3 inch Pepperoni, sausage (housemade with fennel and sage), bacon (berkshire breed, house cured), ham (local varieties), meatballs (house made, fresh ground pork and beef), fresh ground beef, spicy c
0
Cheese Selection Items
Goat cheese (local capriole farms), mozzarella (grande whole milk), ricotta (grande sopraffina - super fine), smoked gouda, fresh mozzarella, chipotle colby cheddar (kenny's farmhouse), hard cheese b
0
Side Sauces Selection Items
Garlic butter $1.00, basil pesto $1.00, white truffle oil drizzle $1.00 ($2.00 upcharge for 18"), balsamic reduction $1.00, olive tapenade $1.00, sierra sauce $1.00, pizza sauce $0.50, ranch $0
0
Pizza by The Slice
Artisan Toppings $1.00 per topping, cheeses $1.50 each
$4
0
Vegan Pizza by the Slice
Artisan toppings $1.00 per topping cheeses $1.50 each
$5
0
18" Cheese Pizza
Our standard pizza is 18, made with whole milk mozzarella, italian plum tomato sauce, romano, oregano & basil. Artisan toppings $3.00 per topping, cheeses $4.00 each
$17
0
18" Cheese Vegan Pizza
Our standard pizza is 18, made with whole milk mozzarella, italian plum tomato sauce, romano, oregano & basil. Artisan toppings $3.00 per topping, cheeses $4.00 each
Garlicky, buttery rolls made from our fresh pizza dough. Crusty on the outside and light as air on the inside. A classic pizzeria snack!
$4
0
Cheesesticks 16"
With our gigantic breadsticks, brush them with our garlic infused butter, cover them with a sprinkle of romano and oregano. served with 2 sides of pizza sauce. add your favorite toppings
Calzone with our fresh homemade dough, we then add our pizza sauce, whole milk ricotta, basil, and whole milk mozzarella. you finish building your calzone by selecting three (3) toppings of your choi
Our White Pie is a combination of 3 cheeses, romano, whole milk mozzarella, and ricotta with hints of roasted garlic and herbs
$22
0
Margherita
A little twist on the classic. we use housemade basil pesto as the sauce, top it with fresh mozzarella and oven roasted tomatoes and finish it with balsamic reduction & fresh basil
$25
0
BBQ Chicken
our housemade smokey & sweet bbq sauce in place of the traditional pizza sauce and top it with whole milk mozzarella, smoked gouda, bacon, bbq chicken, red onions & finish it with fresh cilantro
$26
0
Hawaii 502
Same as our BBQ chicken except we place the chicken with ham and add pineapple
$26
0
Pizza Por Favor
Our basic cheese pizza except half mozzarella and half chipotle cheddar. we top this with chorizo, homemade ranchero sauce, fresh pico de gallo & queso fresco
$26
0
Righteous Pig
Our classic 18" pie and add all the pig we could find, meatballs, bacon, sausage, pepperoni & ham
$27
0
The Forager
A perfect harmony of flavors meet, cariole farms goat cheese, sheltowee farms mushrooms, caramelized onions, fresh thyme, and finished with white truffle Oil
Papalinos NY Pizzeria offers Pizza, Drinks & Desserts across 28 menu items, with prices from $2.00 to $27.00. Browse the full Papalinos NY Pizzeria menu with current prices — budget picks like the $2.00 Fountain Soda — updated September 2026.
Papalinos NY Pizzeria Menu: Frequently Asked Questions
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the Papalinos NY Pizzeria menu?
Papalinos NY Pizzeria offers 28 menu items across Other and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does Papalinos NY Pizzeria food cost?
Menu prices at Papalinos NY Pizzeria range from $2.00 for the most affordable options up to $27.00 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Papalinos NY Pizzeria cheapest items guide.
What are the cheapest items at Papalinos NY Pizzeria?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Papalinos NY Pizzeria, visit the dedicated Papalinos NY Pizzeria cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $2.00.
