Skip to content
S

Setauket Pastaria menu

3.0177 ratings

Prices, calorie guide, and order-online options in one place

179 items $1.25 to $29.00 Other Add photos
Coupons Order

Advertisements

Prices may vary. Please confirm at the restaurant before ordering.

side orders

13 items

Sauce on the Side

$0.5
0

Garlic Bread

$2.95
0

Garlic Knots

$3
0

Focaccia Bread

$3
0

Zeppole

$3.5
0

Pint of Tomato Sauce

$3.5
0

Pint of Marinara Sauce

$3.5
0

Garlic Bread with Melted Mozzarella

$3.95
0

Pasta

$3.95
0

Vegetable

$3.95
0

2 Sausage

$4.95
0

2 Meatball

$4.95
0

Pint of Vodka Sauce

$4.95
0

beverages

7 items

Fountain Drink

$1.25
0

Unsweetened Tea

$1.25
0

Pellegrino

$1.5
0

Coffee

$1.5
0

Tea

$1.5
0

Espresso

$2.5
0

Cappuccino

$3
0

Advertisements

pizza

11 items

Regular Pizza Slice

$2.76
0

Sicilian Pizza Slice

$2.76
0

Grandma Pizza Slice

$2.76
0

Stuffed Pizza Slice

$4.5
0

Marinara Pie

$10
0

16" Large Pie

$13
0

Margherita Pie

$15
0

Sicilian Pie

$16.5
0

Grandma Sicilian Pie

$16.5
0

Old Fashion Sicilian Pie

$16.5
0

Stuffed Meat Pizza

Meatball, ham, sausage, pepperoni and mozzarella.

$29
0

pastaria delights

14 items

Rice Ball

$3.5
0

Stuffed Garlic Knot

$3.75
0

Stuffed Garlic Chicken

$3.75
0

Pepperoni Pinwheel

$3.75
0

Rice Ball Parmigiana

$4.5
0

Broccoli Roll

With cheddar cheese.

$5.5
0

Meatball Roll

$5.5
0

Sausage, Pepper and Onion Roll

$5.5
0

Spinach Roll

$5.5
0

Chicken Roll

$5.5
0

Eggplant Roll

$5.5
0

Pepperoni Roll

$5.5
0

Special Roll

$5.5
0

Calzone

$6.5
0

Advertisements

soups

7 items

Soup of the Day

Call restaurant for the daily soup selection. Served with Italian bread and butter.

$3.95
0

Pasta Fagoli Soup

Served with Italian bread and butter.

$3.95
0

French Onion Soup

Served with Italian bread and butter.

$3.95
0

Chicken Soup

Served with Italian bread and butter.

$3.95
0

Tortellini Soup

Served with Italian bread and butter.

$3.95
0

Minestrone Soup

Served with Italian bread and butter.

$3.95
0

Stracciatella Soup

Served with Italian bread and butter.

$3.95
0

appetizers

21 items

French Fries with Ketchup

$4.95
0

Beer Battered Onion Rings with Ketchup

$5.95
0

Mozzarella Sticks with Tomato Sauce

$6.95
0

Stuffed Mushrooms

$7.95
0

Zucchini Sticks

$7.95
0

Spinach and Mushrooms

Sauteed in garlic and oil.

$7.95
0

Chicken Fingers

With honey mustard, french fries and ketchup.

$8.95
0

Homemade Bruschetta

$8.95
0

Buffalo Wings

With blue cheese.

$8.95
0

6 Baked Clams

Little Neck clams.

$9.95
0

Clams Casino

$9.95
0

Eggplant Rollatini

$9.95
0

4 Fried Calamari

With marinara sauce.

$10.95
0

Mussels Marinara

$10.95
0

Mussels White

$10.95
0

5 Fried Ravioli

$10.95
0

Maryland Crab Cakes

$10.95
0

Hot Antipasta

$11.95
0

4 Shrimp Cocktail

$12.95
0

4 Shrimp Scampi

$12.95
0

4 Fried Shrimp

$12.95
0

Advertisements

salads

11 items

House Salad

With mozzarella and house balsamic. Served with Italian bread and butter.

$5.95
0

Italian Salad

With mozzarella and balsamic vinaigrette. Served with Italian bread and butter.

$5.95
0

Caesar Salad

With Parmesan, Caesar dressing. Served with Italian bread and butter.

$5.95
0

Greek Salad

With feta and balsamic vinaigrette. Served with Italian bread and butter.

$6.95
0

Fresh Mozzarella and Tomatoes

With roasted peppers, balsamic vinaigrette. Served with Italian bread and butter.

$9.95
0

Warm Spinach Salad

With bacon and red onion. Served with Italian bread and butter.

$9.95
0

Calamari Salad

Lettuce, celery and lemons. Served with Italian bread and butter.

$10.95
0

Bosc Pear Salad

With Gorgonzola and raspberry vinaigrette. Served with Italian bread and butter.

$10.95
0

Antipasta Salad

Cold with salami, ham and provolone. Served with Italian bread and butter.

$11.95
0

Scungilli Salad

Lettuce, celery and lemons. Served with Italian bread and butter.

$13.95
0

Cold Seafood Salad

Mussels, calamari, shrimp, scallops and scungilli. Served with Italian bread and butter.

$24.95
0

heros

20 items

Meatball Hero

$5.95
0

Sausage Hero

$5.95
0

Salami and Provolone Hero

$6
0

Meatball and Mushrooms Hero

$6.5
0

Meatball and Peppers Hero

$6.5
0

Sausage and Peppers Hero

$6.5
0

Pepper and Egg Hero

$6.5
0

Potato and Egg Hero

$6.5
0

Chicken Cutlet

With peppers and onions.

$6.5
0

Italian Combo Hero

Salami, provolone, ham, lettuce, tomato and balsamic vinaigrette. \n

$6.5
0

Chicken Cutlet Hero with Lettuce and Tomato

Lettuce, tomato and mayo or dressing.

$6.95
0

Grilled Chicken Hero with Lettuce and Tomato

Lettuce, tomato and mayo or dressing.

$6.95
0

Eggplant Hero

$6.95
0

Cheese Steak Hero

With peppers and onions.

$6.95
0

Fresh Mozzarella and Prociutto Hero

$6.95
0

Fresh Mozzarella Hero

With roasted peppers on garlic bread.

$6.95
0

Veal Cutlet Hero

$8
0

Veal and Peppers Hero

$8.5
0

Veal and Mushrooms Hero

$8.5
0

Shrimp Hero

$8.95
0

Advertisements

create your own personal pie

2 items

Create Your Own Personal 12" Pie

$5.95
0

Gluten-Free Personal 10" Pie

$7.95
0

specialty pies

27 items

Margherita Pie

$8.5
0

White Pie

$8.5
0

Vegetable Pie

$8.5
0

Chicken Parmesan Pie

$8.5
0

Baked Ziti Pie

$8.5
0

Lasagna Pie

$8.5
0

Four Cheese Pie

$8.5
0

BBQ Chicken Pie

$8.5
0

Buffalo Pie

$8.5
0

Godfather Pie

$8.5
0

Chicken and Fresh Tomato Pie

$8.5
0

Meat Lovers Pie

Meatballs, sausage, pepperoni and ham.

$8.5
0

Eggplant Parmigian Pie

$8.5
0

Eggplant Rollatini Pie

Ham, ricotta and mozzarella.

$8.5
0

Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato with Balsamic Pie

$8.5
0

Bread Crumb, Grated Cheese and Onion Pie

$8.5
0

Chicken Marsala Pie

$8.5
0

Broccoli and Cheddar Pie

$8.5
0

Chicken Francese Pie

$8.5
0

Spinach and Fresh Tomato Pie

$8.5
0

Caesar Salad Pie

$12
0

Greek Salad Pie

$12
0

Pear Salad Pie

$12
0

Angel Hair Bolognese Pie

$12
0

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie

$12
0

Chicken and Roasted Peppers Pie

$12
0

Artichoke Pie

$12
0

pasta

12 items

Pasta with Tomato Sauce

Served with choice pasta, Italian bread and butter.

$9.95
0

Pasta with Marinara Sauce

Served with choice pasta, Italian bread and butter.

$9.95
0

Pasta with Mushroom Sauce

Served with choice pasta, Italian bread and butter.

$9.95
0

Pasta with Broccoli Garlic and Oil

Served with choice pasta, Italian bread and butter.

$10.95
0

Pasta with Meatballs

Served with choice pasta, Italian bread and butter.

$11.95
0

Pasta with Sweet Italian Sausage

Served with choice pasta, Italian bread and butter.

$11.95
0

Pasta with Vodka Sauce

Served with choice pasta, Italian bread and butter.

$11.95
0

Pasta Bolognese Meat Sauce

Served with choice pasta, Italian bread and butter.

$12.95
0

Pasta with Calamari Marinara

Served with choice pasta, Italian bread and butter.

$12.95
0

Pasta with Clam Sauce

Served with choice pasta, Italian bread and butter.

$13.95
0

Pasta with Scungilli

Served with choice pasta, Italian bread and butter.

$15.95
0

Pasta with Frutti di Mare

Clams, mussels, shrimp, scallops, scungilli and lobster tail. Served with choice pasta, Italian bread and butter.

$24.95
0

pasta specials

17 items

Baked Ziti with Ricotta

$12.95
0

Fettucini Alfredo with Broccoli

$12.95
0

Fettucini Alfredo with Broccoli Garlic and Oil

$12.95
0

Cavatelli

$12.95
0

Puttanesca

$12.95
0

Gnocchi

Ala Napolitano with fresh mozzarella.

$12.95
0

Primavera

$12.95
0

Baked Ziti with 2 Sausage

$13.95
0

Baked Ziti with 2 Meatballs

$13.95
0

Baked Lasagna

$13.95
0

6 Baked Ravioli

$13.95
0

Baked Manicotti

$13.95
0

Baked Stuffed Shells

$13.95
0

Fettucini Alfredo

$13.95
0

Carbonara

$13.95
0

Fettucini Alfredo with Shrimp

$17.95
0

Penne Ala Vodka with Shrimp

$17.95
0

chicken

7 items

Chicken Marsala with Mushrooms

Served with a side.

$14.95
0

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana

Served with a side.

$14.95
0

Chicken Francese

Served with a side.

$14.95
0

Chicken Rollatini

Served with a side.

$14.95
0

Chicken Sorrentino

Served with a side.

$14.95
0

Chicken Cacciatore

Served with a side.

$14.95
0

Chicken Scarpiello

Served with a side.

$14.95
0

vegetable

2 items

Eggplant Pamigiana

Served with a side.

$14.95
0

Eggplant Rollatini

Served with a side.

$15.95
0

veal

4 items

Veal Parmigiana

Served with a side.

$16.95
0

Veal and Peppers

Served with a side.

$16.95
0

Veal Marsala with Mushrooms

Served with a side.

$16.95
0

Veal Francese

Served with a side.

$16.95
0

shrimp

4 items

Shrimp Parmigiana

Served with a side.

$19.95
0

Shrimp Fried Diavolo

Served with a side.

$19.95
0

Shrimp Francese

Served with a side.

$19.95
0

Shrimp Scampi

Served with a side.

$19.95
0

About Setauket Pastaria

Setauket Pastaria serves Side Orders, Beverages & Pizza across 179 menu items, with prices from $1.25 to $29.00. See the full Setauket Pastaria menu with current prices — budget picks like the $0.50 Sauce on the Side — updated September 2026.

Categories: Other

Reviews & Photos

From people who've eaten at Setauket Pastaria

3 ★

177 reviews

Rate & review

Reviews are checked before they appear. Be honest & kind.

No reviews yet. Be the first to review Setauket Pastaria.

Help keep this page accurate

Wrong info, feedback, or want this page updated or removed? Contact us →

Opens your email app to [email protected]. We attach this page's link so we can reply faster.

Add a photo of Setauket Pastaria

Photos are reviewed before they appear.

Drag & drop a photo here

or click to browse

Suggest a Correction

Setauket Pastaria menu

Reviewed before any change is made. Thanks for keeping menus accurate!

Similar Binge-Worthy Restaurants

More budget-friendly fast food and value menu alternatives to Setauket Pastaria

See all →
W

Winebar

italian · Binge-worthy picks
Auntie Anne's

Auntie Anne's

other · Binge-worthy picks
H

Honey Baked Ham

deli food · Binge-worthy picks
G

Go Puff

other · Binge-worthy picks

Own Setauket Pastaria?

Claim it to update prices & details, post offers, and get a verified ✓ badge guests trust.

Free while we're in beta. Later a one-time $99 lifetime, then monthly plans. Early claims stay free.

Claim this restaurant →

Setauket Pastaria Menu: Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.

What is on the Setauket Pastaria menu?
Setauket Pastaria offers 179 menu items across Other and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.

How much does Setauket Pastaria food cost?
Menu prices at Setauket Pastaria range from $1.25 for the most affordable options up to $29.00 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Setauket Pastaria cheapest items guide.

What are the cheapest items at Setauket Pastaria?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Setauket Pastaria, visit the dedicated Setauket Pastaria cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $1.25.

Is Setauket Pastaria good value for money?
Setauket Pastaria holds a customer rating of 3/5 based on 177 reviews. To judge value more accurately, compare Setauket Pastaria side-by-side with similar restaurants: Setauket Pastaria vs Honey Baked Ham or Setauket Pastaria vs Winebar.

How does Setauket Pastaria compare to similar restaurants nearby?
Setauket Pastaria serves Other cuisine alongside similar restaurants like Honey Baked Ham, Winebar, Go Puff. Use our comparison pages to see a direct price-by-price breakdown: Setauket Pastaria vs Honey Baked Ham, Setauket Pastaria vs Winebar.