Budget Dining Guide
Mahoney's Cheapest Menu Items & Affordable Meal Options
Looking for affordable food at Mahoney's? This budget guide lists every menu item sorted from lowest to highest price so you can find cheap eats and low-cost meal deals quickly. Prices updated July 2026.
Lowest Price
$2.50
Average Item Price
$7.03
Budget for Two
$14.06
Priced Items Tracked
30
Top 3 Most Affordable Picks
Mahoney's Menu Items Ranked by Price — Cheapest to Most Expensive
Every affordable menu item at Mahoney's sorted from lowest to highest price
| # | Menu Item | Category | Portion | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cheddar & Ale Soup | appetizers | — | $2.50 |
| 2 | Homemade Soup Of The Day | appetizers | — | $2.50 |
| 3 | Basket Of Fries | appetizers | deep fried until golden brown | $3.95 |
| 4 | Beer Battered Onion Rings | appetizers | served with creole mayonnaise | $3.95 |
| 5 | Hearty Homemade Chili | appetizers | served with melted cheddar, chopped onions & nacho chips | $3.95 |
| 6 | Breaded Mozzarella Sticks | appetizers | served with marinara sauce | $5.95 |
| 7 | Potato Skins | appetizers | stuffed with cheddar cheese & crispy bacon served with sour cream | $5.95 |
| 8 | Hudson Valley Nachos Supreme | appetizers | nachos smothered with chili, cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, jalapeno, peppers, black olives & served with sour cream | $6.50 |
| 9 | Buffalo Wings | appetizers | tossed in our homemade "buffalo" sauce served with bleu cheese & celery sticks | $6.95 |
| 10 | Chicken Tenders | appetizers | served with your choice of honey mustard, bbq horseradish or buffalo sauce | $6.95 |
| 11 | Potato Skins | appetizers | with our homemade chili & cheese | $6.95 |
| 12 | Small Cheese Pizza | pizza | each topping above $4.75 - $0.50 on half pie. extra cheese, chicken or bacon $1.50, $0.75 on half pie | $7.00 |
| 13 | Hamburger | burgers | — | $7.50 |
| 14 | Cheese Burger | burgers | choice of american, swiss, cheddar or provolone | $7.95 |
| 15 | Chicken Caesar Roll-Up | wraps | grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, black olives, parmesan cheese & caesar dressing | $7.95 |
| 16 | Mahoney's Chicken Bacon Sensation | sandwiches | grilled chicken breast with bacon, swiss, muenster and cheddar cheese with honey mustard sauce served on a french baguette | $7.95 |
| 17 | McReuben | sandwiches | the finest of corned beef grilled with sauerkraut, swiss cheese & russian dressing served on grilled marble rye | $7.95 |
| 18 | Mozzarella & Red Peppers | wraps | fresh mozzarella & roasted red peppers with spinach & drizzled roasted garlic and balsamic vinaigrette | $7.95 |
| 19 | Oven Roasted Turkey Breast | wraps | thin sliced turkey breast accompanied by tomatoes & green leaf lettuce with a cranberry orange relish | $7.95 |
| 20 | Philly Cheese Steak | sandwiches | thin sliced sirloin grilled with mushrooms, onions & peppers on a club roll with melted cheese | $7.95 |
| 21 | Poughkeepsie Grilled Chicken Express | sandwiches | grilled chicken breast topped with tomato and mozzarella with a roasted garlic & balsamic vinaigrette served on a french baguette | $7.95 |
| 22 | Red Fox Fried Fresh Fish Filet | sandwiches | a generous portion of fresh scrod, batter fried & served on a kaiser roll | $7.95 |
| 23 | Shaved Roast Beef | wraps | thin sliced roast beef with tomatoes & fresh spinach with a horseradish sauce | $7.95 |
| 24 | Turkey Club | sandwiches | triple decker with thin sliced fresh turkey, lettuce, tomato, bacon & cheese served on your choice of bread | $7.95 |
| 25 | Chili Burger | burgers | smothered with our hearty homemade chili | $8.50 |
| 26 | Mahoney's Celtic Burger | burgers | topped with irish bacon and sharp irish cheddar cheese | $8.50 |
| 27 | Marist Burger | burgers | topped with grilled ham and cheddar | $8.50 |
| 28 | Vassar Veggie Burger | burgers | veggie burger with mushrooms, onions & your choice of cheese | $8.50 |
| 29 | Maria Sampler | appetizers | buffalo wings, chicken tenders, potato skins, mozzarella sticks & served with an assortment of dipping sauces | $8.95 |
| 30 | Large Cheese Pizza | pizza | each topping above $1.25 $0.75 on half pie, extra cheese, chicken or bacon $2.50 - $1.25 on half pie | $10.00 |
Mahoney's Budget Breakdown — Average Cost per Menu Category
Find the most affordable Mahoney's food category to save money on your next order
appetizers
$5.42
12 items
wraps
$7.95
4 items
sandwiches
$7.95
6 items
burgers
$8.24
6 items
pizza
$8.50
2 items
Similar Binge-Worthy Restaurants
More value-menu alternatives if you like Mahoney's
Frequently Asked Questions About Mahoney's Prices
Common questions about menu prices, budget meals, and affordable dining options.
What is the cheapest item on the Mahoney's menu?
How much does it cost to eat at Mahoney's on a budget?
How many low-cost menu items does Mahoney's have?
Are Mahoney's prices updated regularly?
Which Mahoney's menu category has the cheapest prices?
Smart Ways to Save Money at Mahoney's — Budget Dining Tips
Finding affordable meals at Mahoney's doesn't mean you have to sacrifice quality. Our curated low-cost menu guide helps you discover the cheapest food options, budget-friendly combo deals, and best value items available on the current menu.
Prices shown are tracked from official menu sources and updated regularly. Whether you're a student looking for cheap eats, a family dining on a budget, or simply trying to keep meal costs down, sorting by price is the fastest way to find great value at Mahoney's.
Compare Mahoney's prices with similar restaurants using our comparison tool to see which offers better value for your money. You can also check the full Mahoney's menu for the complete listing including premium items. For nutrition-focused decisions, review the cheapest item calories at Mahoney's and compare low-calorie menu options before ordering.