Our double chocolate devils food cake with chocolate chips topped with our signature rich chocolate buttercream frosting and topped with a rolo because rolos are awesome
$3
0
Bunny Bites
Our moist carrot cake made with pecans and pineapples topped with our signature cream cheese frosting and orange jimmies, our little bunnies love these
$3
0
Chocolamento
Our favorite chocolate buttermilk cake with chocolate chips topped with our mint buttercream and a piece of our favorite chocolate mint.
$3
0
Tuxedo
Our double chocolate buttermilk cake with chocolate chips topped with our flavorful vanilla buttercream.
$3
0
Alfred Hitchocolate
Our moist and flavorful vanilla cake topped with our signature rich chocolate buttercream frosting and rainbow sprinkles, this is our main choice for our family birthday parties.
$3
0
Blonde Bombshell
Our light but flavorful vanilla cake topped with our favorite vanilla buttercream frosting and rainbow sprinkles.
$3
0
Opposites Attract
Our chocolate buttermilk cake with chocolate chips topped with our peanut butter buttercream and a mini peanut butter cup.
$3
0
Over the Rainbow
Its our fruitiest combo, making a play on rainbow sherbet with a lemon, strawberry and orange trio cake topped with our fresh strawberry buttercream.
$3
0
Key Lime-O-Licious
Our key lime cake topped with our signature cream cheese frosting with graham cracker crumbs and green sanding sugar. Some of our family members actually argue over who likes this more.
$3
0
Cherry Blossom
Our green tea cake is lightly flavored with green tea and topped with our lychee buttercream and red sprinkles. Made to appease our family tea aficionado.
$3
0
Cookies and Cream
Our favorite chocolate buttermilk cake topped with oreo cookies and our signature cream cheese frosting
Ice cold lemonade, nice and tart lemon flavor with a touch of orange to sweeten perfect to quench your thirst
$1
0
Iced Coffee
Our freshly brewed french roast coffee iced to perfection. Simple syrup available to sweeten to taste as well as whole milk or half and half
$1
0
Bottled Water
Ice cold and refreshing
$1
0
Whole Milk
$1
0
Milk Reduced Fat
$1
0
Chocolate Milk
Reduced fat milk with a little chocolate to go with it
$1
0
Coffee
Our signature freshly brewed french roast with all the fixins. Available by the cup or air pot. Small cup $1.00 Large cup $1.50 Air pot rental with accoutrements $12.00
$1
0
Tea
Black tea, green tea, herbal tea. Check out our selections at the counter. Red Rose black tea available by request from our family tea drinkers stash in the kitchen. Small $1.00 large $1.50, catered
$1
0
Red Bull
Regular or diet ice cold and waiting to give you wings
A vegan edition of our moist carrot cake made with pecans and pineapples topped with our signature cream cheese frosting and orange jimmies
$3
0
Impeach My Hunger
Our moist and delicious vanilla cake filled with peach cobbler with our vanilla buttercream frosting with a dust of cinnamon. These are a family favorite for summer BBQs.
$3.25
0
Lemon Drop
Our sweet but tangy moist lemon cake filled with our fresh lemon curd and topped with our fresh lemon buttercream and a candy lemon slice. Made with lemons from our family trees and so refreshing
$3.25
0
Hella Nutella
Our light and flavorful vanilla cake filled with Nutella topped with Nutella buttercream and caramelized hazelnut pieces. An homage to our italian grandma wilhelmina.
$3.25
0
Elvis is in the Building
Our fresh banana cake filled with our yummy homemade caramel topped with peanut butter buttercream frosting and peanut butter chips. Head baker has been known to demand dancing in return for these.
$3.25
0
Samoa
Our rich chocolate devils food cake with chocolate chips filled with our homemade caramel topped with our signature cream cheese frosting, toasted coconut and a drizzle of caramel.
$3.25
0
Pecand Madness
Our double chocolate cake filled and topped with our homemade thick coconut pecan frosting.
$3.25
0
Blueberries and Cream
Light vanilla cake filled with blueberry compote and topped with cream cheese frosting and a dollop of compote
$3.25
0
Toasted Coconut
Coconut almond cake filled with lemon curd, topped with cream cheese frosting and toasted coconut. Divine
$3.25
0
School Days
Vanilla cake filled with grape jelly and topped with peanut butter buttercream
$3.25
0
Peaches & Cream
Vanilla cake filled with peach compote and topped with our luscious cream cheese frosting
$3.25
0
Caramel Apple
Fresh apple cake filled with caramel, topped with our signature cream cheese frosting and a drizzle of caramel
$3.25
0
Banana Split
Our yummy banana cake filled with homemade fudge sauce topped with vanilla buttercream toasted pecans and a maraschino cherry
$3.25
0
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Our decadent pumpkin cake filled with cheesecake filling and topped with our cream cheese frosting and graham cracker crumbs
Our family recipe makes these handmade cinnamon rolls worth getting up early for. Fresh out of the oven every morning and drizzled with our delicious frosting, you wont hit that snooze button again
$3
0
Take n Bake Cinnamon Rolls Half Dozen
Our delicious cinnamon rolls packed for you to take home and bake to perfection
$15
0
Take n Bake Cinnamon Rolls Dozen
Our delicious cinnamon rolls packaged for you to take home and bake to perfection. Clear simple instructions and cream cheese frosting included
$30
0
Breakfast Meeting Special
Two dozen mini cinnamon rolls and a carafe of coffee and/or an assortment of teas
A vegan edition of our moist carrot cake made with pecans and pineapples topped with our signature cream cheese frosting and orange jimmies, our little bunnies love these
$3.5
0
Gluten Free Gentlemen Prefer Reds
Vegan and Gluten Free: our southern red velvet cake topped with our signature cream cheese frosting
$3.5
0
Vegan Gentlemen Prefer Reds
Vegan and Gluten Free: our southern red velvet cake topped with our signature cream cheese frosting
$3.5
0
Gluten Free Lemon Drops
Our sweet but tangy moist lemon cake filled with our fresh lemon curd and topped with our fresh lemon buttercream and a candy lemon slice.
$3.5
0
Double Trouble Gluten Free
Your chocolate Gluten Free with our double chocolate devils food cake with chocolate chips topped with our signature rich chocolate buttercream frosting and topped with a rolo.
$3.5
0
Fresh Banana Vegan
$3.5
0
Blonde Bombshell Gluten Free
A Gluten free or vegan version of our light but flavorful vanilla cake topped with our favorite vanilla buttercream frosting and rainbow sprinkles.
$3.5
0
Blonde Bombshell Vegan
A gluten free or vegan version of our light but flavorful vanilla cake topped with our favorite vanilla buttercream frosting and rainbow sprinkles.
Our double chocolate buttermilk cake topped with our baileys irish cream frosting. An homage to our many irish roots.
$3.5
0
Cosmopolitan
Our cranberry cosmopolitan cake topped with our cosmopolitan buttercream.
$3.5
0
Irish Car Bomb
Chocolate guinness draught cake filled with jameson irish Whiskey and chocolate cream, topped with baileys irish cream buttercream frosting.
$3.5
0
Margarita
Our margarita cake infused heavily with tequila and topped with our tequila and lime buttercream frosting, and sprinkled with tequila salt. An homage to our hispanic roots.
$3.5
0
Lemon Bomb
Our lemony cake infused with abolute vodka and topped with our vodka lemon buttercream frosting.
$3.5
0
Pina Colada
Our pina colada cake infused with malibu coconut rum, and topped with our coconut rum butter cream frosting and sprinkled with toasted coconut. We love pina coladas but not so much getting caught in
$3.5
0
Screwdriver
Our light orange cake infused with absolute vodka and also topped with our vodka buttercream frosting.
$3.5
0
Strawberry Daiquiri
Our fresh strawberry cake soaked in dark spiced rum and topped with our fresh strawberry and spiced rum buttercream frosting.
$3.5
0
White Russian
Our double chocolate buttermilk cake topped with our absolute vodka and kahlua buttercream frosting.
With a crisp crust and moist inside. Made with a mixture of whole wheat flours and bread flour.
$7
0
About That Takes The Cake
That Takes The Cake offers Classic Cupcakes, Beverage & Daily Flavors across 81 menu items, with prices from $1.00 to $50.00. Browse the full That Takes The Cake menu with current prices — budget picks like the $1.00 Frosting Shots — updated September 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.
That Takes The Cake Menu: Frequently Asked Questions
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the That Takes The Cake menu?
That Takes The Cake offers 81 menu items across Other and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does That Takes The Cake food cost?
Menu prices at That Takes The Cake range from $1.00 for the most affordable options up to $50.00 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the That Takes The Cake cheapest items guide.
What are the cheapest items at That Takes The Cake?
For the lowest-cost meal options at That Takes The Cake, visit the dedicated That Takes The Cake cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $1.00.
