Mixed greens tossed in our creamy house parmesan dressing and fresh shaved parmesan cheese topped with housemade croutons. Add ham or chicken $3.00, grilled shrimp for $6.00
$7
0
Garden Salad
A large salad of lettuce, tomato, onion, and green pepper topped with shredded cheddar cheese, served with your choice of dressing house parmesan, bleu cheese, ranch, citrus vinaigrette. Topped with
$7
0
Asian Chopped Salad
Shredded romaine lettuce, cabbage, and brussel sprouts, garnished with fresno chili peppers and carrots tossed in a sweet chili-soy dressing. Add grilled shrimp $6.00, ham or chicken $3.00
Hand breaded chicken tenders served with house ranch or your choice of dipping sauce
$8
0
Chicken Wings
Eight crispy fried wings, tossed in your choice of sauce. BBQ, garlic parmesan, thai chili, buffalo, jerk or Habanero listed in the order of increasing heat. Served with housemade ranch and celery st
$8
0
Puffer Fish Fingers
Fried strips of flaky white fish not a real puffer fish dipped in our famous coconut rum batter and japanese bread crumbs served with pina colada sauce
$8
0
Caribbean Chick on a Stick
Grilled chicken skewers that have been marinated in caribbean spices, served with orange ginger dipping sauce
$8
0
All Thai'd Up Squealer
Grilled strips of pork tenderloin that have been marinated in pineapple curry served with spiced mango mayo.
$8
0
Saba Rocks
You can get them at the nautifish or in the BVI. We're a lot closer. Five decadent deep fried sausage balls stuffed with cheddar cheese, served with melted cheese sauce and a side of chips & salsa
$8
0
Son of a Sailor Nachos
Double decker nachos topped with shredded jerk chicken, aged cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, jalapenos, fresh cilantro and sour cream. Need more heat. A sprinkle of ghost pepper cheese and ha
$8
0
Boneless Wings
Fried chicken bites tossed in your choice of sauce and served with house ranch and celery sticks
$8
0
Shock Top Onion Rings
A basket of our beer battered onion rings served with a side of ranch
Lightly seasoned jerk chicken, topped with melted swiss cheese and house slaw, served on a toasted hoagie with spiced mango mayo. No lettuce, pickle or onion. Add bacon $2.00, add grilled peppers $0.
$9
0
Nauti Patty Melt
1/2 lb. burger, grilled on dark rye bread and topped with swiss cheese and grilled onions. Served with pickles, but no lettuce or tomatoes
$9
0
Hot Mess Ham & Cheese
Piles of hot ham covered in melted aged cheddar cheese sauce served on a toasted hoagie roll. Lettuce, onion, pickles or tomato not on this one
$9
0
Nauti Fish Po'Boy
A huge fish sandwich. Fried fish on a toasted sourdough roll served with jalapeno lime tartar sauce, our house slaw, tomato, onion and pickles
$10
0
Hog Wild Tenderloin
Always a lake favorite. A big as your head, hand-breaded pork tenderloin served on a soft kaiser roll. Finish it with the big o ring buffalo, BBQ, thai chili, garlic parm, or habenaro. Get your porke
$10
0
Cubano Burger
1/2 lb. burger topped with a mound of ham, swiss cheese, pickles and spicy mustard grilled on dark rye bread. Served with pickles, but no lettuce, onion or tomato
$10
0
Chicken Parmesan
Shredded chicken covered in marina sauce and melted mozzarella and parmesan cheeses topped with fresh basil on a soft hoagie roll. Lettuce, onion, pickles or tomato not on this one. Add sauteed mushr
$10
0
All Nighter
Huge 1/2 lb. burger, topped with 2 strips of bacon, cheddar cheese, and an over easy fried egg
$11
0
Black Hog Burger
Juicy, hand pattied 1/2 lb. hamburger topped with 2 slices of bacon, a pile of ham and a thick slice of smoked gouda cheese
$12
0
Troublemaker
Full 1/2 lb. burger, topped with our bacon onion jam then crowned with a battered and fried thick slice of smoked gouda cheese
$12
0
BBQ Chicken
Shredded chicken topped with BBQ sauce, 2 strips of bacon and a mound of beer battered onion rings. Served on a toasted hoagie roll
$12
0
Hot Twins
Not one you'll soon forget. Swiss cheese sandwiched between 2 1/4 burgers, sandwiched between 2 cheese sandwiches grilled with ghost pepper cheese. No lettuce, tomato, pickle or onion
This is not your ordinary bar food. We take aged, smoked gouda cheese, batter it in our shock top beer batter and then fry it until crispy on the outside and hot and gooie on the inside. Served with
$10
0
Cruzan Coconut Rum Shrimp
Our famous housemade coconut rum shrimp served with eat with a spoon pina colada sauce
$10
0
Calamari
Hand breaded salt & pepper calamari served with fresh lemon and parsley served with a sweet chili sauce
$12
0
Island Combo Platter
Your trip starts in hawaii with puffer fish fingers, next stop fiji for thai pork skewers tihen off to jost van dyke for saba rocks, set sail to jamaica mon for caribbean chick on a stick, and home t
Beer battered fish served pub style with malt vinegar and seasoned fries
$11
0
Broaster Fried Chicken
4 pieces of our juicy broasted chicken, served with bread and 1 side
$11
0
Nautifish Dinner
Your choice of grilled, sauteed or fried fish fillet served with toasted bread and your choice of 2 sides
$13
0
Caribbean Grilled Chicken
A grilled, marinated chicken breast topped with mango salsa served with your choice of 2 sides. Add a second breast for $2.00
$13
0
Glazed Pork Medallions
A marinated pork tenderloin grilled and finished with pineapple curry glaze. Served with a choice of 2 sides
$15
0
Nautigump Shrimp
A trifecta of shrimp grilled, beer battered and coconut rum shrimp paired with our house sauces pina colada and sweet thai chili. Served with a choice of 2 sides
$20
0
Ribeye
12 oz ribeye steak, grilled to your liking served with roasted garlic toast and your choice of 2 sides
$22
0
Grilled or Fried Seafood Platter
Grilled and blackened fish filet, served with 3 grilled garlic shrimp with sauteed calamari. Served with a choice of 2 sides
A healthy veggie option, delish. Roasted garlic braised in white wine, sauteed with fresh kale served over lemon pasta topped with fresh parmesan cheese. Served with toasted bread
$11
0
Lemon Pepper Chicken with Mushrooms
Chicken and mushrooms dressed in a white wine sauce seasoned with lemon, pepper and fresh ginger served over pasta. Comes with toasted garlic bread
$12
0
Pollo Allo Parmesano
A fresh breaded chicken breast topped with melted mozzarella and shaved fresh parmesan cheese. Served on top of spaghetti with classic marinara sauce with roasted garlic toast
$13
0
Island Seafood Scamp
Shrimp and calamari sauteed with mushrooms, onions and roasted garlic, served over pasta with a white wine cream sauce. Comes with garlic toast
Toppings: italian sausage, pepperoni, bacon, ham, chicken, hamburger, shrimp, mushrooms, onion, bacon, onion jam, green peppers, tomato, jalapenos, shredded lettuce, olives. Meat topping $1.50, veggi
$14
0
Hot N Ready Pizza
Order a hot and ready pepperoni or cheese pizza for only. This is our traditional thin crust pizza, the only thing different you just go to the front of the line
$15
0
Buffalo Chicken
Pizza loaded with chicken, buffalo sauce and cheddar cheese drizzled with ranch
$18
0
BBQ Chicken
Sweet and spicy BBQ sauce topped with chicken and melted cheddar cheese served with a side of our house slaw
$18
0
Bob's Black Hog
A meat-lovers dream! Pilled high with ham, bacon, pepperoni, Italian sausage, with mozzarella and parmesan cheeses
$19
0
Nautifish Shrimp
Pizza topped with roasted garlic sauteed shrimp, mushrooms, bacon, onion jam and smoked gouda and parmesan cheeses
$19
0
Kitchensink Pizza
This one is amazing. We start with a black hog pizza and then add mushrooms, onion, green peppers, olives and another layer of cheese
$22
0
About Nautifish Rum Bar
Nautifish Rum Bar offers Desserts, Furry Friends Menu & Sides across 63 menu items, with prices from $1.00 to $23.00. Browse the full Nautifish Rum Bar menu with current prices — budget picks like the $1.00 Ice Cream Sandwiches and Popsicles — updated September 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.
Nautifish Rum Bar Menu: Frequently Asked Questions
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the Nautifish Rum Bar menu?
Nautifish Rum Bar offers 63 menu items across Other and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does Nautifish Rum Bar food cost?
Menu prices at Nautifish Rum Bar range from $1.00 for the most affordable options up to $23.00 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Nautifish Rum Bar cheapest items guide.
What are the cheapest items at Nautifish Rum Bar?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Nautifish Rum Bar, visit the dedicated Nautifish Rum Bar cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $1.00.
