Skip to content
B

Bay Goodman Pizza Menu

Prices, calorie guide, and order-online options in one place

4 126 ratings
75 items
$1.69 from
pizza category Add photos
Coupons Order Online

Advertisment

Menus change often, so please confirm prices at the restaurant. Know a current price? Use the report option on any item to help keep this menu accurate.

75 dishes From $1.69 – $12.00

desserts

4 items

Chocolate Chunk Cookie

$1.69
0

Pizza Fritta

$2.79
0

Brownie

$2.79
0

Cannoli (2)

$3.49
0

starters & snacks

9 items

Garlic Knots

Homemade breadsticks tossed in our garlic parm sauce and baked to perfection.

$2.79
0

Colossal Fries

1 lb. Tavern style fries seasoned with salt and pepper. Add bacon, mozzarella & cheddar $6.99

$3.79
0

Cheesy Garlic Bread

Delicious sub loaf baked with buttery garlic parmesan sauce and fresh herbs, topped with mozzarella.

$4.29
0

Veggie Platter

Fried mushrooms, cauliflower & zucchini sticks with ranch dressing & red sauce.

$6.99
0

Loaded Skins

5 Russet potatoes loaded with bacon topped with mozzarella & cheddar cheese and served with sour cream.

$6.99
0

Mozzarella Sticks

7 Battered mozzarella sticks served with tomato basil sauce.

$6.99
0

Pizza Logs

5 Pizza Logs served with tomato basil sauce.

$6.99
0

Fried Calamari

Lightly battered, tossed with banana peppers & served with marinara sauce.

$8.99
0

Bay Goodman Platter

2 Loaded skins, 2 pizza logs, 2 chicken fingers, veggies, 2 mozzarella sticks, 2 sauces and sour cream.

$11.79
0

Advertisment

sides

6 items

French Fries

$2.99
0

House Salad

$2.99
0

Macaroni Salad

$2.99
0

Home Fries

$2.99
0

Caesar Salad

$2.99
0

House Made Chips

$2.99
0

wings & fingers

2 items

Jumbo Wings or New Boneless Wings

Served with celery & bleu cheese and choice of our authentic buffalo sauce mild or hot, country sweet, barbecue, or garlic parmigiano.

$4.49
0

Chicken Fingers

Generous order of tender chicken Fingers with tavern style fries, served with your choice of dipping sauce.

$7.89
0

Advertisment

burgers

5 items

Rochester Burger

Topped with white american cheese, mustard, onions and our own hot sauce.

$4.59
0

All American Burger

Topped with american cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions and mayo.

$4.59
0

Bacon Cheeseburger

Topped with bacon, american cheese, ketchup, mustard, onions and pickles.

$4.89
0

My Way Burger

Topped with any or all of your favorites. Truly made

$4.89
0

The Big Dog

Famous zwiegels foot long hot dog made

$5.29
0

salads

4 items

House Salad

Crisp romaine, red onions, tomatoes, red and green peppers with our house dressing.

$6.99
0

Mediterranean Salad

Crisp romaine, topped with roasted red peppers, red onions, artichoke hearts, black olives and asiago cheese.

$6.99
0

Caesar Salad

Crisp romaine, red onions, bacon, seasoned croutons, topped with shredded asiago cheese.

$6.99
0

Chopped Veggie Salad

Fresh mushrooms, peppers, carrots, tomatoes, red onions, broccoli and our famous Original Bay Goodman house vinaigrette.

$7.95
0

Advertisment

grilled panini

6 items

Pizano

Sicilian hot soppressata, tomato, roasted peppers & provolone cheese with our house made oil.

$7.89
0

Bambino

Roasted turkey, bacon, provolone cheese, topped with ranch dressing.

$7.89
0

La Bella

Fresh spinach & tomato with asiago & mozzarella cheese.

$7.89
0

Wise Guy

House made meatballs, cappicola, mozzarella & provolone cheese brushed with extra virgin oil.

$7.89
0

Margherita

Fresh tomato & basil with mozzarella cheese and extra virgin oil.

$7.89
0

The My Way

Choose from your favorite ingredients we offer to create a mouth watering sandwich.

$7.89
0

wraps

5 items

Garden Grill

$7.89
0

Grilled Chicken Caesar

$7.89
0

Grilled Chicken Artichoke

$7.89
0

Buffalo Chicken

$7.89
0

Steak, Artichoke & Mushroom

$7.89
0

Advertisment

poor boy subs - cold subs

9 items

Italian Assorted

Sicilian hot soppressata, hot cappicola and pepperoni.

$7.89
0

Baked Ham

$7.89
0

Genoa Salami

$7.89
0

Tuna

$7.89
0

Veggie

$7.89
0

Old Fashioned Assorted

Turkey, ham and salami.

$7.89
0

Turkey

$7.89
0

Cappicola

$7.89
0

Cheese

$7.89
0

hot subs

7 items

Meatball or Chicken Parmigiano

Covered with our red sauce, pecorino romano and mozzarella.

$7.89
0

Bay Burger

A 3 grill pressed burgers with loads of bacon, melted cheddar, lettuce, tomato and mayo.

$7.89
0

Buffalo Chicken

Crispy chicken tossed in our buffalo wing sauce. Covered in mozzarella, baked and topped with bleu cheese.

$7.89
0

Goodman Delite

Grilled chicken or steak with mushrooms and artichoke hearts in a light sauce. Toasted and topped with provolone.

$8.29
0

The Capo

Grilled steak with capicola, spinach and provolone cheese.

$8.89
0

Great Steak-Out

Sirloin steak with mushrooms, peppers and onions topped with provolone cheese and country sweet sauce.

$8.89
0

Steak in the Grass

Shaved sirloin steak with fresh spinach, onions, banana peppers and garlic. Grilled and topped with provolone cheese.

$8.89
0

pizza

1 items

Pizza

Small 10'' slices cheese toppings $0.99 each, large 14" 12 slices cheese toppings $1.69 each. sheet 32 slices cheese toppings $2.89 each, medium 12" 8 slices cheese toppings $1.49 each. ext

$7.99
0

plates

6 items

Hamburger

$8.39
0

Steak

$8.39
0

Italian Sausage

$8.39
0

Cheeseburger

$8.39
0

Chicken Finger

$8.39
0

Big Dog

$8.39
0

classic & specialty pizzas

11 items

Pizza DiVinci

Tomato basil sauce with fresh tomato, fresh torn basil leaves, ricotta and mozzarella.

$10
0

Garlic Garden

Delicious garlic sauce and spinach, Spanish onions and fresh tomatoes over shredded mozzarella cheese.

$10
0

Buffalo Chicken Pie

Made with our Authentic Buffalo Wing sauce, diced crispy chicken, topped with shredded mozzarella cheese and served with bleu cheese

$10
0

Steak-Out Pie

Shaved steak with sauteed bell peppers and spanish onions with mozzarella over garlic sauce and a touch of country sweet sauce.

$10
0

Breakfast Pizza

Western omelet, italian frittata, my way breakfast pizza.

$10
0

Pizza Sicilia

Our famous red sauce, diced onions, hot banana peppers, spicy pepperoni, italian sausage and pecorino romano.

$10
0

Three Meat Pie

Your choice of three meat toppings, loads of freshly shredded mozzarella cheese and our classic red sauce.

$10
0

Veggie Weggie

Our Famous Red Sauce with fresh mozzarella, bell peppers, mushrooms and spanish onions tops off this classic pie.

$10
0

Calzones

Mozzarella and ricotta small pizza prices apply

$10
0

Our Famous Deluxe

Our signature sauce, loaded with mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, bell peppers and Spanish onions.

$10.95
0

Elite Eight

Our famous red sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, ham, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions & olives.

$12
0
View Bay Goodman Pizza's menu prices, nutrition, locations and coupons

Browse latest menu of Bay Goodman Pizza's desserts Menu, starters & snacks Menu, sides Menu, wings & fingers Menu, burgers Menu, salads Menu, grilled panini Menu, wraps Menu, poor boy subs - cold subs Menu, hot subs Menu, pizza Menu, plates Menu, classic & specialty pizzas Menu, Breakfast menu, Lunch menu and Dinner menu everything is included.

Restaurant Information

Categories:
pizza
Rating
4 (126 reviews)
Click on a star to rate this restaurant

About Bay Goodman Pizza

Bay Goodman Pizza offers Desserts, Starters & Snacks & Sides across 75 menu items, with prices from $1.69 to $12.00. Browse the full Bay Goodman Pizza menu with current prices — budget picks like the $1.69 Chocolate Chunk Cookie — updated August 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.

4 ★ · 126 reviews

Rate & review

Reviews are checked before they appear. Be honest & kind.

No reviews yet — be the first to review Bay Goodman Pizza.

Photos

No photos yet — add the first one.

Similar Binge-Worthy Restaurants

More budget-friendly fast food and value menu alternatives to Bay Goodman Pizza

See all →
C

Catania Cafe

coffee · Binge-worthy picks
S

Sunset

burger · Binge-worthy picks
L

Lexington Pizza Parlour

italian · Binge-worthy picks
S

Speck's Deli & Gourmet Pizza

pizza · Binge-worthy picks
A

Annie's

italian · Binge-worthy picks
M

Miceli's

italian · Binge-worthy picks

Own Bay Goodman Pizza?

Claim it to update prices & details, post offers, and get a verified ✓ badge guests trust.

Free while we're in beta. Later a one-time $99 lifetime, then monthly plans — early claims stay free.

Claim this restaurant →
Spotted wrong info, or want this page updated or removed? Contact us →

Opens your email app to [email protected] — we attach this page's link so we can reply faster.

Bay Goodman Pizza Menu — Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.

What is on the Bay Goodman Pizza menu?
Bay Goodman Pizza offers 75 menu items across pizza and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.

How much does Bay Goodman Pizza food cost?
Menu prices at Bay Goodman Pizza range from $1.69 for the most affordable options up to $12.00 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Bay Goodman Pizza cheapest items guide.

What are the cheapest items at Bay Goodman Pizza?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Bay Goodman Pizza, visit the dedicated Bay Goodman Pizza cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $1.69.

Is Bay Goodman Pizza good value for money?
Bay Goodman Pizza holds a customer rating of 4/5 based on 126 reviews. To judge value more accurately, compare Bay Goodman Pizza side-by-side with similar restaurants: Bay Goodman Pizza vs Pizza Hut or Bay Goodman Pizza vs Domino's Pizza.

How does Bay Goodman Pizza compare to similar restaurants nearby?
Bay Goodman Pizza serves pizza cuisine alongside similar restaurants like Pizza Hut, Domino's Pizza, Sunset. Use our comparison pages to see a direct price-by-price breakdown: Bay Goodman Pizza vs Pizza Hut, Bay Goodman Pizza vs Domino's Pizza.