Check out these hand sized pies in store. Flavors change every week.
$2
0
Small Apple Dulce de Leche Pie
An all-American classic; covered in sweet caramel dulce de leche goodness.
$8
0
Small Apple Blueberry Pie
Our apple blueberry pie perfectly sized for you.
$8
0
Small Bourbon Pecan Pie
The perfect sized pecan pie to curl up next to the fireplace with. The perfect marriage of pecans and bourbon come together in this pie. Notes of vanilla, oak, and spices shine through to give this c
$9
0
Small Maple Pumpkin Pie
Perfectly sized and a perfectly sweet spin on your holiday favorite.
$9
0
Small Peach Bourbon Pie
Our peach bourbon pie downsized to share.
$9
0
Small S'mores Pie
Homemade fluff, chocolate ganache, and graham crackers in our tasty pie crust. Our most popular pie right sized for 2 to share.
$10
0
Large Traditional Apple Pie
Pure, unadulterated, American pie. No twists here, just everybody's favorite dessert, here for the holidays.
$18
0
Large Apple Dulce de Leche Pie
An all-American classic; covered in sweet caramel dulce de leche goodness.
$19
0
Large Traditional Pumpkin Pie
A pie the pilgrims would be proud of (if they had pie).
$19
0
Large Traditional Pecan Pie
Nutty and sweet, a main stay for the dessert table around the holidays.
$19
0
Large Apple Blueberry Pie
Apples and blueberries in our delicious pie crust.
$19
0
Large Bourbon Pecan Pie
The perfect marriage of pecans and bourbon come together in this pie. Notes of vanilla, oak, and spices shine through to give this classic pie a little more personality.
$20
0
Large Maple Pumpkin Pie
A Thanksgiving must, brought to the next level with real maple syrup.
$20
0
Large Peach Bourbon Pie
We take peaches at the peak of the season and give them a nice bath in bourbon for this Summer favorite.
$20
0
Large S'mores Pie
Homemade fluff, chocolate ganache, and graham crackers in our tasty pie crust.
A chewy cookie loaded with tart cherries and a smooth almond taste.
$3
0
Chocolate Coffee Stout Cookie
3 of our favorite things combined into one amazing cookie.
$3
0
Malted Chocolate Chip Cookie
Chocolate chip cookie meets everyone's favorite classic drink - a malt! Nutty barley comes through and provides a rich sweetness to everyone's favorite cookie.
$3
0
Mexican Hot Chocolate Cookie
We were inspired by Mexican hot chocolate during one of our baking sessions. This chocolate chocolate chip cookie has cayenne, cinnamon, and other spices for a unique treat.
$3
0
Oatmeal Currant Cookie
Our spin on a traditional oatmeal cookie, given a refreshing flavor with cardamom and orange zest.
$3
0
Harvest Cookie
All the flavors of fall in 1 cookie. Chock full of dried cranberries, walnuts, sun flower seeds and a touch of cinnamon.
$3
0
Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookie
We took our classic recipe and made it gluten free.
$3.5
0
Gluten Free Coconut Cherry Cookie
Coconut, tart cherries, and a hint of lime combined in 1 awesome cookie.
Our New York style cheesecake with a hint of lemon.
$5.5
0
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Our pumpkin cheesecake delivers with real pumpkin and a hint of your favorite fall spices.
$6
0
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cheesecake
A perfect marriage of semi-sweet chocolate and natural peanut butter, swirled into our original cheesecake.
$6
0
Nutella Cheesecake
Everybody's favorite spread, swirled right in the middle.
$6
0
Advertisements
About The Fat Cardinal Bakery
The Fat Cardinal Bakery offers Pies, Cookies & Brownies across 34 menu items, with prices from $2.00 to $21.00. Browse the full The Fat Cardinal Bakery menu with current prices — budget picks like the $2.00 Hand Pies — updated September 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.
The Fat Cardinal Bakery Menu: Frequently Asked Questions
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the The Fat Cardinal Bakery menu?
The Fat Cardinal Bakery offers 34 menu items across Other and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does The Fat Cardinal Bakery food cost?
Menu prices at The Fat Cardinal Bakery range from $2.00 for the most affordable options up to $21.00 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the The Fat Cardinal Bakery cheapest items guide.
What are the cheapest items at The Fat Cardinal Bakery?
For the lowest-cost meal options at The Fat Cardinal Bakery, visit the dedicated The Fat Cardinal Bakery cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $2.00.
