muenster cheese)
$3.95
0
Whitefish Salad
$5.5
0
Nova Lox & Cream Cheese
$7.95
0
Advertisment
vegetarian & vegan
11 items
Buttermilk Bialy
a fresh bialy with melted muenster, tomato, sprouts & dijon
$3.95
0
Cascadilla Crisp
sliced cucumber, roasted red peppers, fresh tomato, red onion, sprouts and parsley - garlic dressing on hand - sliced multi - grain bread
$3.95
0
Dewitt Melt
a fresh bialy with homemade coleslaw, tomato and melted swiss cheese
$3.95
0
Van Dorn's Vegan
homemade hummus, roasted red peppers, tomato, sprouts on oatmeal wheat bread
$4.5
0
Cayuga Croissant
avocado, tomato, mushrooms, sprouts and parsley - garlic dressing on a croissant
$4.75
0
Jonahs Jive
homemade hummus, fresh spinach, tomato, cucumber and parsley - garlic dressing on hand - sliced multi - grain bread
$4.75
0
Varna Vegan
lemon teriyaki seitan on oatmeal wheat bread with fresh spinach, tomato and balsamic vinaigrette
$5.75
0
Viva Chelsea
fresh mozzarella cheese with fresh basil, tomato, extra - virgin olive oil, salt and pepper on rosemary focaccia bread
$5.95
0
Steamin' Treman
veggie burger with fresh homemade salsa and melted pepper jack cheese on a multi - grain roll
$6.25
0
Lat Strand
fresh mozzarella, sun - dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers on a baguette
$6.95
0
Michigan Hollow
a warm balsamic - marinated portobello mushroom with roasted red peppers, parsley - garlic dressing and melted provolone cheese on a multi - grain roll
$6.95
0
ham / bacon / salami
6 items
C.T.B.L.T
toasted sourdough bread with aioli dressing, avocado, bacon, lettuce and tomato
$4.95
0
Mediterranean
genoa salami, lettuce, tomato, red onion, banana peppers and provolone cheese with vinaigrette on ciabatta bread
$5.75
0
Clinton's Wich
hot ham, fresh salsa and banana peppers topped with melted cheddar on a baily
$6.25
0
Euro
ham, brie cheese, red onion and dijon mustard on ciabatta bread
$6.95
0
Antipasto Wrap
prosciutto, artichoke hearts, sun - dried tomatoes, pepperoni, lettuce and mozzarella cheese with vinaigrette dressing in a sun - dried tomato wrap
$7.95
0
Il Francisco
thinly sliced prosciutto, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, fresh goat cheese, kalamata olive spread, tomato, vinaigrette and fresh basil on rosemary focaccia
$8.25
0
Advertisment
chicken & tuna
7 items
Fulton St, Melt
homemade albacore tuna salad on a plain bagel with tomato and melted cheddar cheese, please ask if you'd prefer homemade chicken salad
$5.95
0
Milestone
house - roasted chicken breast, homemade plum chutney and lettuce served club - style on toasted sourdough
$6.25
0
Mt. Pleasant
house - roasted chicken breast, fresh spinach, tomato and chipotle aioli on sourdough bread
$6.25
0
T - Burg With A Twist
all - white albacore tuna salad with avocado and tomato on pumpernickel bread
$6.25
0
Olympian
house - roasted chicken breast, feta cheese, fresh spinach, tomato and vinaigrette dressing in a sun - dressing tomato wrap
$6.95
0
Pancho Villa
house - roasted chicken breast, avocado, fresh salsa & jalapeno peppers in a sun - dried tomato wrap
$7.25
0
Tuscan Verde
our own roast chicken breast with homemade pesto, fresh spinach, fresh tomato and provolone cheese on rosemary focaccia bread
$7.75
0
beef
3 items
Court Street Beef
rare roast beef with parsley - garlic cream cheese, lettuce and tomato on rye
View
Ithaca Bakery's menu prices, nutrition, locations and coupons
Browse latest menu of Ithaca Bakery's
specialty sandwiches Menu,
new york deli sandwiches Menu,
bagel sandwiches - side stuff Menu,
bagel sandwiches Menu,
vegetarian & vegan Menu,
ham / bacon / salami Menu,
chicken & tuna Menu,
beef Menu,
turkey & smoked turkey Menu,
Breakfast menu, Lunch menu and Dinner menu everything is included.
Ithaca Bakery offers Specialty Sandwiches, New York Deli Sandwiches & Bagel Sandwiches - Side Stuff across 76 menu items, with prices from $0.75 to $8.25. Browse the full Ithaca Bakery menu with current prices — budget picks like the $0.75 Cheeses — updated July 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.
Suggestions are reviewed before they show publicly. Thanks for keeping deals fresh!
Reviewed before any change is made. Thanks for keeping menus accurate!
Spotted wrong info, or want this page updated or removed?
Contact us →
Opens your email app to [email protected] — we attach this page's link so we can reply faster.
Ithaca Bakery Menu — Frequently Asked Questions
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the Ithaca Bakery menu?
Ithaca Bakery offers 76 menu items across sandwiches and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does Ithaca Bakery food cost?
Menu prices at Ithaca Bakery range from $0.75 for the most affordable options up to $8.25 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Ithaca Bakery cheapest items guide.
What are the cheapest items at Ithaca Bakery?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Ithaca Bakery, visit the dedicated Ithaca Bakery cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $0.75.
Is Ithaca Bakery good value for money?
Ithaca Bakery holds a customer rating of 4/5 based on 115 reviews. To judge value more accurately, compare Ithaca Bakery side-by-side with similar restaurants: Ithaca Bakery vs FOOD or Ithaca Bakery vs Brew.
How does Ithaca Bakery compare to similar restaurants nearby?
Ithaca Bakery serves sandwiches cuisine alongside similar restaurants like FOOD, Brew, Jimmy John's. Use our comparison pages to see a direct price-by-price breakdown: Ithaca Bakery vs FOOD, Ithaca Bakery vs Brew.
