Home Cheapest Items My Pie Pizzeria Cheapest Items

Budget Dining Guide

My Pie Pizzeria Cheapest Menu Items & Affordable Meal Options

Looking for affordable food at My Pie Pizzeria? This budget guide lists every menu item sorted from lowest to highest price so you can find cheap eats and low-cost meal deals quickly. Prices updated August 2026.

Lowest Price

$0.50

Average Item Price

$7.37

Budget for Two

$14.74

Priced Items Tracked

42

Top 3 Most Affordable Picks

#1 Extra Dressing $0.50
#2 Smoothie $0.50
#3 Caesar Dressing $0.75

My Pie Pizzeria Menu Items Ranked by Price — Cheapest to Most Expensive

Every affordable menu item at My Pie Pizzeria sorted from lowest to highest price

Full menu →
# Menu Item Category Portion Price
1 Extra Dressing dressings — $0.50
2 Smoothie add-ons omega-3 protein shot add $0.50
3 Caesar Dressing dressings — $0.75
4 Smoothie add-ons with ice cream or frozen yogurt add $0.75
5 Any Additional Ingredient* thin crust — $1.65
6 Chocolate Chip Cookies desserts — $1.75
7 Any Additional Ingredient* deep dish — $1.80
8 Dinner Salad salads & stuff with chicken breast add $2.45
9 Brownies desserts — $2.50
10 Spicy Garlic Bread salads & stuff our open-faced cheesy garlic bread with a spice to it $2.50
11 1/2 Pint soup — $2.95
12 Cheese pizza slices — $3.25
13 Dinner Salad salads & stuff combination of seasonal fresh greens topped with carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes, croutons, and your choice of dressing. $3.25
14 Pepperoni pizza slices — $3.25
15 Sausage pizza slices — $3.25
16 Slice Of The Day* pizza slices — $3.25
17 Cheesecake desserts 30 year old family recipe $3.95
18 My Pie Mozzarella Garlic Bread salads & stuff baked with creamy whipped butter, fresh garlic, and stuffed with mozzarella cheese. $3.95
19 Pint soup — $4.95
20 1 - Strawberry, Banana, & Juice * real fruit smoothies — $5.25
21 5. Peach, Banana, & Juice* real fruit smoothies — $5.25
22 6. Mango, Banana, & Juice* real fruit smoothies — $5.25
23 Caesar Salad salads & stuff fresh greens with croutons and a traditional homemade caesar dressing. $5.50
24 2. Strawberry, Blueberry, & Juice real fruit smoothies — $6.00
25 3. Strawberry, Raspberry, & Juice* real fruit smoothies — $6.00
26 4. Blueberry, Banana, & Juice* real fruit smoothies — $6.00
27 Caesar Salad salads & stuff with chicken breast $7.95
28 Chef’s Salad salads & stuff roasted turkey, kretschmar’s hickory smoked ham, cheddar cheese, cucumbers, tomatoes & hard-boiled eggs on a bed of lettuce with your choice of dressing. $7.95
29 Cobb Salad salads & stuff tomatoes, chicken breast, eggs, blue cheese, & bacon on bed of fresh greens with your choice of dressing. $7.95
30 Mandarin Orange Salad salads & stuff fresh greens, mandarin oranges, mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions, blue cheese & walnuts, served with our homemade mandarin orange vinaigrette. $7.95

My Pie Pizzeria Budget Breakdown — Average Cost per Menu Category

Find the most affordable My Pie Pizzeria food category to save money on your next order

dressings

$0.63

2 items

add-ons

$0.63

2 items

desserts

$2.73

3 items

pizza slices

$3.25

4 items

soup

$5.28

3 items

salads & stuff

$5.49

9 items

Similar Binge-Worthy Restaurants

More value-menu alternatives if you like My Pie Pizzeria

See all →
C

Catania Cafe

coffee
S

Sunset

burger
L

Lexington Pizza Parlour

italian
Pizza Hut

Pizza Hut

pizza
S

Speck's Deli & Gourmet Pizza

pizza
Domino's Pizza

Domino's Pizza

pizza

Frequently Asked Questions About My Pie Pizzeria Prices

Common questions about menu prices, budget meals, and affordable dining options.

What is the cheapest item on the My Pie Pizzeria menu?
The most affordable item at My Pie Pizzeria is Extra Dressing priced at $0.50. This is one of the lowest-cost menu options available, making it a great budget-friendly pick for cost-conscious diners.

How much does it cost to eat at My Pie Pizzeria on a budget?
The average menu item at My Pie Pizzeria costs about $7.37. For two people dining on a budget, you can expect to spend approximately $14.74 by choosing affordable options. Look at the lowest-priced items for the best value meals.

How many low-cost menu items does My Pie Pizzeria have?
My Pie Pizzeria currently has 42 menu items with tracked prices. Out of these, we list the 30 most affordable options sorted from lowest to highest price to help you find cheap eats quickly.

Are My Pie Pizzeria prices updated regularly?
Yes. Our My Pie Pizzeria menu price data is continuously tracked and updated. This page reflects the most recent pricing as of August 2026. Restaurant prices may vary by location, so use these as general reference prices for budget planning.

Which My Pie Pizzeria menu category has the cheapest prices?
The most budget-friendly category at My Pie Pizzeria is dressings with an average price of $0.63 across 2 items. This category offers the best value if you are looking for affordable dining options and low-cost meals.

Smart Ways to Save Money at My Pie Pizzeria — Budget Dining Tips

Finding affordable meals at My Pie Pizzeria doesn't mean you have to sacrifice quality. Our curated low-cost menu guide helps you discover the cheapest food options, budget-friendly combo deals, and best value items available on the current menu.

Prices shown are tracked from official menu sources and updated regularly. Whether you're a student looking for cheap eats, a family dining on a budget, or simply trying to keep meal costs down, sorting by price is the fastest way to find great value at My Pie Pizzeria.

Compare My Pie Pizzeria prices with similar restaurants using our comparison tool to see which offers better value for your money. You can also check the full My Pie Pizzeria menu for the complete listing including premium items. For nutrition-focused decisions, review the cheapest item calories at My Pie Pizzeria and compare low-calorie menu options before ordering.