Home Menu City Island Diner
C

City Island Diner Menu

Prices, calorie guide, and order-online options in one place

wraps • sandwiches • burger
4
(122 reviews)
Add photo

Advertisment

Menus change often, so please confirm prices at the restaurant. Know a current price? Use the report option on any item to help keep this menu accurate.

125 dishes From $1.00 – $15.95

beverages

3 items

Coffee

$1
0

Soda

$2
0

Juice

$2.5
0

desserts

5 items

Apple Pastry Turnover

$2
0

Muffin

$2
0

Homemade Banana Chocolate Chip Bread

$2
0

Lindzer Tart

$2
0

Layer Cake du Jour

Please call restaurant for today's selection.

$4
0

Advertisment

soups

7 items

Cup of Soup

Please call restaurant for today's selection.

$3
0

Bowl of Soup

Please call restaurant for today's selection.

$4
0

Cup of Chowder

$4.5
0

Cup of Chili

$4.95
0

Bowl of Chowder

$5.5
0

Bowl of Chili

$5.95
0

Bowl of Chili and Chips

With cheese and onion.

$7.95
0

sides

9 items

Side of French Fries

$3.75
0

Side of Coleslaw

$3.75
0

Side of Macaroni Salad

$3.75
0

Side of Onion Rings

$4
0

Side of Hot Vegetables

$4
0

Side of Mashed Potatoes

$4
0

Side of Homemade Potato Pancakes

$4
0

Side of Sweet Fries

$4.25
0

Side of Homemade Greek Salad

$4.95
0

Advertisment

the basics

12 items

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Served with a pickle.

$4.25
0

Egg Salad Sandwich

Served with a pickle.

$4.5
0

BLT Sandwich

Served with a pickle.

$5.25
0

Tuna Salad Sandwich

Served with a pickle.

$5.25
0

Chicken Salad Sandwich

Served with a pickle.

$5.95
0

Sabrett Hot Dog

With fries. Served with a pickle.

$5.95
0

Tuna Melt Sandwich

Served with a pickle.

$6.75
0

Pastrami Sandwich

On rye. Served with a pickle.

$7.95
0

Corned Beef Sandwich

On rye. Served with a pickle.

$7.95
0

Fresh Turkey Club Sandwich

Served with a pickle.

$8.95
0

Traditional Reuben Sandwich

Served with a pickle.

$8.95
0

Monte Cristo Sandwich

Served with a pickle.

$8.95
0

burgers

8 items

All Beef Burger

Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$5.5
0

All Beef Burger with Cheese

Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$5.95
0

Homemade Turkey Burger

Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$5.95
0

California Veggie Burger

Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$5.95
0

All Beef Burger with Bacon

Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$6.5
0

All Beef Burger with Bacon and Cheese

Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$6.95
0

Titanic Burger

10 oz. burger served with coleslaw and pickle.

$7.5
0

Titanic Burger with Cheese

10 oz. burger served with coleslaw and pickle.

$7.95
0

Advertisment

salad platters

10 items

City Island House Salad

Mixed greens with tomato, red onions and carrots.

$5.95
0

Chicken Caesar Salad

Grilled chicken, croutons, Parmesan cheese and romaine lettuce.

$8.95
0

Spinach Salad

Fresh baby spinach, bacon, mushrooms, sliced eggs and dressing.

$8.95
0

Cobb Salad

Turkey, Swiss cheese, bacon, sliced egg, lettuce and tomato.

$8.95
0

Chef's Salad

Roast beef, turkey, ham, American cheese, sliced egg, lettuce and tomato.

$8.95
0

Greek Salad

Feta cheese, tomatoes, peppers, onions, olives, cucumbers and romaine lettuce.

$8.95
0

Taco Salad

Homemade chili with lettuce, tomato, cheese, onion and tortilla chips.

$8.95
0

Snug Salad

Baby spinach, goat cheese, walnuts, tomatoes and red onion.

$8.95
0

Fresh Fruit Salad

Fresh fruit served with cottage cheese and lettuce.

$8.95
0

Chicken, Tuna and Egg Salad Platter

Served with cheese, tomatoes, and crackers on a bed of lettuce.

$8.95
0

appetizers

15 items

Island Wings

$7.95
0

Chicken Tenders

$7.95
0

Mozzarella Sticks

$7.95
0

Jalapeno Poppers

$7.95
0

Homemade Fried Zucchini Stix

$8.95
0

Black Bean and Goat Cheese Empanada

$8.95
0

Chicken Teriyaki Potstickers

$8.95
0

"Train Wreck" Potato Wedges

$9.95
0

Nachos Grande

$9.95
0

Chicken Quesadilla

$9.95
0

Veggie Quesadilla

$10.95
0

Crispy Calamari

$10.95
0

Sweet Fried Clams

$10.95
0

Baked Clams Oreganato

$10.95
0

Bar Platter

Mozzarella sticks, poppers, chicken strips, fries and onion rings.

$15.95
0

Advertisment

specialty burgers

5 items

Bronx Burger

Bacon, American cheese and fried onions. Served on a sandwich-sized English muffin with fries, lettuce, tomatoes and pickles.

$8.95
0

Great Lakes Burger

Mushrooms, onions and Swiss cheese. Served on a sandwich-sized English muffin with fries, lettuce, tomatoes and pickles.

$8.95
0

Cozumel Burger

Jalapeno Jack cheese with homemade salsa. Served on a sandwich-sized English muffin with fries, lettuce, tomatoes and pickles.

$8.95
0

Southwestern Burger

Homemade chili, cheddar cheese and diced onions. Served on a sandwich-sized English muffin with fries, lettuce, tomatoes and pickles.

$8.95
0

Pisa Burger

Leaning toward pizza. Served on a sandwich-sized English muffin with fries, lettuce, tomatoes and pickles.

$8.95
0

bronx heroes and sandwiches

7 items

Aunt Frannie's Homemade Meatball Parmigiana Hero

Fresh roasted in-house. Served with french fries.

$8.95
0

Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich

Fresh roasted in-house. "Philled" with cheese, steak and onions. Served with french fries.

$8.95
0

Chicken Parmigiana Hero

Fresh roasted in-house. Served with french fries.

$9.95
0

Roast Pork Sandwich

Fresh roasted in-house with pepper jack cheese and a side of gravy. Served with french fries.

$9.95
0

Roast Beef "Balboa" Sandwich

Fresh roasted in-house with mozzarella cheese and sauteed onions on garlic bread. Served with french fries.

$9.95
0

Tropical Chicken BBQ Hero

Fresh roasted in-house grilled chicken with mango BBQ sauce, bacon and melted Swiss. Served with french fries.

$9.95
0

Fresh Filet of Fish Sandwich

Served with coleslaw, tartar sauce and french fries.

$9.95
0

wraps

10 items

Antipasto Wrap

Ham, salami, mozzarella, eggplant and red pepper. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

California Wrap

Turkey, Muenster, tomato, lettuce, olives, and creamy dill dressing. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Chef's Salad Wrap

Ham, turkey, roast beef, cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and sliced egg. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Grilled chicken, lettuce, homemade croutons and Caesar dressing. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Greek Salad Wrap

Lettuce, tomato, feta, onions, peppers, olives, cucumbers, and vinaigrette. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Mexican Wrap

Homemade chili, cheddar, onions and sour cream. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Roast Beef Wrap

Roast beef, lettuce, roasted peppers and herb cheese. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Tuna Salad Wrap

Homemade tuna salad, lettuce, tomato and sliced egg. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Vidalia Wrap

Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, olives and vidalia vinaigrette. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Apple-Nut Veggie Wrap

Chopped apples, pineapples, shredded carrots, walnuts, raisins and herb cheese. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

specialty sandwich board

8 items

Columbia Sandwich

Our Italian combo. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Constellation Sandwich

Our clam roll. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Courageous Sandwich

Chicken cutlet with the works. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Intrepid Sandwich

Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato and herb mayo. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

The Magic Sandwich

Chicken salad and BLT on a bagel. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Mayflower Sandwich

Turkey, stuffing and cranberry on rye. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Shamrock Sandwich

Corned beef, melted Swiss and coleslaw. Served with pickle.

$8.95
0

Independence Sandwich

Virginia ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

paninis

9 items

Cuban Panini

Roast pork, ham, Muenster cheese, tomato, pickles, onions and special sauce. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Milano Panini

Spinach, mushrooms, provolone and roasted peppers. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Delancey Panini

Pastrami, Swiss cheese and sauerkraut with homemade mustard relish. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Moonstruck Panini

Salami, eggplant, mozzarella cheese and roasted red pepper relish. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Cordon Bleu Panini

Breaded chicken, ham and Swiss cheese with Dijon mustard. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Hawaiian Panini

Virginia ham, Swiss cheese, pineapple salsa and honey mustard. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Islander Panini

Sliced loin of pork, pepper jack cheese and spicy remoulade. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Mediterranean Panini

Grilled chicken with homemade Greek salad. Served with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

Make Your Own Panini

Served on a club roll with coleslaw and pickle.

$8.95
0

hot open sandwiches

4 items

Roast Beef Open Sandwich

Served with mashed potatoes and gravy.

$9.95
0

Roast Loin of Pork Open Sandwich

Served with mashed potatoes and gravy.

$9.95
0

Oven Roasted Chicken Open Sandwich

Served with mashed potatoes and gravy.

$9.95
0

Roast Turkey Open Sandwich

Served with mashed potatoes and gravy.

$9.95
0

home style dinners

13 items

Jumbo Cheese Ravioli Dinner

Served with homemade meatballs. Served with bread.

$13.95
0

Roast Loin of Pork Dinner

With potato pancakes and sauerkraut. Served with bread.

$13.95
0

Old Fashioned Roast Beef Dinner

With mashed potatoes and vegetable. Served with bread.

$13.95
0

Roast Turkey Dinner

With stuffing, mashed potatoes and vegetables. Served with bread.

$13.95
0

Roast 1/2 Chicken Dinner

With mashed potatoes and vegetables. Served with bread.

$13.95
0

Bangers and Mashed Dinner

With vegetables. Served with bread.

$13.95
0

Fresh Calamari Marinara Over Linguine Dinner

Served with bread.

$13.95
0

Corned Beef and Cabbage Dinner

With mashed potatoes and carrots. Served with bread.

$14.95
0

Chicken Sicilian Over Linguine Dinner

Served with bread.

$14.95
0

Traditional Irish Shepard's Pie Dinner

Served with bread.

$14.95
0

Broiled Tilapia Oreganata Dinner

With rice and vegetable. Served with bread.

$14.95
0

Shrimp In a Basket Dinner

With fries and coleslaw. Served with bread.

$14.95
0

Fish and Chips Dinner

Includes fries, coleslaw and tartar sauce. Served with bread.

$14.95
0
View City Island Diner's menu prices, nutrition, locations and coupons

Browse latest menu of City Island Diner's beverages Menu, desserts Menu, soups Menu, sides Menu, the basics Menu, burgers Menu, salad platters Menu, appetizers Menu, specialty burgers Menu, bronx heroes and sandwiches Menu, wraps Menu, specialty sandwich board Menu, paninis Menu, hot open sandwiches Menu, home style dinners Menu, Breakfast menu, Lunch menu and Dinner menu everything is included.

Restaurant Information

Categories:
wraps • sandwiches • burger
Rating
4 (122 reviews)
Click on a star to rate this restaurant

About City Island Diner

City Island Diner offers Beverages, Desserts & Soups across 125 menu items, with prices from $1.00 to $15.95. Browse the full City Island Diner menu with current prices — budget picks like the $1.00 Coffee — updated July 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.

4 ★ · 122 reviews

Rate & review

Reviews are checked before they appear. Be honest & kind.

No reviews yet — be the first to review City Island Diner.

Photos

No photos yet — add the first one.

Similar Binge-Worthy Restaurants

More budget-friendly fast food and value menu alternatives to City Island Diner

See all →
KFC

KFC

chicken · Binge-worthy picks
T

The Glasshouse Cafe

coffee · Binge-worthy picks
S

Sunset

burger · Binge-worthy picks
Between The Buns

Between The Buns

burger · Binge-worthy picks
McDonald's

McDonald's

burger · Binge-worthy picks
Jimmy John's

Jimmy John's

sandwiches · Binge-worthy picks

Own City Island Diner?

Claim it to update prices & details, post offers, and get a verified ✓ badge guests trust.

Free while we're in beta. Later a one-time $99 lifetime, then monthly plans — early claims stay free.

Claim this restaurant →
Spotted wrong info, or want this page updated or removed? Contact us →

Opens your email app to [email protected] — we attach this page's link so we can reply faster.

City Island Diner Menu — Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.

What is on the City Island Diner menu?
City Island Diner offers 125 menu items across wraps and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.

How much does City Island Diner food cost?
Menu prices at City Island Diner range from $1.00 for the most affordable options up to $15.95 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the City Island Diner cheapest items guide.

What are the cheapest items at City Island Diner?
For the lowest-cost meal options at City Island Diner, visit the dedicated City Island Diner cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $1.00.

Is City Island Diner good value for money?
City Island Diner holds a customer rating of 4/5 based on 122 reviews. To judge value more accurately, compare City Island Diner side-by-side with similar restaurants: City Island Diner vs McDonald's or City Island Diner vs Wendy's.

How does City Island Diner compare to similar restaurants nearby?
City Island Diner serves wraps cuisine alongside similar restaurants like McDonald's, Wendy's, Burger King. Use our comparison pages to see a direct price-by-price breakdown: City Island Diner vs McDonald's, City Island Diner vs Wendy's.