All beef patty grilled and topped with your choice of American cheese, pepper jack or cheddar cheese. Served with fries or house salad.
$4
0
Chicago Style Footlong Hot Dog
All beef footlong topped with mustard, onion, tomatoes and relish. Served with fries or house salad.
$5
0
Italian Sausage Sandwich
Our homemade sausage served on French bread with sweet peppers and au jus with fries or house salad.
$6.5
0
Italian Meatball Sandwich
Our homemade delicious meatballs served on French bread covered with marinara. Served with fries or house salad.
$6.5
0
Veggie Quesadillas
Grilled flour tortilla topped with cheese, red pepper, mushrooms and onions with side of guacamole and salsa. Served with fries or house salad.
$6.5
0
Grilled Classico Panini
Fresh sliced roasted turkey, bacon, provolone cheese, tomatoes and avocado. Served with fries or house salad.
$7
0
Grilled Italiano Panini
Genoa salami, imported mortadella, ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions and Italian dressing. Served with fries or house salad.
$7
0
Turkey Avocado Club
Sliced turkey breast and avocado topped with bacon, lettuce and tomato on wheat bread. Served with fries or house salad.
$7
0
Tuna Melt
White albacore tuna salad topped with cheddar cheese served on wheat bread with fries or house salad.
$7
0
Italian Gyro Sandwich Platter
Our homemade sausage thinly sliced and served over pita and topped with onion, tomatoes and our own Italian tzatziki sauce. Served with fries or house salad.
$7.25
0
Grilled Tuscan Panini
A grilled boneless chicken breast, provolone cheese, roasted red peppers, artichoke hearts, tomatoes and basil pesto mayo. Served with fries or house salad.
$7.5
0
The Combo Sandwich
Traditional Italian sausage and sliced beef with sweet peppers. Served with fries or house salad.
$7.5
0
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Tender slow smoked hand-pulled pork in our Tennessee spices tossed in apple bourbon BBQ topped with cheddar jack cheese, served on a specialty roll with fries or house salad.
$7.5
0
Fatty Magoo Burger
Our juicy 1/2 lb. burger with grilled onion, bacon bits and American cheese, drizzled with bleu cheese dressing. Served with fries or house salad.
$8
0
All American Burger
Our juicy 1/2 lb. burger served with American cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion.
$8
0
Magoo's Special Beef Sandwich
Oven baked and served open face with peppers, grilled onions, mozzarella and marinara on the side with fries or house salad.
$8
0
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Skinless chicken breast breaded and tossed in our Buffalo sauce topped with pepper jack cheese served on French bread with fries or house salad.
$8
0
Blackened Chicken Sandwich
Cajun chicken breast, pepper jack cheese, avocado and lime mayo. Served with fries or house salad.
$8
0
Chicken BLT Ranch Wrap
Cubed grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce and tomato drizzled with ranch dressing in a flour tortilla. Served with fries or house salad.
$8
0
Steak Sandwich
Premium steak served with mushroom and onion straws with fries or house salad.
Your choice of three chicken, steak, ground beef or fish tacos in a flour tortilla topped with pico de gallo. With tortilla chips and salsa. Served with soup or house salad.
$6
0
Tacos Platter
Your choice of three chicken, steak, ground beef or fish tacos in a flour tortilla topped with pico de gallo. With side of rice and beans. Served with soup or house salad.
$8
0
Jumbo Butterfly Shrimp Dinner
Breaded shrimp served with fries and soup or house salad.
$11
0
Chicago Joe's Chicken
Baked boneless chicken breast lightly breaded and topped with fresh bruschetta and served over fettuccine tossed in extra virgin olive oil with soup or house salad.
$11.5
0
Chicken Vesuvio
Sauteed garlic, white wine sauce and spices served with potato wedges, soup or house salad.
$11.5
0
The Parmigiana
Tender chicken breast lightly breaded served with side of mostaccioli marinara with soup or house salad.
$12
0
Healthy Magoo Platter
Caprese salad, choice of sauteed broccoli or spinach and two plain or blackened chicken breast.
Served with your choice of one of our specialty sauces. Mounds of giant wings, cooked to perfection and smothered in the sauce of your choice. Approximately seven to 10 wings per lb.
$8
0
Chicken Tenders with Side
Regular or Buffalo. Six of our home-made juicy chicken tenders covered with our seasoned breading and served with your favorite sauce with fries or house salad.
$8.99
0
Award Winning Wings with 2 Flavors
Served with your choice of two of our specialty sauces. Mounds of giant wings, cooked to perfection and smothered in the sauce of your choice. Approximately seven to 10 wings per lb.
Your choice of spaghetti, angel hair, linguine or mostaccioli, tossed in bolognese or marinara.
$8
0
Ravioli
Meat, cheese or spinach filled and topped with marinara.
$9
0
Vodka Pasta
Rigatoni in a garlic cream and tomato sauce flavored with vodka.
$10
0
Baked Sausage Paisano
Rigatoni in our signature vodka sauce with homemade Italian sausage and mushrooms covered with mozzarella cheese.
$12
0
About Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery
Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery serves Salads And Soups, Desserts & Appetizers across 76 menu items, with prices from $3.00 to $14.00. See the full Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery menu with current prices — budget picks like the $3.00 Minestrone Soup — updated September 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.
Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery Menu: Frequently Asked Questions
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery menu?
Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery offers 76 menu items across Other and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery food cost?
Menu prices at Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery range from $3.00 for the most affordable options up to $14.00 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery cheapest items guide.
What are the cheapest items at Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery, visit the dedicated Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $3.00.
Is Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery good value for money?
