Try our crunchy, gluten-free, pizzelles (Flat Cones) ! Our scoopista team handcrafts the best crunchy pizzelles... a perfect accompaniment for any gelato! You can also make a little gelato sandwich u
$3.95
0
Bucket & Bay Vanilla (6 oz)
Bucket & Bay Vanilla is made with the full vanilla bean (not a vanilla extract). The gelato is aged with the vanilla for at least 24 hours to infuse all the flavors in the gelato. Smooth and floral,
$5.95
0
Deep Dark Chocolate (6 oz)
DEEP DARK CHOCOLATE (raaka 71% virgin chocolate from Dominican Republic and Boivia). Unroasted, stoneground cocoa beans present a totally unique flavor profile. It is deep dark raw but not bitter! W
$5.95
0
Mint Chip Classic (6oz)
MINT CHIP This gelato has some truly loyal fans. It delivers a blast of freshness, with a creamy texture and elegantly drizzled chocolate chip. Not to be missed. (100% grass-fed milk + organic pepp
$5.95
0
Rose Latte Gelato (6 oz)
Rose Latte. Elegant! The interplay between the highest grade dry rose petals & 100% grass-fed milk elevates this unique flavor. Travelling through China years ago, we shared a pot of rose petal tea
$5.95
0
BLACK LABEL Vanilla (6 oz)
BLACK LABEL VANILLA (alcohol infused) {johnny walker black + vanilla). We start with our amazing100% grass-fed milk, and real Madagascar vanilla beans (you can see the beans as dots in your gelato!)
$5.95
0
Bourbon Peach (6 oz)
BOURBON PEACH (alcohol infused) (bourbon + fresh peaches) Evoking the comfort of the warm summer nights down south. The interplay between the fresh peaches, spices, and Bulleit Bourbon is decadent!1
$5.95
0
Mix: Deep Dark Chocolate + BLACK LABEL Vanilla (6 oz)
A mix of Two Flavors!
\nBLACK LABEL VANILLA (alcohol infused) {johnny walker black + vanilla). We start with our amazing 100% grass-fed milk, and real Madagascar vanilla beans (you can see the
$5.95
0
Mix: Deep Dark Chocolate + Mint Chip (6 oz)
A mix of Two Flavors!
\n
\nDEEP DARK CHOCOLATE (raaka 71% virgin chocolate from Dominican Republic and Boivia). Unroasted, stoneground cocoa beans present a totally unique flavor profile.
$5.95
0
Mix: Deep Dark Chocolate + Rose Latte (6 oz)
A mix of Two Flavors!
\n
\nDEEP DARK CHOCOLATE (raaka 71% virgin chocolate from Dominican Republic and Boivia). Unroasted, stoneground cocoa beans present a totally unique flavor profile.
$5.95
0
Mix: Bucket & Bay Vanilla + Rose Latte (6 oz)
A mix of Two Flavors!
\n
\nBUCKET & BAY VANILLA is made with the full vanilla bean (not a vanila extract). The gelato is aged with the vanilla for at least 24 hours to infuse all the flavo
$5.95
0
Bucket & Bay Vanilla (PINT)
Bucket & Bay Vanilla is made with the full vanilla bean (not a vanilla extract). The gelato is aged with the vanilla for at least 24 hours to infuse all the flavors in the gelato. Smooth and floral,
$13
0
Deep Dark Chocolate (PINT)
DEEP DARK CHOCOLATE (raaka 71% virgin chocolate from Dominican Republic and Boivia). Unroasted, stoneground cocoa beans present a totally unique flavor profile. It is deep dark raw but not bitter! W
$13
0
Mint Chip Classic (PINT)
This gelato has some truly loyal fans. It delivers a blast of freshness, with a creamy texture and elegantly drizzled chocolate chip. Not to be missed. (100% grass-fed milk + organic peppermint esse
$13
0
Rose Latte Gelato (PINT)
Rose Latte. Elegant! The interplay between the highest grade dry rose petals & 100% grass-fed milk elevates this unique flavor. Travelling through China years ago, we shared a pot of rose petal tea
$13
0
RedEye (coffee) (PINT)
REDEYE (cold brew coffee + espresso caramel) This coffee flavor is stunning! We make a very rich tasting gelato with a unique cold-brew coffee by local Jersey City high end coffee roaster modcup. An
$13
0
Toasted Coconuts (PINT)
Toasted Coconuts - Taste the island life with this cool flavor! House-roased coconuts provide an unbeatable depth and long finish to the fresh aroma of coconuts.
\n
$13
0
Hazelnut (PINT)
Hazelnut - House-roasted hazelnuts, ground and infused in 100% grass-fed milk. This gelato has a nice nutty aroma, reminiscent of Nutella, but more real. Decadent. For a golden combo, mix it with ou
$13
0
PSR - Purple Sticky Rice (PINT)
Purple Sticky Rice - Comfort Food Re-invented. We start with forbidden rice, which we boil in our 100% Grass-fed milk, and then we age it overnight. A touch of lemon grass at the end, provides a nic
$13
0
BLACK LABEL Vanilla (PINT)
BLACK LABEL Vanilla (PINT)
\n
\n
\nBLACK LABEL VANILLA (alcohol infused) {johnny walker black + vanilla). We start with our amazing100% grass-fed milk, and real Madagascar vanilla bean
$13
0
Bourbon Peach (PINT)
BOURBON PEACH (alcohol infused) (bourbon + fresh peaches) Evoking the comfort of the warm summer nights down south. The interplay between the fresh peaches, spices, and Bulleit Bourbon is decadent!1
$13
0
Shavasana - Blueberry Lavender (PINT)
SHAVASANA (blueberry lavender) - The beautiful floral aroma of the lavender, infused in 100% grass-fed milk, gets a nice fresh finish from the
\nblueberries. Unforgettable!
$13
0
About Bucket & Bay Craft Gelato Co
Bucket & Bay Craft Gelato Co serves Gelato across 22 menu items, with prices from $3.95 to $13.00. See the full Bucket & Bay Craft Gelato Co menu with current prices — budget picks like the $3.95 Flat Cones = Gluten-free Pizzelles (x5) — updated September 2026. Rated 4.0/5 by diners.
Bucket & Bay Craft Gelato Co Menu: Frequently Asked Questions
Common
questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.
What is on the Bucket & Bay Craft Gelato Co menu?
Bucket & Bay Craft Gelato Co offers 22 menu items across Other and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.
How much does Bucket & Bay Craft Gelato Co food cost?
Menu prices at Bucket & Bay Craft Gelato Co range from $3.95 for the most affordable options up to $13.00 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the Bucket & Bay Craft Gelato Co cheapest items guide.
What are the cheapest items at Bucket & Bay Craft Gelato Co?
For the lowest-cost meal options at Bucket & Bay Craft Gelato Co, visit the dedicated Bucket & Bay Craft Gelato Co cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $3.95.
Is Bucket & Bay Craft Gelato Co good value for money?
