Buffalo Gap Saloon menu

Pizza By The Slice

Luu Luu Pie

Light spread of grandma stutzerelli's sauce, candied hazelnuts, blue cheese crumbles, diced red onion, artichoke hearts, mozzarella and chopped pepperoncini

Pesto Pizza

Our rich pesto sauce and spicy pepperoni with mozzarella and provolone cheeses, topped with fresh tomatoes

Edggie Veggie Pie

Our basic pie smothered with spinach, kalamata olives, mushrooms, red onion, feta cheese, roma tomatoes and no meat to eat, all topped with shaved parmesan cheese

Buffalo Pie

The classic combo piled high with pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, onions, black olives and green peppers

Dakota Chicken Pie

Chopped up bits of grilled chicken breast tossed in gapdaddy's buffalo wing sauce, peppers, onions, and mozzarella. Sprinkled with bleu cheese crumbles and served with a side of bleu cheese dressing

Meat Pie

Sausage, chorizo, canadian bacon, ground beef, pepperoni and three cheeses meat good, cheese good

Pulled Porky Pie

Secret sauce of ancho chipotle and bbq topped with slow roasted shredded pork, peppers, mozzarella & cheddar cheese. Finished with crispy fried onions and scallions

Personal Pizza Combo

Served all day. A 7" round pizza perfect for one person choose any two toppings plus a soup or salad

Selection Topping

Meat: Italian sausage, canadian bacon, ground beef, meat balls, chicken, extra cheese, bleu cheese, pesto, pepperoni or chorizo. Medium: $1.75 each large: $2.25 each

Build Your Own Pie

Fish & Chips - Halibut Fish & Chips

A generous portion of our beer battered fish served with cole slaw, fries and homemade tartar sauce. Choose your fish: Cod or Halibut, 2 pc, 3 pc, 4 pc

Winner Chicken Dinner

You know who you are, this staff favorite named after one of our regulars beals meals is simple a grilled chicken breast, steamed veggies and infused rice pilaf. Choice of soup or salad

Fish & Chips - Cod Fish & Chips (2 Pieces)

A generous portion of our beer battered fish served with cole slaw, fries and homemade tartar sauce. Choose your fish: Cod or Halibut

Fish & Chips - Cod Fish & Chips (3 Pieces)

A generous portion of our beer battered fish served with cole slaw, fries and homemade tartar sauce. Choose your fish: Cod or Halibut

Great Plains Goulash

Just like mom made only totally different, cavitappi pasta with ground beef, cheese, sweet corn, onions, diced tomatoes and garlic tossed in an herbacious brown gravy. Served with corn bread. Choice

St. Louis Style Ribs (Half Rack)

St. louis style ribs slow cooked in our black hills BBQ sauce & finished off on our open flame grill. Served with cole slaw and sweet potato fries

Grandy's Meatloaf Platter

Grandy's favorite secret recipe meat loaf cut thick just the way she likes it a testament to the charms of a simple table. Served with sweet potato mash, gravy, sauteed veggies and choice of soup or

Fish & Chips - Cod Fish & Chips (4 Pieces)

A generous portion of our beer battered fish served with cole slaw, fries and homemade tartar sauce. Choose your fish: Cod or Halibut

Flat Iron Skewers

Four thinly sliced flat iron steak skewers marinated in T roy's secret marinade it's sweet, spicy, gluten free, almost paleo, & may or may not be made from unicorns & rainbows. Chargrilled and served

Honey Lime Prawn Platter

Three shrimp skewers marinated in a sweet and spicy sauce grilled to perfection and topped with grilled orange lime salsa. Served over sweet potato mash and a paleo salad to start

Fried Oysters

Pacific NW oysters lightly breaded and seasoned, pan fried in light butter and served with cole slaw and fries

Buffaloganoff

A richly flavored offering of buffalo steak and onion, slow simmered in their own gravy, combined with mushrooms, a little sherry and sour cream, ladled over wide egg noodles. Thick, soothing and utt

Cowboy Steak Platter

A tender 8 oz top sirloin filet, hand rubbed with our own coffee and spice blend, flame broiled as you like it, smothered with crisp haystack onions and a dollop of chipotle butter. Served with sweet

Paleo Steak and Egg

8 oz Top sirloin seasoned with sea salt and pepper, grilled and served over seasonal veggies and sweet potato mash. Topped off with two over medium eggs, and avocado. Served with a paleo salad

St. Louis Style Ribs (Full Rack)

St. louis style ribs slow cooked in our black hills BBQ sauce & finished off on our open flame grill. Served with cole slaw and sweet potato fries

Fish Fry Friday

It's not just for lent anymore. A huge captains platter with 2pc cod, 3pc fried shrimp, clamstrips, house fries and house made slaw. Served with lemon, tartar and cocktail sauce

Taco Salad

A crispy tortilla shell filled to the brim with lettuce, seasoned ground beef, taco chicken or grilled chicken, zesty black beans, cheddar cheese, tomatoes, olives, sour cream, and green onions. Serv

Jumbo Sweet & Spicy Prawn Caesar - Classic Caesar (no Meat)

Romaine lettuce tossed in our classic caesar dressing and homemade croutons, sprinkled with shaved parmesan cheese, and topped with six jumbo skewered tiger prawns dripping with honey lime marinade

Kibbey's Wedge

A thick wedge cut of fresh iceburg lettuce topped with chopped pepper bacon, tomato and house made blue cheese dressing

Taco Salad

A crispy tortilla shell filled to the brim with lettuce, seasoned ground beef, taco chicken or grilled chicken, zesty black beans, cheddar cheese, tomatoes, olives, sour cream, and green onions. Serv

The Candied Hazelnut

Fresh cut apples, grilled chicken, bleu cheese crumbles, mixed greens, red onion, balsamic vinaigrette, eat it up cause it's a really good salad salad

Our Way Cobb Salad

We do the work for you and toss a perfect mix of chopped greens, bacon, egg, red onion and bleu cheese crumbles with an Italian bleu cheese dressing topped with grilled chicken and a tomato garnish

Cowboy Chop Salad

Hand chopped iceberg and romaine lettuce tossed in a BBQ style ranch dressing with tomato, corn, zesty black beans and topped with diced BBQ chicken breast, crispy fried onions and fresh cilantro

Jumbo Sweet & Spicy Prawn Caesar

Romaine lettuce tossed in our classic caesar dressing and homemade croutons, sprinkled with shaved parmesan cheese, and topped with six jumbo skewered tiger prawns dripping with honey lime marinade

Jumbo Sweet & Spicy Prawn Caesar - Grilled Chicken Caesar

Romaine lettuce tossed in our classic caesar dressing and homemade croutons, sprinkled with shaved parmesan cheese, and topped with six jumbo skewered tiger prawns dripping with honey lime marinade

Jumbo Sweet & Spicy Prawn Caesar - Pesto Chicken Caesar

Romaine lettuce tossed in our classic caesar dressing and homemade croutons, sprinkled with shaved parmesan cheese, and topped with six jumbo skewered tiger prawns dripping with honey lime marinade

Jumbo Sweet & Spicy Prawn Caesar - Blackened Salmon Caesar (4oz)

Romaine lettuce tossed in our classic caesar dressing and homemade croutons, sprinkled with shaved parmesan cheese, and topped with six jumbo skewered tiger prawns dripping with honey lime marinade

Blackened Wild Salmon Paleo Salad (4 oz)

Grilled and blackened Salmon topped with orange lime salsa serced over a bed of field greens with tomatoes, onions and oranges

Jumbo Sweet & Spicy Prawn Caesar - Steak Caesar (8 oz)

Romaine lettuce tossed in our classic caesar dressing and homemade croutons, sprinkled with shaved parmesan cheese, and topped with six jumbo skewered tiger prawns dripping with honey lime marinade

Blackened Wild Salmon Paleo Salad (8 oz)

Grilled and blackened Salmon topped with orange lime salsa serced over a bed of field greens with tomatoes, onions and oranges

Paleo Salad

Field greens with cucumbers, tomatoes, lemon wedges and sunflower seeds

Mixed Green Salad (Small)

Mixed greens, cucumbers, olives, tomatoes, shredded cheese and sunflower seeds

Soup of Day

Mixed Green Salad (Large)

Mixed greens, cucumbers, olives, tomatoes, shredded cheese and sunflower seeds

Badlands Chili

Our all meat chili with 27 herbs & spices topped with shredded cheddar and onions. A true classic & proud favorite each order comes with our home made corn bread

Soup & Salad Combo

Cup of soup and large mixed green salad

Reverse Combo

Bowl of soup and small mixed green salad

Penny’s Gigantic Cinnamon Roll

Mmm, good add bacon surprise a loved one take one home

Chocolate Fix

A rich double fudge brownie cake filled with just the right amount of walnuts then topped with chocolate syrup and fresh hand made vanilla whip cream

Bourbon Bread Pudding

Fresh crusty sourdough baked with sweet coconut custard and pecans then topped with bourbon butter sour cream and fresh hand made vanilla whip cream

Old Fashioned Carrot Cake

A huge homemade triple layer spiced carrot cake with fresh cream cheese frosting. Great for sharing

Fresh Fried Potato Chips

House Fries

Waffle Fries (w/ Ranch)

Tater Tots (w/ Ranch)

Sweet Potato Fries

Mozzarella Cheese Stix

Hunky chunks of fried mozzarella cheese. Served with marinara

Honey Lime Prawn Skewers

Two shrimp skewers marinated in a sweet and spicy sauce grilled to perfection and topped with grilled orange salsa

Chipotle Cheese Quesadilla

A blend of three cheeses with peppers, onions, lettuce, lou's roasted salsa and topped off with chipotle pepper sauce and cilantro sour cream sauce. Add bbq pork, taco beef, chicken, or jumbo honey l

Six Shooters

Fresh pacific nw oyster shooters served ice cold in our zesty cocktail sauce. Single: $1.50

Spinach & Artichoke Dip

Served with tri colored tortilla chips

Hummus Plate

Freshly made hummus served with toasted naan, roasted garlic, feta cheese, kalamata olives, celery, cucumbers, carrot sticks and pepperoncinis

Chix-Tenders & Fries (Chicken Fingers)

The classic. A very lightly breaded chicken tenderloin. Served with fries and ranch dressing

Onion Rings

World famous, hand made, BIG and deelicious

Loaded Potato Skins

Halved russet potato skins stuffed with bacon, cheddar, olives, tomatoes, green onions and served with sour cream

Mt. Rushmore Nachos

Fresh fried tortilla chips piled high, smothered with 3 cheeses, olives, tomatoes, green onions, black beans, sour cream and a side of house made salsa. Add beef, chicken or chili: $3.50

Clam Strips

Succulent battered sea clams served with tartar and cocktail sauce. Add fries: $2.50

Fried Brie

Mini wheel of herb crusted danish brie, served with crostini, fresh apples, roasted garlic, grapes, and candied walnuts

The Man Platter

Up for a challenge if you can finish this platter then you are the man this appetizer feeds 4 or more it includes a mt. rushmore nacho, 3 lbs of buffalo wings, house made onion rings, tater tots, and

PBLT

Pepper bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo on toasted sourdough. Nuff' said. Add avocado: $1.99

Fish San

Beer battered cod with our homemade tartar sauce, lettuce, tomatoes and onions on a toasted kaiser roll

Kobe Beef Sliders

Three snake river ranch kobe beef sliders topped with pepper bacon, brie cheese and garlic mayo. Served with your choice of soup, salad or fries

Grilled Mac n Cheese Sand

Grilled sourdough stuffed with mac n cheese, pepperjack, and pepper bacon. Served with your choice of soup, salad, or fries. Pair it with tomato basil soup every wednesday

Meatloaf Sandwich

Grandy's old fashioned meatloaf thickly sliced with lettuce, tomatoes and mayonnaise served hot or cold on sourdough

Edggie Veggie Hummwich

This no cow sandwich is crammed with hummus, tomatoes, cucumbers, mushrooms, roasted red peppers, onions, spinach, feta, italian vinaigrette and melted swiss cheese on toasted dark rye

Slow Roasted Pork Sando

Slow cooked and tangy, our own BBQ pork and house made cole slaw are piled high atop a toasted kaiser roll. Extra napkins may be necessary

Beef Au Jus

Thinly sliced roast beef piled high on a french baguette with grilled onions, swiss cheese and a side of au jus for dippin

Wild Billy Cheese Steak

Grilled roast beef, sauteed onions and peppers, italian dressing and provolone cheese on a french roll

Beef & Bleu

An old favorite with a new twist sliced roast beef, our special bleu cheese spread, lettuce and tomatoes on lightly grilled artisan rosemary bread

Lamb Gyro

Thinly sliced lamb, shredded lettuce, onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, feta, tzatziki sauce and pepperoncinis. Choice of side. Double meat: $3.50

Taco Bar

3 Corn tortillas gluten free stuffed with your choice of filling choose one: Slow roasted pork, taco chicken, seasoned beef, beer battered cod, tofu & zesty black beans or for an extra $1.00, select

Turkey Club

Pepper bacon, turkey, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, 1000 island and mayo on a kaiser roll

The Reuben

Our world famous double decker with corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss cheese and our secret reuben sauce on dark rye

Steak Sandwich

A juicy 8 oz top sirloin filet charbroiled any way you like it on a toasted french baguette topped with lettuce, tomato and cowboy onions

Paleo Pork Tacos

Four lettuce tacos mounded with slow roasted pulled pork loaded with napa cabbage, diced tomatoes, black olives, and fresh avocado. Finished with sunflower seeds, fresh cilantro & side of lou's salsa

No Bone

Densely breaded chicken breast fritters

Buffalo Wings

1 lb of Our famous jumbo wings

Scrimps

Six large deep fried shrimp

All American

Lettuce, tomato, onion, and goop with choice of cheese: Cheddar, swiss, pepper jack, mozzarella or philly swiss

Dakota

Buffalo wing sauce and bleu cheese crumbles

Cowboy

Smothered with haystack onions, melted pepperjack and our black hills BBQ sauce

Mediterranean

Tzatziki sauce, lettuce, tomato, feta cheese, pepperoncinis and cucumbers

Hot Diggity Damn

Sirachi aioli, sauteed onions & diced jalapenos in more hot sauce, pepperjack & cool. I mean cole slaw

Mushroom Swiss

All American mushroom and swiss please

Pesto Marinara

Pepperoni, pesto, marinara swiss cheese, fire roasted bell peppers, fresh spinach, tomato & onion

Black Hills BBQ

Grilled onions and peppers, cheddar cheese, BBQ sauce and avocado

Harvest

Avocado, cucumbers, chopped spinach, onion, tomato, pepperjack and ancho chile chipotle sauce

Bacon & Bleu

Pepper bacon & bleu cheese sauce

Garlic on Garlic

roasted garlic, sauteed onion, rosemary garlic aioli & shaved parmesan. Bring your own tic tacs

Peanut Buddy

Peanut butter, bacon, pickles, goop & cheddar enough said

Badlands Chili

Served open face with mounds of our world famous all meat chili. Onions upon request. Cheese extra

Reuben Melt

With corned beef, sauerkraut, 1,000 & swiss

The Mule

Two of our signature 1/2 lb patties topped with canadian bacon, cheese of your choice, goop and a fried egg 10.99

Pesto Chicken Mac

Grilled Chicken Mac

Chili Mac

Bacon & Chorizo Mac

Shrimp & Chorizo Mac

Blackened Salmon Mac

Buffaloganoff & Cheese

Paleo Options