Skip to content
A

All Star Bagel Bayville menu

3.0118 ratings

Prices, calorie guide, and order-online options in one place

42 items $1.25 to $6.99 bagels Add photos
Coupons Order

Advertisements

Prices may vary. Please confirm at the restaurant before ordering.

bagels

9 items

Bagel

$0.9
0

Bagel with Butter

$1.79
0

Bagel with Butter and Jelly

$1.99
0

Bagel with Cream Cheese

$1.99
0

Bagel with Peanut Butter

$1.99
0

Bagel with Peanut Butter and Jelly

$2.1
0

Bagel with Cream Cheese and Jelly

$2.1
0

Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese

$2.69
0

Bagel with Cream Cheese and Lox

$6.99
0

side dishes

4 items

Hashbrown

$1.25
0

Sausage Patty

$1.5
0

4 Slices of Bacon

$2
0

3 Slices of Porkroll

$2
0

Advertisements

drinks

2 items

Coffee

$1.29
0

Fountain Soda

$1.39
0

breakfast sandwiches

6 items

2 Eggs Sandwich

$2.25
0

2 Eggs and Cheese Sandwich

$2.75
0

Egg Whites Sandwich

$2.99
0

Meat Sandwich

$3.45
0

Egg Whites and Cheese Sandwich

$3.69
0

Meat and Cheese Sandwich

$3.99
0

Advertisements

lunch sandwiches

11 items

Pizza Bagel Sandwich

$2.89
0

BLT Sandwich

$4.95
0

Ham and Cheese Sandwich

$5.25
0

Chicken Salad Sandwich

$5.25
0

Tuna Salad Sandwich

$5.25
0

Cheesesteak Sandwich

$5.25
0

Cheesesteak Special Sandwich

$5.45
0

Turkey and Cheese Sandwich

$5.5
0

Roast Beef and Cheese Sandwich

$5.75
0

Pastrami and Cheese Sandwich

$5.75
0

Italian Sandwich

Ham, salami and provolone.

$5.75
0

Advertisements

breakfast special

1 item

The Triple Threat Breakfast Special

Cheddar bagel with 1 sausage patty, 2 eggs and 2 slices of cheddar.

$5.25
0

breakfast platters

1 item

Build Your Own Omelette Platter

3 Eggs.

$5.75
0

Advertisements

lunch special

1 item

The Travis Pastrami Lunch Special

Hot pastrami and Swiss on choice of bagel or hard roll with onions and spicy mustard.

$5.99
0

About All Star Bagel Bayville

All Star Bagel Bayville serves Bagels, Side Dishes & Drinks across 42 menu items, with prices from $1.25 to $6.99. See the full All Star Bagel Bayville menu with current prices — budget picks like the $0.90 Bagel — updated September 2026.

Categories: bagels

Reviews & Photos

From people who've eaten at All Star Bagel Bayville

3 ★

118 reviews

Rate & review

Reviews are checked before they appear. Be honest & kind.

No reviews yet. Be the first to review All Star Bagel Bayville.

Help keep this page accurate

Wrong info, feedback, or want this page updated or removed? Contact us →

Opens your email app to [email protected]. We attach this page's link so we can reply faster.

Add a photo of All Star Bagel Bayville

Photos are reviewed before they appear.

Drag & drop a photo here

or click to browse

Suggest a Correction

All Star Bagel Bayville menu

Reviewed before any change is made. Thanks for keeping menus accurate!

Similar Binge-Worthy Restaurants

More budget-friendly fast food and value menu alternatives to All Star Bagel Bayville

See all →
Long Island Bagel Cafe

Long Island Bagel Cafe

coffee · Binge-worthy picks

Own All Star Bagel Bayville?

Claim it to update prices & details, post offers, and get a verified ✓ badge guests trust.

Free while we're in beta. Later a one-time $99 lifetime, then monthly plans. Early claims stay free.

Claim this restaurant →

All Star Bagel Bayville Menu: Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about the menu, pricing, and dining options.

What is on the All Star Bagel Bayville menu?
All Star Bagel Bayville offers 42 menu items across bagels and other categories. Browse the full menu above to see everything available, including portion sizes and category breakdowns.

How much does All Star Bagel Bayville food cost?
Menu prices at All Star Bagel Bayville range from $1.25 for the most affordable options up to $6.99 for premium items. The full price breakdown is shown in the menu table above. Looking for the cheapest options? Visit the All Star Bagel Bayville cheapest items guide.

What are the cheapest items at All Star Bagel Bayville?
For the lowest-cost meal options at All Star Bagel Bayville, visit the dedicated All Star Bagel Bayville cheapest menu items guide — every item sorted from the lowest to highest price so you can quickly find budget-friendly food starting at just $1.25.

Is All Star Bagel Bayville good value for money?
All Star Bagel Bayville holds a customer rating of 3/5 based on 118 reviews. To judge value more accurately, compare All Star Bagel Bayville side-by-side with similar restaurants: All Star Bagel Bayville vs Long Island Bagel Cafe or All Star Bagel Bayville vs Einstein Bagels.

How does All Star Bagel Bayville compare to similar restaurants nearby?
All Star Bagel Bayville serves bagels cuisine alongside similar restaurants like Long Island Bagel Cafe, Einstein Bagels, Einstein Bros Bagels. Use our comparison pages to see a direct price-by-price breakdown: All Star Bagel Bayville vs Long Island Bagel Cafe, All Star Bagel Bayville vs Einstein Bagels.