Home Menu Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop
C

Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop Menu

Prices, calorie guide, and order-online options in one place

pizza • sandwiches • calzones
4
(61 reviews)

Prices may vary — please confirm at the restaurant before ordering.

Advertisment

97 dishes From $0.99 – $13.25

fresh salads

10 items

Small Salad

$3.25
0

Fresh Garden Salad (Large)

$4.99
0

Super Salad

$7.25
0

Greek Salad

$7.25
0

Club Salad

$7.25
0

Antipasto Salad

$7.25
0

Greek Chicken Salad

$8.25
0

Grilled Steak Salad

$8.25
0

Chicken Caesar Salad

$8.25
0

Buffalo Chicken Salad

$9.25
0

pasta dinners

7 items

Penne & Marmara Sauce

Add a meatball $1.50, add pepperoni or sausage sauce $1.50.

$5.25
0

Meatball Casserole w/Garlic Toast

3 Meatballs, melted provolone & mozzarella

$6.75
0

Stuffed Shells w/Garlic Toast

With ricotta cheese, 4 jumbo shells

$7.25
0

Eggplant Parmesan

Served over spaghetti w/garlic toast

$7.25
0

Chicken Parmesan

Served over spaghetti w/garlic toast

$7.25
0

Side of Meatballs

Available with pasta dinners only

$1.75
0

Side of Sausage

Available with pasta dinners only

$3.25
0

Advertisment

fun foods

14 items

Meaty Wings

Homemade sauces: Buffalo, BBQ, garlic butter, season, salt & garlic butter

$5.25
0

Small French Fries

Nacho cheese, bacon or beef gravy $2.00

$3
0

Breadsticks

W/ marinara sauce or garlic butter

$4.25
0

Cheesy Garlic Toast (1 Pcs)

$1.5
0

Garlic Toast (1 Pcs)

$0.99
0

Loaf of Garlic Bread

$3.75
0

12" Pepperoni Roll or Jalapeno Roll

$7.25
0

Provolone Wedges

$5.25
0

Fried Mushrooms

$5.25
0

Onion Rings

$4.25
0

Jalapeno Poppers

$5.25
0

Battered Dipped Zucchini Strips

$4.99
0

Chicken Tenders w/ Fries

$8.25
0

Single Cuts (Traditional)

Toppings $0.49 extra

$1.85
0

hot pocket wedge

9 items

Pepperoni

$8.99
0

Grilled Chicken

$8.99
0

Turkey

$8.99
0

Italian

$8.99
0

Club

$8.99
0

Veggie

$8.99
0

Philly Steak

$8.99
0

Steak

$8.99
0

Ham

$8.99
0

Advertisment

deli sandwiches

4 items

Rueben

$7.99
0

Turkey

$7.99
0

Corned Beef

$7.99
0

Tuna

$7.99
0

gyros and wraps

6 items

Turkey

$5.5
0

Veggie

$5.5
0

Grilled Steak

$5.5
0

Italian

$5.5
0

Grilled Chicken

$5.5
0

Chicken Caesar

$5.5
0

Advertisment

focaccia sandwiches

9 items

Pepperoni

$7.99
0

Grilled Chicken

$7.99
0

Turkey

$7.99
0

Italian

$7.99
0

Club

$7.99
0

Veggie

$7.99
0

Philly Steak

$7.99
0

Steak

$7.99
0

Ham

$7.99
0

oven baked hoagies

20 items

Italian

$5.25
0

Steak

$5.25
0

Meatball

$5.25
0

Veggie

$5.25
0

Eggplant Parmigiana

$5.25
0

Chicken Parmigiana

$5.25
0

Ham & Cheese

$5.25
0

Egg & Pepperoni

$5.25
0

Turkey

$5.25
0

Egg & Hot Pepper

$5.25
0

Egg & Sweet Pepper

$5.25
0

Cheese Hoagie

$5.25
0

Philly Steak

Fried onions, cheddar cheese, mushrooms

$5.5
0

Club

Turkey, ham, bacon

$5.5
0

Buffalo Chicken

$5.5
0

Cheeseburger

$5.5
0

Roethlisberger

$5.5
0

Hot Sausage

$5.5
0

Grilled Chicken

$5.5
0

Fish

$9.5
0

Advertisment

sicilian pizza

1 items

Sicilian Pizza

$13.25
0

traditional red or white pizza

1 items

Traditional Red or White Pizza

$4.99
0

specialty pizza

1 items

Specialty Pizza

$7.99
0

calzones & stombolis

9 items

House (Pepperoni & Sausage)

$9.25
0

Mushroom & Cheese

$9.25
0

Veggie Combination

$9.25
0

Cheese

$9.25
0

Steak

$9.25
0

Meatball

$9.25
0

Italian

$9.25
0

Pepperoni

$9.25
0

Spinach

$9.25
0

lunch menu

6 items

Small 1 Topping Pizza & Can of Pop

$6.5
0

Homemade Focaccia

$6.5
0

Half Hoagie Gyro or Wrap

$5.5
0

Pasta

With marinara sauce & garlic toast

$5.25
0

2 Slices of Cheese Pizza & Small Salad or Fries

$5.5
0

1 Slice of Cheese Pizza & Small Salad or Fries

$4.5
0
View Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop's menu prices, nutrition, locations and coupons

Browse latest menu of Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop's fresh salads Menu, pasta dinners Menu, fun foods Menu, hot pocket wedge Menu, deli sandwiches Menu, gyros and wraps Menu, focaccia sandwiches Menu, oven baked hoagies Menu, sicilian pizza Menu, traditional red or white pizza Menu, specialty pizza Menu, calzones & stombolis Menu, lunch menu Menu, Breakfast menu, Lunch menu and Dinner menu everything is included.

Restaurant Information

Categories:
pizza • sandwiches • calzones
Rating
4 (61 reviews)
Click on a star to rate this restaurant

Similar Binge-Worthy Restaurants

More budget-friendly fast food and value menu alternatives to Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop

See all →
Long Island Bagel Cafe

Long Island Bagel Cafe

coffee · Binge-worthy picks
Pizza Hut

Pizza Hut

pizza · Binge-worthy picks
Between The Buns

Between The Buns

burger · Binge-worthy picks
M

Miceli's

italian · Binge-worthy picks
T

The Glasshouse Cafe

coffee · Binge-worthy picks
A

Annie's

italian · Binge-worthy picks
Own this restaurant, or spotted wrong info? Let us know →

Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop Menu — Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.

What is on the Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop menu?
Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop offers 97 menu items across pizza and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.

How much does Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop food cost?
Menu prices at Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop range from $0.99 for the most affordable options up to $13.25 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop cheapest items guide.

What are the cheapest items at Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop, visit the dedicated Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $0.99.

Is Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop good value for money?
Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop holds a customer rating of 4/5 based on 61 reviews. To judge value more accurately, compare Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop side-by-side with similar restaurants: Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop vs FOOD or Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop vs Pizza Hut.

How does Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop compare to similar restaurants nearby?
Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop serves pizza cuisine alongside similar restaurants like FOOD, Pizza Hut, Pizze. Use our comparison pages to see a direct price-by-price breakdown: Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop vs FOOD, Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop vs Pizza Hut.