gosling's black seal rum, cock & bull ginger beer, fresh lime
0
Hth 43
beverly's version of an old french champagne drink
$6
0
Tipsy Tea
a vodka spiked peach tea
$6
0
Advertisment
specialty drinks $6
2 items
Hth 43
beverly's version of an old french champagne drink
0
Tipsy Tea
a vodka spiked peach tea
0
our brews
6 items
Hefewestern
a true to style german hefeweizen featuring a light and refreshing body with pleasant banana and clove notes.
0
Annexation Ale
an american style ipa with a pine and citrus hop profile and medium copper body. strong, bold and hoppy.
0
Kitchen Sink Pale Ale
american pale ale, born out of friendship and humor. collage of hops from around the world blended with a copper colored malt profile and a touch of rye.
0
Roscoe Red Ale
a strong amber colored ale named as homage to our beloved late boxer, roscoe. toffee and caramel sweetness with hop undertones of fruit, spice and earth.
0
773 Stout
an easy drinking dry stout served on nitro giving it a creamy mouthfeel. malt notes of cocoa, coffee, and chocolate.
0
18th Rebellion Ale
kolsch style ale carefully fermented to be light and crisp. noble hop additions provide balance to the golden malt profile.
made with fresh romaine, egg, thick cut bacon, red onion, grilled marinated chicken breast, organic blue cheese, tomato
$9.99
0
Pulled Pork
½ lb dry-rubbed pork shoulder, smoked 8 hours, hand pulled. gluten free
$9.99
0
Links
house recipe pork sausage link smoked 2 hours and grilled
$9.99
0
BBQ Chicken
½ fresh brined chicken, dry rubbed, smoked 4 hours.
$10.49
0
Southwest Chicken Salad
chipotle-marinated grilled chicken breast, cilantro, avocado, black beans, fire roasted corn, tomato, tortilla strips. gluten free
$10.99
0
Spinach Salad
fresh baby spinach, goat cheese, pickled red onion, grilled chicken, bacon and balsamic vinegar
$10.99
0
Ribs
½ rack or full rack of dry-rubbed baby backs
$10.99
0
Flat Iron Steak
10oz flat iron steak grilled to request. served with choice of two sides
$15.99
0
Combination Platter
¼ lb pulled pork, ¼ chicken, links and ¼ rack of ribs
$16.99
0
guest taps
6 items
Red Streak Cider
a true english draft cider with a crisp tart fish and atouch of oak. 5.2 abv
$5
0
Saugatuck Bonfire Brown
american brown ale with chocolate, biscuit and buttery flavors with a hint of smoke.
$5.5
0
Saugatuck Hop On A Blonde
american craft beer with soft malt flavor and aroma that has had the daylights hopped out of it!
$5.5
0
Deschutes Chainbreaker White IPA
brewed with wheat and pilsner malt; this wipa displays beautiful citrus aromas from cascade and citra hops that meld with the esters of belgian yeast
$5.5
0
Arcadia Sky High Rye
west coast pale ale brewed with 80% english barley malt and 20% rye malt. massive floral aromas, notes of lemon, peach, and pine needles anchored by a sweet malty flavor of toffee.
$5.5
0
Peche Mel'scaldis
belgium- natural peach extract balances out this high octane amber. refreshing, highly carbonated, and refined
$8.5
0
appetizers
7 items
House Made Spent Grain Pretzels
served with roasted poblano queso
$5.99
0
Smothered Goat Cheese
goat cheese with basil and oregano marinara, with garlic french bread
$7.49
0
Jumbo Chicken Wings
choose one of three sauces: buffalo, o'learys hot or teriyaki. served with celery and blue cheese dressing
$7.99
0
Buffalo Caprese
buffalo mozzarella, heriloom tomato, basil, reduced balsamic and evoo
$7.99
0
Charleston Crab Cakes
jumbo lump blue crab with sweet bell pepper relish
$9.99
0
Buffalo Fried Shrimp
elwoods ipa based hot sauce. served with celery and blue cheese dressing.
$9.99
0
North Woods Charcuterie Plate
an assortment of meats and cheeses limited only by our imagination.
$11.99
0
dessert
6 items
773 Stout Semi-Freddo
gelato-style frozen treat with honey, chocolate, and spent grains.
$5.99
0
Upside Down Carmel Banana Cake
bananas, walnuts, and a cinnamon caramel sauce
$5.99
0
Jimmy Jam's Sweet Potato Pie
honey cream top
$5.99
0
Citrus Tiramisu
house made lady fingers with orange mousse and white chocolate.
$5.99
0
Triple Chocolate Flourless Cake
$6.49
0
8 Layer Coconut Cake
coconut rum glazed cake with a coconut cream filling
$6.49
0
specialty dish
4 items
House Made Spent Grain Pretzels
served with roasted poblano queso
$5.99
0
Pulled Pork
½ lb of hand pulled pork on brioche roll. choice of sauces
$8.99
0
Grass Fed
lb hand-formed 90/10 7 sons, roanoke, in.
$10.99
0
North Woods Charcuterie Plate
an assortment of meats and cheeses limited only by our imagination.
$11.99
0
white wine
5 items
St. Julien "Blue Heron" - Paw Paw, Michigan
sweet wine with flavors of pear and mango
$6
0
King Estate "Acrobat"
pinot gris - oregon. with flavors of honeydew, grapefruit and golden delicious apples
$7
0
New Harbor Sauvignon Blanc
new zealand. crisp finish with enticing flavors of citrus, passion-fruit and guava
$7
0
Dark Horse Chardonnay
paso robles, california. rich flavors of baked apple and pear, layered with toasted oak notes of caramel and brown spice
$7
0
Kendall-Jackson Vintner's Reserve Chardonnay
sonoma county, california. classic california chardonnay with lively citrus, nectarine and tangerine flavors and a hint of toasted oak
$10
0
red wine
5 items
Little Black Dress Pinot Noir
hopland, california. light red wine with a lingering finish of strawberry jam and pomegranate
$7
0
Chalone Monteray Merlot
central coast, california. full-bodied wine with juicy black cherry and spicy clove flavors
$7
0
Santa Carolina Carmenere Riserva
chile. deep ruby and purple wine with a nose of black cherry, tobacco and oak. great with bbq
$7
0
Alta Vista Classic Malbec
mendoza, argentina. medium-bodied with ripe red-fruit flavors
$8
0
Louis M. Martini Cabernet Sauvignon
sonoma county, california. dense red wine with fresh red plum and blackberry jam aromas and flavors
$9
0
soups & salad
6 items
Old Man Tom's Gumbo
made with gulf shrimp, blue crab, clams, house made andouille
Horse Thief Hollow features Grilled Flat Bread Pizza $9.99, Weekly Specials & Children'S Menu $5 across 117 menu items, with prices from $0.99 to $16.99. Explore the full Horse Thief Hollow menu with current prices — budget picks like the $0.99 Corn Bread — updated July 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.
Suggestions are reviewed before they show publicly. Thanks for keeping deals fresh!
Reviewed before any change is made. Thanks for keeping menus accurate!
Spotted wrong info, or want this page updated or removed?
Contact us →
Opens your email app to [email protected] — we attach this page's link so we can reply faster.
Horse Thief Hollow Menu — Frequently Asked Questions
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the Horse Thief Hollow menu?
Horse Thief Hollow offers 117 menu items across gastropub and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does Horse Thief Hollow food cost?
Menu prices at Horse Thief Hollow range from $0.99 for the most affordable options up to $16.99 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Horse Thief Hollow cheapest items guide.
What are the cheapest items at Horse Thief Hollow?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Horse Thief Hollow, visit the dedicated Horse Thief Hollow cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $0.99.
How does Horse Thief Hollow compare to similar restaurants nearby?
Horse Thief Hollow serves gastropub cuisine alongside similar restaurants like LINK, Post Office, Frontier. Use our comparison pages to see a direct price-by-price breakdown: Horse Thief Hollow vs LINK, Horse Thief Hollow vs Post Office.