Skip to content
n

72nd St Bagel menu

4.0139 ratings

Prices, calorie guide, and order-online options in one place

154 items $1.15 to $13.80 sandwiches Add photos
Coupons Order

Advertisements

Prices may vary. Please confirm at the restaurant before ordering.

create your own salad $8.45

4 items

Create Your Own Salad

choose any 7 items.

0

Create Your Own Salad

greens choice: romaine, spinach, mixed greens.

0

Create Your Own Salad

salad dressings: balsamic vinegar, french dressing, creamy italian dressing, sesame ginger dressing, italian dressing, lemon juice, low-fat honey dijon dressing, fat-free french dressing, light itali

0

Create Your Own Salad

salad toppings: beets, bell peppers, broccoli, capers, carrots, cherry tomato, chick peas, chopped tomato, chow mein, corn, cucumbers, egg whites, feta cheese, grape leaves, hard-boiled eggs, hearts

$0.5
0

knishes $3.75

5 items

Potato Knish

0

Mushroom Knish

0

Spinach Knish

0

Sweet Potato Knish

0

Kasha Knish

0

Advertisements

fresh fruits

3 items

Banana

$0.5
0

Apple

$0.85
0

Fruit Salad

$4.95
0

bagels

4 items

Mini Bagel

$0.9
0

Bagel

$1.15
0

Flages

flat bagel.

$1.75
0

1 Dozen Bagels

1 bagel free. please indicate bagel flavors below and indicate in special instructions quantity of each.

$13.8
0

Advertisements

bagels & cheese spreads

11 items

Bagel & Butter

$1.5
0

Bagel & Jelly

$1.5
0

Bagel, Butter & Jelly

$2
0

Bagel & Cream Cheese

$2.75
0

Bagel & Tofu Cream Cheese

$3.25
0

Bagel & Peanut Butter

$3.25
0

Bagel & Flavored Cream Cheese

$3.5
0

Bagel & Flavored Tofu Cream Cheese

$3.5
0

Bagel & Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese

$3.75
0

Bagel & Strawberry Cream Cheese

$3.75
0

Bagel & Lox Spread

$4.25
0

beverages

20 items

Coffee

$1.5
0

Flavored Coffee

flavored coffee choice: french vanilla, hazelnut

$1.5
0

Tea

tea selection: english breakfast, earl grey, peppermint, chamomile, black raspberry, lemon zinger, orange spice.

$1.5
0

Flavored Tea

$1.5
0

Hot Chocolate

$1.5
0

Canned Soda

soda selection: coke, diet coke, pepsi, diet pepsi, caffeine-free diet coke, sprite, diet sprite, dr. pepper, diet dr. pepper, ginger ale, diet ginger ale, sunkist, diet sunkist, cream soda, diet cre

$1.95
0

Snapple

snapple selection: peach iced tea, diet peach iced tea, raspberry iced tea, diet raspberry iced tea, orangeade, grapeade, iced tea.

$1.95
0

Espresso

$2
0

Poland Spring Water

$2
0

Iced Tea

$2.25
0

Yoo-Hoo

$2.25
0

Nesquik Chocolate Milk

$2.25
0

Vitamin Water

vitamin water selection: multi-v citrus frost, energy tropical citrus, focus kiwi strawberry.

$2.5
0

Iced Coffee

$2.75
0

Fresh Squeezed Juice

juice selection: orange, grape fruit

$2.95
0

Cappuccino

$3.5
0

Latte

$3.5
0

Iced Cappuccino

$4.45
0

Iced Latte

$4.45
0

Tropicana

tropicana selection: orange, grapefruit, strawberry orange banana, orange tangerine.

$4.95
0

Advertisements

side salads

4 items

Macaroni Side Salad

$1.75
0

Potato Side Salad

$1.75
0

Coleslaw Side Salad

$1.75
0

Israeli Side Salad

$2.5
0

baked goods

7 items

Fat-Free Chocolate Chip Cookie

$1.75
0

Muffin

$2.75
0

Fat-Free Muffin

$2.75
0

Danish

$2.75
0

Crossiant

$2.75
0

Jumbo Cookie

$2.75
0

Assorted Bakery Cookies

$12
0

Advertisements

cheese spreads

10 items

1/4 Lb. Butter

$2.25
0

1/4 Lb. Jelly

$2.25
0

1/4 Lb. Cream Cheese

$2.25
0

1/4 Lb. Peanut Butter

$2.75
0

1/4 Lb. Flavored Cream Cheese

$2.95
0

1/4 Lb. Tofu Cream Cheese

$2.95
0

1/4 Lb. Flavored Tofu Cream Cheese

$2.95
0

1/4 Lb. Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese

$3
0

1/4 Lb. Strawberry Cream Cheese

$3
0

1/4 Lb. Lox Spread

$3.25
0

salad spreads

12 items

1/4 Lb. Egg Salad

$2.5
0

1/4 Lb. Hummus Salad

$2.5
0

1/4 Lb. Babaganoush Salad

$2.5
0

1/4 Lb. Eggplant Salad

$2.5
0

1/4 Lb. Fat-Free Egg White Salad

$2.75
0

1/4 Lb. Chopped Herring Salad

$2.75
0

1/4 Lb. Classic Tuna Salad

$3.5
0

1/4 Lb. Fat-Free Tuna Salad

$3.75
0

1/4 Lb. Vegetable Tuna Salad

$3.75
0

1/4 Lb. Curry Tuna Salad

$3.75
0

1/4 Lb. White Fish Salad

$3.95
0

1/4 Lb. Baked Salmon Salad

$3.95
0

cheese

4 items

1/4 Lb. American Cheese

$2.75
0

1/4 Lb. Muenster Cheese

$2.75
0

1/4 Lb. Cheddar Cheese

$2.75
0

1/4 Lb. Fresh Mozzarella Cheese

$3.95
0

pizza

2 items

Pizza Slice

$2.95
0

Pizza

$6.95
0

breakfast

4 items

Oatmeal

$3
0

Challah French Toast

$6.25
0

South Of The Border Special

scrambled eggs, cheese, lettuce, tomato and jalapeño in a wrap. served with homefries.

$6.95
0

Challah French Toast With Eggs

$7.95
0

egg sandwiches

4 items

2 Scrambled Eggs Sandwich

$3.25
0

2 Scrambled Egg Whites Sandwich

$3.95
0

Egg & Cheese Sandwich

$3.95
0

Egg Whites & Cheese Sandwich

$4.95
0

smoothie bar

1 item

Smoothie

smoothie fruits: watermelon, cranberry, mango, strawberry, banana, pineapple, cantaloupe, blueberry, honeydew.

$3.95
0

bagel & cheese

4 items

Bagel & American Cheese

$4.25
0

Bagel & Muenster Cheese

$4.25
0

Bagel & Cheddar Cheese

$4.25
0

Bagel & Fresh Mozzarella Cheese

$4.95
0

homemade soups

3 items

Homemade Soup

$4.5
0

Large Soup & Bagel

$4.95
0

Soup & Salad Special

$9.45
0

bagels & salad spreads

12 items

Bagel & Hummus Salad

$4.95
0

Bagel & Babaganoush Salad

$4.95
0

Bagel & Eggplant Salad

$4.95
0

Bagel & Egg Salad

$5.25
0

Bagel & Chopped Herring Salad

$5.5
0

Bagel & Fat-Free Egg White Salad

$5.95
0

Bagel & Classic Tuna Salad

$6.25
0

Bagel & Fat-Free Tuna Salad

$6.95
0

Bagel & Vegetable Tuna Salad

$6.95
0

Bagel & Curry Tuna Salad

$6.95
0

Bagel & White Fish Salad

$7.45
0

Bagel & Baked Salmon Salad

$7.45
0

fish

5 items

1/4 Lb. Cream Herring

$5.25
0

1/4 Lb. Nova Scotia Salmon

$7.95
0

1/4 Lb. Kippered Salmon

baked.

$7.95
0

1/4 Lb. Smoked White Fish

$7.95
0

1/4 Lb. Smoked Sable

$10.75
0

breakfast specials

6 items

Breakfast Platter

two eggs any-style served with bagel and homefries.

$5.45
0

Omelet With 2 Choices

$6.45
0

Italian Omelet

mozzarella, tomato and basil.

$7.95
0

Garden Omelet

feta cheese, tomato and olives.

$7.95
0

Fat-Free Omelet

made with egg whites, broccoli and mushroom.

$7.95
0

Westside Omelet

nova and onion.

$8.25
0

falafel

2 items

Falafel Sandwich

lettuce, tomato, falafel and hummus packed in pita bread.

$5.45
0

Falafel Platter

falafel served on a bed of lettuce and tomato with israeli salad and pita bread on the side.

$7.95
0

bagel & fish

5 items

Bagel & Cream Herring

$6.95
0

Bagel & Smoked White Fish

$8.25
0

Bagel & Nova Scotia Salmon

$8.75
0

Bagel & Kippered Salmon

baked.

$8.75
0

Bagel & Smoked Sable

$11.95
0

wraps

5 items

1. Greek Salad Wrap

$7.95
0

2. Tuna, Avocado & Cucumber Wrap

$7.95
0

3. Tuna & Muenster Cheese Wrap

israeli salad and pickle.

$7.95
0

5. Fresh Mozzarella Wrap

roasted pepper, tomato, basil and pesto.

$7.95
0

4. Smoked Salmon Wrap

scallion cream cheese, cucumber, lettuce and capers.

$9.95
0

panini

5 items

1. Eggplant & Mozzarella Panini

tomato and vinaigrette.

$7.95
0

2. Tuna & Cheese Panini

avocado and roasted pepper.

$7.95
0

3. Three Cheese Panini

roasted pepper.

$7.95
0

4. Mozzarella & Tomato Panini

basil and roasted peppers.

$7.95
0

5. Smoked Salmon Panini

cream cheese.

$9.95
0

combo sandwiches

7 items

1. Tuna Combo Sandwich

muenster cheese, israeli salad and pickle.

$8.45
0

2. Fresh Mozzarella Combo Sandwich

tomato, roast pepper, basil and pesto or balsamic vinegar.

$8.45
0

3. Tuna & Sephardic Eggplant Combo Sandwich

with cucumber.

$8.45
0

4. Tuna & Sliced Egg Combo Sandwich

black olives and red onions.

$8.45
0

7. Tuna & Melted Cheese Combo Sandwich

tomato and avocado.

$8.45
0

5. Baked Salmon Combo Sandwich

scallion cream cheese, cucumber, tomato and onion.

$9.95
0

6. Smoked Salmon Combo Sandwich

scallion cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, capers and onion.

$9.95
0

salad platters

4 items

1. Egg Salad Platter

lettuce, tomato, cucumber and pickle served with a scoop of egg salad.

$8.95
0

2. Tuna Salad Platter

lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, pickle, olives and sliced hard-boiled egg served with a scoop of tuna salad.

$9.45
0

3. Mediterranean Salad Platter

lettuce, tomato, olives, jalapeño and pickle served with scoops of hummus, eggplant and babaganoush.

$9.45
0

4. Mozzarella Salad Platter

fresh mozzarella, crisp romaine, capers and roasted peppers served with house vinaigrette.

$9.45
0

fish platter

1 item

Fish Platter

served on a bed of lettce with sliced tomatoes, cucumbers, capers, black olives, bermuda onions and your choice of fish, cream cheese and bagel.

$12.95
0

About 72nd St Bagel

72nd St Bagel features Create Your Own Salad $8.45, Knishes $3.75 & Fresh Fruits across 154 menu items, with prices from $1.15 to $13.80. Explore the full 72nd St Bagel menu with current prices — budget picks like the $0.50 Create Your Own Salad — updated September 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.

Categories: sandwiches · bagels · vegetarian

Reviews & Photos

From people who've eaten at 72nd St Bagel

4 ★

139 reviews

Rate & review

Reviews are checked before they appear. Be honest & kind.

No reviews yet. Be the first to review 72nd St Bagel.

Help keep this page accurate

Wrong info, feedback, or want this page updated or removed? Contact us →

Opens your email app to hi@menuxp.com. We attach this page's link so we can reply faster.

Add a photo of 72nd St Bagel

Photos are reviewed before they appear.

Drag & drop a photo here

or click to browse

Suggest a Correction

72nd St Bagel menu

Reviewed before any change is made. Thanks for keeping menus accurate!

Similar Binge-Worthy Restaurants

More budget-friendly fast food and value menu alternatives to 72nd St Bagel

See all →
KFC

KFC

chicken · Binge-worthy picks
Long Island Bagel Cafe

Long Island Bagel Cafe

coffee · Binge-worthy picks
T

The Glasshouse Cafe

coffee · Binge-worthy picks
Between The Buns

Between The Buns

burger · Binge-worthy picks
M

Marathon

american · Binge-worthy picks
Jimmy John's

Jimmy John's

sandwiches · Binge-worthy picks

Own 72nd St Bagel?

Claim it to update prices & details, post offers, and get a verified ✓ badge guests trust.

Free while we're in beta. Later a one-time $99 lifetime, then monthly plans. Early claims stay free.

Claim this restaurant →

72nd St Bagel Menu: Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.

What is on the 72nd St Bagel menu?
72nd St Bagel offers 154 menu items across sandwiches and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.

How much does 72nd St Bagel food cost?
Menu prices at 72nd St Bagel range from $1.15 for the most affordable options up to $13.80 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the 72nd St Bagel cheapest items guide.

What are the cheapest items at 72nd St Bagel?
For the lowest-cost meal options at 72nd St Bagel, visit the dedicated 72nd St Bagel cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $1.15.

Is 72nd St Bagel good value for money?
72nd St Bagel holds a customer rating of 4/5 based on 139 reviews. To judge value more accurately, compare 72nd St Bagel side-by-side with similar restaurants: 72nd St Bagel vs Craig's or 72nd St Bagel vs Jimmy John's.

How does 72nd St Bagel compare to similar restaurants nearby?
72nd St Bagel serves sandwiches cuisine alongside similar restaurants like Craig's, Jimmy John's, KFC. Use our comparison pages to see a direct price-by-price breakdown: 72nd St Bagel vs Craig's, 72nd St Bagel vs Jimmy John's.