Skip to content
N

NY Pizza Pie menu

4.0156 ratings

Prices, calorie guide, and order-online options in one place

20 items $2.99 to $11.99 pizza Add photos
Coupons Order

Advertisements

Prices may vary. Please confirm at the restaurant before ordering.

salads

4 items

House Salad

Fresh Arcadian salad mix, zima tomatoes, mixed peppers, red onions and cucumbers.

$2.99
0

Caesar Salad

Fresh cut romaine, fresh shaved Parmesan cheese and croutons.

$2.99
0

Spinach Strawberry Salad with Feta Cheese

Fresh spinach with red onions, mixed peppers, feta cheese, sliced strawberries and sunflower seeds.

$3.99
0

Caprese Salad

Zima tomatoes, cherry tomatoes, fresh basil, fresh mozzarella cheese and aged balsamic vinegar.

$3.99
0

garlic knots

1 item

Garlic Knots

Fresh made garlic knots with a fresh herb oil butter.

$2.99
0

Advertisements

fried items

4 items

Sweet Potato Fries

$2.99
0

Mac and Cheese Bites

$3.99
0

Cheese Curds

$3.99
0

Cheese Planks

$3.99
0

pizza by the slice

4 items

Regular Cheese Pizza Slice

Served with a 16 oz. fountain drink.

$4
0

Special Pizza Slice

Served with a 16 oz. fountain drink.

$5
0

2 Slices of Regular Cheese Pizza

Served with 2 16 oz. fountain drinks.

$7
0

2 Slices of Special Pizza

Served with 2 16 oz. fountain drinks.

$8
0

Advertisements

stromboli

1 item

Regular Stromboli

$6.99
0

wings

1 item

Wings

$6.99
0

Advertisements

calzones

1 item

1 Topping Calzone

Served with a side of our house gravy.

$7.99
0

pizza

1 item

Cheese Pizza

$9.99
0

Advertisements

specialty pizza

3 items

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

$11.99
0

BBQ Chicken Pizza

$11.99
0

White Pizza

$11.99
0

About NY Pizza Pie

NY Pizza Pie features Salads, Garlic Knots & Fried Items across 20 menu items, with prices from $2.99 to $11.99. Explore the full NY Pizza Pie menu with current prices — budget picks like the $2.99 House Salad — updated September 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.

Categories: pizza

Reviews & Photos

From people who've eaten at NY Pizza Pie

4 ★

156 reviews

Rate & review

Reviews are checked before they appear. Be honest & kind.

No reviews yet. Be the first to review NY Pizza Pie.

Help keep this page accurate

Wrong info, feedback, or want this page updated or removed? Contact us →

Opens your email app to [email protected]. We attach this page's link so we can reply faster.

Add a photo of NY Pizza Pie

Photos are reviewed before they appear.

Drag & drop a photo here

or click to browse

Suggest a Correction

NY Pizza Pie menu

Reviewed before any change is made. Thanks for keeping menus accurate!

Similar Binge-Worthy Restaurants

More budget-friendly fast food and value menu alternatives to NY Pizza Pie

See all →
C

Catania Cafe

coffee · Binge-worthy picks
S

Sunset

burger · Binge-worthy picks
L

Lexington Pizza Parlour

italian · Binge-worthy picks
S

Speck's Deli & Gourmet Pizza

pizza · Binge-worthy picks
A

Annie's

italian · Binge-worthy picks
M

Miceli's

italian · Binge-worthy picks

Own NY Pizza Pie?

Claim it to update prices & details, post offers, and get a verified ✓ badge guests trust.

Free while we're in beta. Later a one-time $99 lifetime, then monthly plans. Early claims stay free.

Claim this restaurant →

NY Pizza Pie Menu: Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.

What is on the NY Pizza Pie menu?
NY Pizza Pie offers 20 menu items across pizza and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.

How much does NY Pizza Pie food cost?
Menu prices at NY Pizza Pie range from $2.99 for the most affordable options up to $11.99 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the NY Pizza Pie cheapest items guide.

What are the cheapest items at NY Pizza Pie?
For the lowest-cost meal options at NY Pizza Pie, visit the dedicated NY Pizza Pie cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $2.99.

Is NY Pizza Pie good value for money?
NY Pizza Pie holds a customer rating of 4/5 based on 156 reviews. To judge value more accurately, compare NY Pizza Pie side-by-side with similar restaurants: NY Pizza Pie vs Pizza Hut or NY Pizza Pie vs Domino's Pizza.

How does NY Pizza Pie compare to similar restaurants nearby?
NY Pizza Pie serves pizza cuisine alongside similar restaurants like Pizza Hut, Domino's Pizza, Sunset. Use our comparison pages to see a direct price-by-price breakdown: NY Pizza Pie vs Pizza Hut, NY Pizza Pie vs Domino's Pizza.