A filet of mahi-mahi, brushed with honey, crusted with pecans, deglazed with chardonnay, key west sunset sauce, rice & vegetable garnish
0
Fish of the Day
Your server would love to tell you todays fish selection, how it is best prepared and the sauces you can choose from. Gluten free
0
Filet Mignon
Aged beef tenderloin cooked to perfection, served with mashed potatoes & vegetable garnish. Gluten free
0
Crusted Chicken Romano
Parmesan and romano crusted chicken breast with minced garlic and a creamy marinara over penne pasta
$15.95
0
Creamy Chicken Picatta
Tender chicken breasts dipped in egg and pan sauteed with our own white sauce, capers, mushrooms, garlic, green onion and shallots. Served with mashed potatoes and vegetable
$15.95
0
Broccolini
Grilled chicken breast, penne pasta & fresh broccoli in a creamy parmesan sauce
$15.95
0
Three Cheese Pasta
Penne pasta with marinara sauce, parmesan, mozzarella & ricotta cheeses & garlic with fresh basil
$15.95
0
Cuban Pork
Slow roasted pork with our house marinade, served with traditional rice and beans with fried plantains
$16.95
0
Baha Fish Tacos
Deep fried, select fish served in a warm flour tortilla with chili cream, mixed cheese, onion, bahamian coleslaw, mandarin oranges & topped with crispy corn strips, cilantro & served with rice, beans
$17.95
0
Beef Brisket dinner
Slow roasted, pulled beef brisket served with pan gravy, mashed potatoes and broccoli
$17.95
0
Mixed Grill
Sauteed scallops and shrimp topped with a lime cilantro sauce, served with rice & vegetable garnish. Gluten free
$22.95
0
Smokey Joes Ribs
Slow roasted baby back pork ribs with sweet & smoky BBQ Sauce, mashed potatoes, onion strings & cole slaw
Cucumbers, tomatoes, carrots & croutons, atop a mix of fresh lettuces. Gluten free
$5.95
0
Caesar Salad
Romaine hearts, parmesan, croutons & romano cheese
$7.95
0
Chinese Chicken Salad
Crispy chicken with sesame sauce, wontons, rice sticks, almonds, green onions, mandarin oranges & a blend of lettuces, tossed in carolines asian vinaigrette
$10.95
0
Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken Breast
Romaine hearts, parmesan, croutons & romano cheese
$10.95
0
Santa Fe Chicken Salad
Diced chicken breast, romaine hearts, roasted corn, black beans, tomatoes, cheddar & jack cheeses with tortilla strips & our own lime cilantro dressing
$10.95
0
Cobb Salad
Romaine hearts, crispy bacon crumbles, hard cooked eggs, diced tomatoes, grilled chicken breast, crumbled blue cheese & house made balsamic vinaigrette
$10.95
0
Fogartys Chopped Salad
Grilled mahi-mahi and shrimp with romaine hearts, mangos, cucumber, tomato, almonds & hearts of palm, tossed with balsamic vinaigrette.
$13.95
0
Caesar Salad with Blackened Mahi-Mahi Filet or Gulf Shrimp
Romaine hearts, parmesan, croutons & romano cheese
$13.95
0
Ahi Salad
Sesame crusted yellow fin tuna cooked rare with diced tomatoes & cucumbers, served over a bed of mixed organic greens & our own balsamic vinaigrette
Key west classic with bahamian conch & island spices
$6.95
0
Peel & Eat Shrimp
Steamed shrimp, chilled & served with our tangy cocktail sauce & lemon.
$6.95
0
Quesadilla
Grilled flour tortillas with melted cheese, grilled onions, green peppers & jalapenos. Served with salsa & sour cream. Add shrimp $4.00 or chicken $3.00
$6.95
0
Fish Bites
Select fresh fish fried golden brown, served with tartar sauce
$7.95
0
Bruschetta
Grilled baguette topped with chopped roma tomatoes, garlic, basil, olive oil, fresh mozzarella & a balsamic vinegar glaze.
$7.95
0
Tex-Mex Rolls
Chili dusted grilled chicken, roasted corn, black beans, cilantro, peppers, onions, jalapenos & cheddar & jack cheeses in a golden brown egg roll
$8.95
0
Sliders
3 Mini burgers with grilled onions & pickles
$8.95
0
Buffalo Chicken Tenders
Boneless chicken strips, dipped in hot cayenne pepper sauce served with celery & bleu cheese
$8.95
0
Lettuce Wraps
Grilled satay chicken, carrots, cucumber salad, coconut curry noodles & thai dipping sauces. Roll it up in crisp, fresh boston lettuce leaves & enjoy. Gluten free
$9.95
0
Key West Crab Cakes
Lump blue crab cakes fried golden brown & served with our special remoulade sauce
$11.95
0
Peppered Ahi Tuna
Rare ahi tuna rolled in fresh cracked black peppercorns, served with spicy red chili soy & wasabi.
$11.95
0
Taste of Key West
Assortment of fish bites, conch fritters & fried shrimp
Fogarty's offers Entrees, Non-Alcoholic Beverages & Homemade Side Dishes across 72 menu items, with prices from $2.00 to $24.95. Browse the full Fogarty's menu with current prices — budget picks like the $2.00 Iced Tea — updated September 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the Fogarty's menu?
Fogarty's offers 72 menu items across Other and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does Fogarty's food cost?
Menu prices at Fogarty's range from $2.00 for the most affordable options up to $24.95 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Fogarty's cheapest items guide.
What are the cheapest items at Fogarty's?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Fogarty's, visit the dedicated Fogarty's cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $2.00.
Is Fogarty's good value for money?
Fogarty's holds a customer rating of 4/5 based on 163 reviews. To judge value more accurately, compare Fogarty's side-by-side with similar restaurants: Fogarty's vs Honey Baked Ham or Fogarty's vs Winebar.
How does Fogarty's compare to similar restaurants nearby?
Fogarty's serves Other cuisine alongside similar restaurants like Honey Baked Ham, Winebar, Go Puff. Use our comparison pages to see a direct price-by-price breakdown: Fogarty's vs Honey Baked Ham, Fogarty's vs Winebar.
