Sue's menu

Sautéed Oysters

One dozen oysters gently sautéed in a seasoned butter sauce served with garlic bread

Fried Oysters

One dozen oysters with tartar, cocktail or voodoo sauce

Andouille Ugly

Sue's spicy Andouille sausage and cheese dip served warm with fried flatbread chips, crackers or garlic bread

Boudi Balls

Six deep fried authentic Boudin Balls made right here in our own kitchen, served with Sue's Voodoo sauce

Cheese Curds

Wisconsin premium breaded white cheddar nuggets fried to perfection. Regular or jalapeño, served with marinara sauce

Fried Shrimp

1/4 pound Gulf Shrimp with tartar, cocktail or voodoo sauce

Garlic Sautéed Shrimp

1/4 pound Gulf shrimp gently sautéed in our seasoned butter sauce, with garlic bread

Cheese Baked Oysters

1/2 Dozen - baked to order with butter, Mozzarella and just enough seasoning with garlic bread. Parmesan or Feta may be substituted for Mozzarella

Spinach Baked Oysters

1/2 dozen - baked with a topping on Feta or Mozzarella, spinach, mushrooms and onions with garlic bread

Sue's Favorite Baked Oysters

Half dozen - baked with Mozzarella, Parmesan, sautéed mushrooms and onions, spices and white wine with garlic bread

Mediterranean Baked Oysters

1/2 dozen - baked with Mozzarella, Feta, Parmesan, Kalamata olives, scallions and white wine topped with crushed pita chips, with garlic bread.

Boiled Shrimp

Half pound shell-on oil Gulf shrimp with tartar, cocktail or voodoo sauce. Cooked to order, served warm or iced

Grouper Nouveau

A beautiful fillet of fresh grouper, grilled and topped with grilled onions, mushrooms and bell peppers. Add Gouda Grits, Sweet Potato Fries Or Cucumber Salad For $0.50

Grouper Creole

A grilled grouper fillet on a bed of rice, smothered with our classic Creole sauce, served with your choice of one side and garlic bread. Add Gouda Grits, Sweet Potato Fries Or Cucumber Salad For $0.

Grouper J. Michael

This is the ULTIMATE! a fresh grouper fillet grilled and draped over a bed of rice, smothered with tangy J. Michael sauce and topped with mushrooms and scallions. Serve with one side and garlic bread

Shrimp and Okra Gumbo

This traditional Louisiana recipe is all about the unadulterated flavor of the shrimp, just enough rice, and just enough heat. Served with garlic bread

Shrimp J. Michael

Created at the original J. Michael's in 1977. A thick and creamy, somewhat spicy sauce with a touch of curry, over a generous portion of shrimp with a side of rice, topped with mushrooms and scallion

Shrimp Creole

This is a dish often imitated but seldom prepared in an authentic way. One of our spiciest dishes, a hearty combination of tomatoes, onions, bell peppers and celery loaded with shrimp and served with

Hamburger Steak*

Fresh ground chuck seasoned and grilled to order, topped with freshly grilled mushrooms and our special homemade peppery gravy. Served with rice and your choice of a side and garlic bread

Garlic Sautéed Shrimp

A generous portion of Gulf shrimp, sautéed in our garlic butter sauce and choice of two sides and garlic bread

Fried Oyster Basket

Plenty of fresh oysters, fried just right

Fried Chicken Tender Basket

Breaded Breast Tenderloin Strips

Fried Fish Basket

White flaky Alaskan cold, a truly delicious fish

Fried Scallop Basket

Juicy little scallops, fried just right

Fried Shrimp Basket

A generous portion of perfectly fried Gulf shrimp

Seafood Platter

Delicious flaky Alaskan cod, tender juicy scallops, plump oysters and beautiful Gulf shrimp, tossed in seasonings made in-house and fried to perfection!

Shrimp or Oyster Sandwich

Fried shrimp or oysters on a hoagie roll, dressed with lettuce, tomato and onion. Served with Voodoo sauce on the side

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Choose American, Provolone, Cheddar or Swiss on grilled sourdough whole rye bread

Grilled Pimento Cheese Sandwich

Sue's homemade pimento cheese with a kick, on grilled sourdough or rye bread

White Albacore Tuna Salad Sandwich

Sue's special recipe! Served cold on rye or salad with lettuce, tomato and onion, we'll make it a Tuna melt with your choice of cheese (American, Cheddar, Swiss or Provolone)

Pulled Beef BBQ Sandwich

With Jamie's awesome tangy sauce on an onion roll. (Especially good with slaw!)

Fabulous Fish Sandwich

Flaky Cod filet, your choice of grilled or fried, served on a toasted onion roll with lettuce, tomato, and onion, with homemade tartar, cocktail or Voodoo sauce on the side

Your choice whole grilled whole fried tender chicken breast fillet covered with shredded Mozzarela on a toasted onion roll, served with lettuce, tomato and onion. Ranch, Honey Mustard or Voodoo on th

One Exceptional Burger*

1/2 pound fresh, ground chuck, hand-pattied, seasoned on the grill and cooked to your liking, served on a toasted onion roll. Include any one optional topping. Lettuce, tomato and onion. Grilled saue

Classic Reuben

Sliced corned beef, Swiss cheese and grilled sauerkraut on toasted New York rye, served with 1000 Island on the side

Roast Beef Supreme

Fallen-apart tender roast on an open face hoagie roll, smothered with peppery gravy made from it's own juices, sautéed onions and mushrooms, and Mozzarella cheese. A classic feast!

Saturday - Check our Special Board!

Tuesday - Black Beans and Rice

Served with Cheese Quesadilla

Wednesday - Spaghetti with Sue's Own Homemade Meat Sauce

Served with Garlic Bread

Thursday - Chicken and Sausage Jambalaya

A traditional spicy rice dish containing chunks of chicken breast and hot Andouille sausage. Served with Garlic Bread

Sunday - Sue's Grouper Chowder

This recipe started with Sue's Aunt Gen's Jolly Skipper Chowder and has been altered a little over the years. A creamy white chowder loaded with potatoes, onions, celery, bacon, Grouper and Sue's sea

Friday - Catfish Basket

Tender Domestic Pond - Raised catfish Filets served with your choice of corn or jalapeño fritters and your choice of two sides

Garlic Bread

Rice

Fritters (4) corn or Jalapeño

Slaw

Simple Side Salad

Pasta

French Fries

Fried Okra

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Fresh Tender Rutabagas

Sue's Cucumber Salad

Gouda Cheese Grits

Sweet Potato Waffle Fries

Slaw

A non-traditional slow made from cabbage and onions. Not your grandmother's sweet slaw!

Simple Side Salad

Mixed greens with freshly sliced mushrooms, onion and cherry tomato

Sue's Cucumber Salad

Fresh cucumber, tomato and red onion in a balsamic marinade

Sue's House Salad

Mixed greens with freshly sliced mushrooms, onion, cherry tomatoes, cucumber, pickled okra, pepperoncini pepper and Mozzarela cheese

Small Greek Salad

Mixed greens with freshly sliced mushrooms, onions, cherry tomatoes, cucumber, pickled okra, pepperoncini peppers, Kalamata olives, Mozzarela and feta cheeses

Large Greek Salad

A huge salad with all the ingredients in the small Greek, just much more of it!!

Soft Drinks, Tea and Coffee

Coca-Cola products include Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Pink Lemonade, Mr. Pibb, and Barq's Root Beer

Key Lime Pie

No description needed! Tart and Sweet

Frozen Chocolate Mousse Pie

A frozen two layer chocolate lover's delight. With a chocolate graham cracker crust

The Dessert Formerly Known as No Name Pie

A frozen creamy two layer confection, delicious beyond description! Graham cracker crust with caramel and toasted coconut and pecans

Jody's Creamy Tomato Soup

Made from scratch with puréed garlic, Onions, tomatoes and Parmesan, served with garlic bread

Red Beans and Rice

Loaded with a combination of Andouille and smoked sausage, few dishes are as notoriously delicious as red beans and rice. Served with garlic bread

And we do mean loaded! This soup is made with the finest fresh ingredients, served with garlic bread

Veggie Plate

Any three vegetable sides with garlic bread or fritters

Chicken and Dumplings

Comfort in a bowl! A timeless classic.

Spaghetti with Homemade Meat Sauce

Also our Wednesday special, so popular we serve it all the time! With garlic bread