presented in a sugared martini glass with appropriate gami
$2.95
0
Sanders Hot Fudge Sundae
a Michigan classic with two scoops of vanilla bean ice cream, sanders hot fudge, whipped cream & caramel drizzle
$4.25
0
The "Original" Sanders Hot Fudge Cream Puff
with a double scoop of vanilla bean ice cream between a pate' choux pastry shell, smothered with sanders hot fudge, a dollop of whipped cream & a maraschino cherry
$4.75
0
Lucy's Fudge Brownie
presented warm with chocolate & vanilla bean ice cream's sanders hot fudge, whipped cream & caramel drizzle
$4.75
0
Betty's Boston Cream Pie
featuring featuring french pastry cream between yellow chiffon, coasted with chocolate ganache & set in a pool of vanilla bean sauce, with a garnish of fresh seasonal berries
$4.95
0
Bavarian Style Cheese Cake
with the motschall's raspberry chambord sauce & a pirouette cookie
$5.95
0
Tiramisu,
featuring yellow chiffon soaked with espresso syrup, layered with mascarpone cheese, dusted with cocoa & presented over vanilla bean sauce
Classic Cesar Salad with Chargrilled Chicken Breast
$2.25
0
Classic Caesar Salad with Jumbo Shrimp
$4.25
0
Classic Caesar Salad with Chargrilled Salmon
$4.25
0
Classic Caesar Salad
with torn romaine hearts, seasoned croutons & shredded parmesan cheese, tossed in our house recipe caesar dressing
$7.5
0
Lucy's "Original" Michigan Chicken Salad
featuring tender diced chicken, celery sundried traverse city cherries & toasted walnuts in a seasoned honey mayonnaise, over select baby greens with a garnish of sweet potato gaufrettes
$10.5
0
Cobb Salad
with rows of diced chicken, crumbled bacon, tomato, chopped egg, cucumber, blue cheese & guacamole, presented over baby greens
$10.5
0
Pecan Crusted Chicken Breast
presented over mesclun greens with sundried cranberries, crumbled gorgonzola, golden pineapple salsa & slivered red onion, served with a side of raspberry vinaigrette
$10.95
0
Sesame Crusted Chicken Strips
served warm over baby greens with feta cheese, fresh roasted beets, calamata olives, roma tomato cucumber & slivered Bermuda onion, with a side of oregano scented vinaigrette
$10.95
0
Atlantic Salmon Filet
coated with our chef's house made pastrami spices, presented over mesclun greens with fresh buffalo mozzarella, roasted sweet peppers, toasted pinenuts, roma tomato, cucumber, calamata olives & red o
featuring a half-pound of fresh ground beef, served on a toasted sesame seen bun with lettuce, tomato & Bermuda onion: sauteed onions, mushrooms, bacon or cheese available for an additional .50 each
$4.95
0
Classic Club Sandwich
with smoked turkey, ham, cheese, crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayonnaise on toasted marble rye bread
$7.95
0
Stacked Vegetarian Sandwich
of sauteed sweet peppers, broccoli florets, zucchini, yellow squash, wild mushrooms, beef steak tomatoes & melted provolone cheese on grilled pita bread, garnished with steamed julienne vegetables, s
$7.95
0
Reuben
on grilled marble rye, with steamed corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss cheese and a side of Thousand Island
$7.95
0
Albacore Tuna Salad
presented on a light flaky croissant with leaf lettuce & tomato or substitute our michigan chicken salad upon request
$7.95
0
Smoked Turkey Lavash
with bacon, melted brie cheese, baby greens & sliced tomato, wrapped in spinach & tomato flat bread with habanero mayonnaise
$7.95
0
Italian Muffaletta
featuring ham, mortadella, sandwich pepperoni & provolone, served warm on herb ciabatta bread with shredded lettuce, sliced tomato & our chef's olive spread
$8.75
0
Herbed Focaccia Sandwich
with chargrilled chicken breast, house roasted peppers, fresh buffalo mozzarella, tender baby greens, plum tomato & roasted garlic basil mayonnaise
$8.75
0
Charred Atlantic Salmon
finished with honey mustard glaze, served on a lightly toasted kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato & Bermuda onion
$8.95
0
Vegetarian Portobella Mushroom "Steak"
marinated & grilled over an open fire, served on a kaiser roll with caramelized onion, tomato and a gratin of smoked mozzarella & parmesan cheese, crowned with jullienne vegetables and served with a
$8.95
0
Crunchy Fried Michigan Lake Perch
served on a toasted kaiser roll with baby greens, sliced tomato & key lime mustard remoulade sauce
with jack Daniel's barbecue & ranch sauces for dipping
$7.75
0
Artichoke Florentine Casserole
featuring artichoke hearts, baby spinach, garlic and cheddar cheese, set with a gratin of parmesan cheese, presented with crostini
$8.5
0
Quesadilla
of southwest chicken or beef, grilled between flour tortillas with scallion, tomatoes and a blend of cheeses, presented with pico de gallo & sour cream
$8.5
0
Blue Corn Chips
layered with aged cheddar, monterey jack, tomatoes, scallions & ripe olives, oven baked with a choice of southwest chicken or beef, served with fresh tomato salsa & sour cream
$8.95
0
Meze Platter
featuring our house made hummus, tabouleh, fresh roasted beets, calamata olives, feta cheese & tomato caprese, with warm pita bread
$9.75
0
Lucy's Tender Fried Calamari
presented with two sauces, marinara & lemon chive beurre blanc, garnished with capers and diced roma tomato
$9.95
0
Prince Edward Island Mussels
steamed in white wine with shallots, garlic, chorizo, brunoise sweet peppers, tomatoes and basil in a saffron infused cream
$10.75
0
Crispy Coconut Crusted Jumbo Shrimp
accompanied by black bean com pancakes, sherried wild mushrooms, golden pineapple mango salsa & sweet potato gaufrettes, accented with basil and chili oil's
$11.95
0
House Cured Atlantic Salmon Carpaccio
cold smoked with a Meyer's dark rum & brown sugar glaze, accompanied with capers, diced egg, slivered Bermuda onion, salmon cream cheese & garlic crostini
featuring our traditional meatloaf, baked in a puffy pastry crust, presented with cabernet brown sauce
$10.75
0
Traditional Fish & Chips
with snow white alaskan cod, fried in our fuller's London Ale beer batter, served with tartar sauce, lemon and malt vinegar upon request
$11.5
0
Stir Fry
of tender chicken, bokchoy, nappa, snow peas, peppers, carrot and mushrooms in a sauce of minced ginger, garlic toasted sesame, sherry & soy, presented over rice and crowned with fried wontons
$11.5
0
Atlantic Salmon Filet
seasoned and broiled to perfection, painted with our honey soy syrup
$15.95
0
Medallions of Herb Marinaded Porkloin
grilled over an open fire and presented with potato farmer cheese pierogi, braised red cabbage, michigan apple & dried cherry compote, with sour cream and chive brown sauce
$15.95
0
Basil Pesto Marinaded Chicken Breast
chargrilled & presented over mafaldine pasta tossed with sundried tomatoes, portobella mushrooms and toasted pinenuts in a sauce of vodka, roasted garlic, reggiano & a touch of cream
$15.95
0
Chicken Tosca
featuring boneless chicken sauteed in parmesan lemon egg batter accompanied by wild mushroom risotto, along with sauteed baby spinach, tomato & garlic, finished with a rich madeira glace
$16.5
0
Maryland Style Jonah Crab Cakes
sauteed to a golden brown and presented over imperial sauce with sweet peppers, scallions, shallots, sherry & a touch of cream
$16.95
0
Twice Cooked Barbecued Duck
painted with Jack Daniel's barbecue sauce, accompanied with aromatic wehani rice braised with shiitake mushrooms, sundried tomatoes and fresh basil, garnished with julienne vegetables
$16.95
0
Ravioli
filled with a three cheese blend, presented with marinara sauce & parmesan, bechamel drizzle, crowned with chargrilled jumbo shrimp, garnished with crumbled chevre, toasted pinenuts & house roasted p
$17.5
0
Michigan Yellow Belly Lake Perch
pan fried with artichoke hearts, tomato, capers, and fresh snipped chives in lemon beurre blanc
$17.75
0
Pan Seared Unsoaked Sea Scallops & Jumbo Shrimp
with hand rolled pasta, sweet peppers, tomato, wild mushrooms, and lemon zest, accented with balsamic syrup basil and chili oils
$18.95
0
Valenciana Style Paella
featuring jumbo shrimp, sea scallops mussels, chicken chorizo, haricot vert, artichoke, tomato & calasparras rice in a saffron infused broth
$19.5
0
Chargrilled Filet Mignon
featuring our hand trimmed specially seasoned beef tenderloin, finished with red wine jus lie and frizzled onions can be cooked to order
$19.95
0
Sirloin Strip Steak
coated with our chef's unique cracked peppercorn and aromatic spice blend, grilled over an open fire, finished with red wine jus lie and frizzled onions can be cooked to order
$19.95
0
About Lucy's Tavern On The Hill
Lucy's Tavern On The Hill serves Desserts, Entree Alternatives Soups & Entree Alternatives Specialty Salads across 63 menu items, with prices from $2.25 to $19.95. See the full Lucy's Tavern On The Hill menu with current prices — budget picks like the $0.95 The Hill's "Smallest" Sundae — updated September 2026.
Lucy's Tavern On The Hill Menu: Frequently Asked Questions
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the Lucy's Tavern On The Hill menu?
Lucy's Tavern On The Hill offers 63 menu items across Other and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does Lucy's Tavern On The Hill food cost?
Menu prices at Lucy's Tavern On The Hill range from $2.25 for the most affordable options up to $19.95 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Lucy's Tavern On The Hill cheapest items guide.
What are the cheapest items at Lucy's Tavern On The Hill?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Lucy's Tavern On The Hill, visit the dedicated Lucy's Tavern On The Hill cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $2.25.
Is Lucy's Tavern On The Hill good value for money?