this is an old southern classic. a sweet lemon custard pie that is the perfect compliment to a coffee or espresso.
$20
0
Vinegar Chess Pie
this is the classic chess pie. a sweet vanilla cakey custard balanced with a little apple cider vinegar.
$20
0
Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie
an indiana farm classic. a sweet creamy brown sugar filling inside a buttery pie crust.
$20
0
Buttermilk Pie
tangy buttermilk adds zip to this pie with a cake-y layer and a smooth custard layer.
$21
0
Oatmeal Pie
oatmeal pie is the perfect breakfast pie! oatmeal with the sweetness of maple syrup and hint of spice.
$21
0
Banana Custard
a creamy custard with concentrated roasted banana flavor.
$21
0
Lemon Meringue Pie
lemon curd from fresh squeezed lemons topped with a billowy cloud of meringue.
$21
0
Peanut Butter Pie
a sweet peanut butter filling in a ginger snap crust topped with chocolate ganache and chopped salted peanuts.
$22
0
Coconut Custard
a smooth custard with concentrated coconut flavor topped with toasted coconut.
$22
0
Ginger Custard
a pretty golden custard flavored and decorated with chopped candied ginger
$22
0
Banana Cream Pie
fresh bananas in a thick layer of vanilla pastry cream topped with white chocolate curls.
$22
0
Coconut Cream Pie
light pastry cream made with coconut milk. toasted coconut above and fresh coconut flakes below.
$22
0
Red Line Espresso Cream
metropolis coffee co's famous redline espresso gives this delicate cream pie its deep coffee flavor.
$22
0
Orange Cream Pie
a bright tangy orange cream in a pecan graham cracker crust topped with lightly sweetened whipped cream. a safer bet than a florida vacation this year.
$22
0
Passion Fruit Meringue Pie
our exotic twist on an old favorite.
$22
0
Chocolate Chess Pie
our decadent chocolate take on the southern staple. we use single bean 70% venezuelan chocolate. customers nicknamed this the "brownie pie."
$23
0
Pumpkin Pie
real cream, vanilla, and quality spices make this a particularly good version of the classic fall pie.
$23
0
Sour Cream Dutch Apple
tart apples enveloped in a tangy sour cream custard topped with a sweet walnut crumble.
$23
0
Key Lime Pie
fresh squeezed key limes and a crisp ginger snap crust are the secrets to our version of this iconic pie. topped with whipped cream (meringue can be substituted via email).
$23
0
Apple Pie
classic two crust apple pie. not too sweet with more fruit than goo in a delicious buttery crust.
$24
0
Chocolate Cream Pie
rich thick chocolate pastry cream topped with lightly sweetened whipped cream and bittersweet chocolate curls.
$24
0
Pear Apple Cranberry With Pecan Crumble
a delicious combination of autumn fruits.
$25
0
Fat Elvis Pie
the name says it all. chocolate, peanut butter & bananas in a graham cracker-peanut-pretzel crust.
$25
0
S'More Pie
serve up s'more pie at your next campfire. goes great with ghost stories & sing-alongs. no stick whittlin' required.
$25
0
Chocolate Cream Pie With Bananas!
you guessed it. we put bananas in the bottom of our chocolate cream pie and it's really yummy. we also garnish the top with dried banana chips.
$25
0
Jeffersonville Pie
we spike our maple pecan pie with chocolate chips and bourbon and dress it with stripes of chocolate ganache.
$26
0
Maple Pecan Pie
maple provides a more complex sweetness to our pecan pie.
$26
0
Broccoli Cheddar Quiche
our creamy quiche with broccoli florets and sharp cheddar cheese.
$26
0
Quiche Luann
our creamy quiche with bacon onion and cheddar.
$26
0
Quiche, Mushroom Gruyere
our creamy quiche with sauted mushrooms and gruyere.
Hoosier Mama Pie Company features ... across 30 menu items, with prices from $20.00 to $26.00. Explore the full Hoosier Mama Pie Company menu with current prices — budget picks like the $20.00 Lemon Chess Pie — updated August 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.
Suggestions are reviewed before they show publicly. Thanks for keeping deals fresh!
Reviewed before any change is made. Thanks for keeping menus accurate!
Spotted wrong info, or want this page updated or removed?
Contact us →
Opens your email app to [email protected] — we attach this page's link so we can reply faster.
Hoosier Mama Pie Company Menu — Frequently Asked Questions
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the Hoosier Mama Pie Company menu?
Hoosier Mama Pie Company offers 30 menu items across bakery & pastries and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does Hoosier Mama Pie Company food cost?
Menu prices at Hoosier Mama Pie Company range from $20.00 for the most affordable options up to $26.00 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Hoosier Mama Pie Company cheapest items guide.
What are the cheapest items at Hoosier Mama Pie Company?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Hoosier Mama Pie Company, visit the dedicated Hoosier Mama Pie Company cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $20.00.